The dogs.....

[John]

No two dogs react to the same stimuli since every dog is different.  Victim Recovery and CSI dogs generally detect similar substances but not always.

[Eleanor]

No two dogs react to the same stimuli since every dog is different.  Victim Recovery and CSI dogs generally detect similar substances but not always.

John, I am stunned by your perception.

Time I watched Holby City.  Kicked the dog out.  And then off to bed.  Tomorrow is another day.  Call me Scarlet.
I think I might be having a nervous breakdown due to the stress of it all.

[John]

John, I am stunned by your perception.

Time I watched Holby City.  Kicked the dog out.  And then off to bed.  Tomorrow is another day.  Call me Scarlet.
I think I might be having a nervous breakdown due to the stress of it all.

      chiow

[pegasus]

Not an EVR dog but fantastically skilled:
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/three-year-old-girl-survived-11-days-4036084
In the first eleven days after the apparent disappearance of Madeleine all the following were involved: Blair, Blair, Brown, Milliband, Beckett, Buck, Henderson, Mitchell, Woolfall, IFLG, CR, CEOP, yet what did they actually do to search for a child who could potentially have woke and wandered and still have been alive? NADA. That little unnamed siberian dog beats the lot of them.

[Brietta]

Not an EVR dog but fantastically skilled:
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/three-year-old-girl-survived-11-days-4036084
In the first eleven days after the apparent disappearance of Madeleine all the following were involved: Blair, Blair, Brown, Milliband, Beckett, Buck, Henderson, Mitchell, Woolfall, IFLG, CR, CEOP, yet what did they actually do to search for a child who could potentially have woke and wandered and still have been alive? NADA. That little unnamed siberian dog beats the lot of them.

A beautiful story with a brilliant outcome ... but whys did it take him 11 days to get round to legging it for home to raise the alarm ... bit tardy that?

[pegasus]

A beautiful story with a brilliant outcome ... but whys did it take him 11 days to get round to legging it for home to raise the alarm ... bit tardy that?

My guess is - while the child was able to walk and forage for water and berries, the optimum behaviour for the dog was to stay with the child. If the dog left at that stage, the child would wander, might come to harm, or might not be found when rescuers arrived. Then maybe after 11 days the child became too weak to walk, so now the dog decided the best action in this new situation was to go for help.

[pegasus]

My award for the crumbiest anti-Eddie post ever goes to this masterpiece I found in the comment section of the Eddie cadaver dog video on youtube

" You will note that the dogs in this video did not sit or lie down, this is the normal reaction,
rather they jumped around and barked, this is highly unusual,
and would rarely indicate a cadaver, or anything else but the dogs desire for a biscuit. "

So there you have it folks, Eddie was barking for bourbons,
and Mr Grime and Mr Amaral were barking completely up the wrong rich tea.

[Brietta]

My award for the crumbiest anti-Eddie post ever goes to this masterpiece I found in the comment section of the Eddie cadaver dog video on youtube

" You will note that the dogs in this video did not sit or lie down, this is the normal reaction,
rather they jumped around and barked, this is highly unusual,
and would rarely indicate a cadaver, or anything else but the dogs desire for a biscuit. "

So there you have it folks, Eddie was barking for bourbons,
and Mr Grime and Mr Amaral were barking completely up the wrong rich tea.

Love it.
One of those witty posts you wish you had written.   

[Mr Gray]

My award for the crumbiest anti-Eddie post ever goes to this masterpiece I found in the comment section of the Eddie cadaver dog video on youtube

" You will note that the dogs in this video did not sit or lie down, this is the normal reaction,
rather they jumped around and barked, this is highly unusual,
and would rarely indicate a cadaver, or anything else but the dogs desire for a biscuit. "

So there you have it folks, Eddie was barking for bourbons,
and Mr Grime and Mr Amaral were barking completely up the wrong rich tea.

I think it is a lot closer to the truth than many on this forum realise...no criticism of the dogs..if there had been evidence there they would have found it...there was no evidence to be found

[slartibartfast]

My award for the crumbiest anti-Eddie post ever goes to this masterpiece I found in the comment section of the Eddie cadaver dog video on youtube

" You will note that the dogs in this video did not sit or lie down, this is the normal reaction,
rather they jumped around and barked, this is highly unusual,
and would rarely indicate a cadaver, or anything else but the dogs desire for a biscuit. "

So there you have it folks, Eddie was barking for bourbons,
and Mr Grime and Mr Amaral were barking completely up the wrong rich tea.

I think it is a lot closer to the truth than many on this forum realise...no criticism of the dogs..if there had been evidence there they would have found it...there was no evidence to be found

The dogs alerted to what they had been trained to alert to...

[stephen25000]

My award for the crumbiest anti-Eddie post ever goes to this masterpiece I found in the comment section of the Eddie cadaver dog video on youtube

" You will note that the dogs in this video did not sit or lie down, this is the normal reaction,
rather they jumped around and barked, this is highly unusual,
and would rarely indicate a cadaver, or anything else but the dogs desire for a biscuit. "

So there you have it folks, Eddie was barking for bourbons,
and Mr Grime and Mr Amaral were barking completely up the wrong rich tea.

I think it is a lot closer to the truth than many on this forum realise...no criticism of the dogs..if there had been evidence there they would have found it...there was no evidence to be found

and let's not forget a contaminated crime scene.

[Brietta]

and let's not forget a contaminated crime scene.

Sure; just another example of the incompetence of the conduct of the initial investigation; three months down the line apartment 5a had played host to four holidaying families in the interim; but matters not a fig since Eddie was obviously barking for his bourbon as explained in the excellent analogy posted earlier.

[Mr Gray]

I think it is a lot closer to the truth than many on this forum realise...no criticism of the dogs..if there had been evidence there they would have found it...there was no evidence to be found


The dogs alerted to what they had been trained to alert to...

you have absolutely no way of knowing if that is true...that's the mistake that you and others make

[slartibartfast]

you have absolutely no way of knowing if that is true...that's the mistake that you and others make

It's more likely to be true than not.

[Mr Gray]

It's more likely to be true than not.

and you have absolutely no way of knowing that