Question is...could three people be so wrong in what they saw?
I have to admit I had no idea about the anonymous call that was saying Mr Murat frequented certain chat rooms, this seems to be information that could only be provided by someone who knew Mr Murat very well or someone close to him asking someone else to make the call. If anything I find this incredible. So much so that I begin to become very suspicious of the caller and their intentions. Especially with hindsight that most, if not all these lurid allegations were thrown out.
To directly answer your question John, it is possible but is it likely? Given any other situation I would say it is highly unlikely for any three people to misidentify someone and it is highly probable that who saw was the person identified.
My problem here is, how much of this was actually first hand witnessing? For example, did just one of them see Mr Murat and then have a conversation with the others and then they believed it was Mr Murat but weren't entirely sure.
I am very cautious about all the initial statements made because it was a highly charged evening, extremely stressful for all those concerned and it is possible that mistakes, unintentional mistakes were made.
Do I think Mr Murat had any involvement with any aspect of Madeleine's case? I don't because apart from a very odd interview he gave post libel proceedings, there is nothing to eve hint he had any hand in things.