Why did Amaral and PJ suspect the McCanns and Murat as being somehow involved?

[Mr Gray]

It is not up to the police to designate/nominate anyone "arguido" - it's the judge from the public ministry. Otherwise certain questions - whose responses might incriminate the respondents - could not be made by the PJ.

This statements supports those who believe that the 48 questions and the reconstruction were being used to incriminate the McCanns rather than help find maddie.

[Luz]

ARGUIDO is a legal status that is conferred to anyone that is questioned during an Inquiry, and when the questions point to facts/occasions/events that may be incriminating to the persons that are going to be questioned.
It's the equivalent to the Miranda act in the US, but even more protective since as "arguido" the person can never be questioned without a legal counselor present.

[John]

We know that Sergey Malinka and Robert Murat spoke on the phone around 11:30 pm on May 3, 2007 - a short time after Madeleine McCann went missing.

Just to let readers know, Malinka's car was later fire-bombed in the street near his apartment and the word "TALK" spray painted on the footpath alongside it.  He has since disappeared.

Read more...

[Mr Gray]

Hopefully once the SY investigation gets underway we will find out why SY do not consider the McCanns suspects in their investigation.

[AnneGuedes]

If from the answers to the 48 a tiny clue had emerged indicating some involvement of the McCanns, then ipso facto the issue "finding Madeleine" had been resolved faute de combattants.

[Luz]

This statements supports those who believe that the 48 questions and the reconstruction were being used to incriminate the McCanns rather than help find maddie.

During an Inquiry/criminal investigation, you are supposed to do everything in order to find the victim - in this case Madeleine McCann. If the parents or any other person had any knowledge about what happened to her, in my opinion, and according to criminal investigation police, every question should be made, everyone should be investigated...

Do you think differently?
Maybe you are more worried with saving the parent's backsides than finding the child... They were.

[Mr Gray]

During an Inquiry/criminal investigation, you are supposed to do everything in order to find the victim - in this case Madeleine McCann. If the parents or any other person had any knowledge about what happened to her, in my opinion, and according to criminal investigation police, every question should be made, everyone should be investigated...

Do you think differently?
Maybe you are more worried with saving the parent's backsides than finding the child... They were.

IMO and a lot of other people the PJ had give up looking for Maddie and were only interested in incriminating her parents, as your post confirms. thank god SY are taking over

[Luz]

I don't want to sound mean, but when a parent that is "supposedly" waiting for a communication from the kidnappers of his child, just sits calmly in the police quarters fooling around the net, discussing baseball and sucking a lollipop while  the police officers were biting their nails in agony....

When a mother protests for being taken at high velocity in a police car to check on a CCTV that might have recorded her child...

The protests of the McApologists do not surprise me anymore.

[Rachel Granada]

I don't want to sound mean, but when a parent that is "supposedly" waiting for a communication from the kidnappers of his child, just sits calmly in the police quarters fooling around the net, discussing baseball and sucking a lollipop while  the police officers were biting their nails in agony....

When a mother protests for being taken at high velocity in a police car to check on a CCTV that might have recorded her child...

The protests of the McApologists do not surprise me anymore.

But we only have Amaral's word for that, Luz.  Personally, I would rather trust the word of Walter Mitty....

[Luz]

IMO and a lot of other people the PJ had give up looking for Maddie and were only interested in incriminating her parents, as your post confirms. thank god SY are taking over

The PJ had investigated thousands of false leads and had requested the same from Interpol and Europol...

Why don't you question the reasons why the McCann always flew away from the most relevant leads?
When something pointed to Portugal, they went to Spain, when in Spain they went to Rome, when in Morocco, they went to Germany....always getting away

[Mr Gray]

I don't want to sound mean, but when a parent that is "supposedly" waiting for a communication from the kidnappers of his child, just sits calmly in the police quarters fooling around the net, discussing baseball and sucking a lollipop while  the police officers were biting their nails in agony....

When a mother protests for being taken at high velocity in a police car to check on a CCTV that might have recorded her child...

The protests of the McApologists do not surprise me anymore.

more and more rubbish posted to blacken the mccanns name. if you read kates account of the high speed car incident you would understand what really happened. Bit like the claim that kate didn't search becacause iot was too cold and dark...pure lies....as redblossom eventually admitted. But these sort of claims are repeated. Fortunately SY will not be listening to such rubbish.

[Mr Gray]

The PJ had investigated thousands of false leads and had requested the same from Interpol and Europol...

Why don't you question the reasons why the McCann always flew away from the most relevant leads?
When something pointed to Portugal, they went to Spain, when in Spain they went to Rome, when in Morocco, they went to Germany....always getting away

i'm sure you beleive this rubbish, but that's all it is ...rubbish

[Mr Gray]

The PJ had investigated thousands of false leads and had requested the same from Interpol and Europol...

Why don't you question the reasons why the McCann always flew away from the most relevant leads?
When something pointed to Portugal, they went to Spain, when in Spain they went to Rome, when in Morocco, they went to Germany....always getting away

Ok, to be fair to you...do you have proof of the above....er no

[Luz]

We know that Sergey Malinka telephoned former suspect in the case Robert Murat on or about 11:30 pm on May 3, 2007 - a short time after Madeleine McCann went missing.

Just to let readers know, Malinka's car was later fire-bombed in the street near his apartment and the word "TALK" spray painted on the footpath alongside it.  He has since disappeared.

Read more...

Malinka was investigated and totally cleared, unlike the McCann. Murat had commercial business with Malinka because this last one worked with computers, and when Murat decided to start his own enterprise he contacted him.

Malinka had had problems because he had dated a 16 year old when he was 18. So he appeared as someone who had had a sexual relationship with a minor. But he was cleared.

[Mr Gray]

Malinka was investigated and totally cleared, unlike the McCann. Murat had commercial business with Malinka because this last one worked with computers, and when Murat decided to start his own enterprise he contacted him.

Malinka had had problems because he had dated a 16 year old when he was 18. So he appeared as someone who had had a sexual relationship with a minor. But he was cleared.

Wrong again. the MCCanns have been investigated portugal ruled there was no evidence of any crime. SY have also ruled them out.