The tapas group and the 'reconstitution' that was never to take place.

[Brietta]

The GBP see easily through attempts to make them think an entire police force is incompetent and corrupt.
The PJ were genuinely trying to solve the case and decided a reconstitution would help.

You do not only do other posters a disservice by supposing they have claimed all Polícia Judiciária Officers are as corrupt as those surrounding Mr Amaral ... you do the PJ itself a disservice.  It should be noted that ordinary hard working officers do not appreciate being associated with those who have faced criminal charges and convictions.

Paulo Rebelo gives an indication of how an investigation should be conducted, reconstruction and all ... his predecessor exemplified the obverse.


'They believe us': Portuguese police finally re-enact Madeleine abduction
Last updated at 13:09 30 October 2007

Kate and Gerry McCann have received a massive boost as Portuguese police have finally decided to reconstruct what happened on the night that Madeleine disappeared.

In a clear sign that Portuguese police are moving back towards the possibility that the four-year old was abducted the new head of the Portuguese police investigation returned to the McCanns' apartment last night to re-enact a possible abduction.

Paulo Rebelo and six detectives appeared to be testing Kate and Gerry McCann's belief that their daughter was snatched from the two-bedroom flat.

They spent almost three hours at the apartment where Madeleine was left sleeping with two-year-old twins Sean and Amelie on May 3.They seemed to be focusing on windows and patio doors where an abductor could have gained entry.

Witnesses saw the team passing a large blue blanket through a bedroom window.

They said the detectives appeared to be checking whether it would be possible for one person to take a child out or if they would have needed an accomplice.

An officer also climbed out of the window.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-490610/They-believe-Portuguese-police-finally-enact-Madeleine-abduction.html#ixzz3fgxhExfJ

[stephen25000]

no it doesn't...it's one of the basic rules of justice...the right to silence... We've gone over the refusal before..if you look at the behaviour of the PJ in lying to the mccanns...not being able to understand the evidence ..conduct in the cipriano case....no one in their right minds would have returned

Total rollocks.

They were under no threat.

The political help they received was quite extraordinary.

They  simply refused to fully cooperate fully with the investigation.

[G-Unit]

The only people the Drs McCann need to 'convince' of anything are the investigating authorities ... absolute arrogance to suggest they need to convince sceptics on social media.

You have a problem with my use of Doctor??  That is very revealing.

It might possibly have been attitudes such as that which may have convinced the Drs McCann Doctor friends that a return to Portugal for a 'reconstitution' might not be the most sensible course of action to take.

Why do you spend your time arguing their corner then? They don't need your help, I'm sure. Your use of the 'Doctor' title seems to have an underlying motive of some kind, so I just thought I'd remind you it doesn't convey anything. The days of respecting people because of their profession are long gone. All the vicars exposed by the NotW, all the lying politicians and misbehaving doctors saw to that.

I can guess why the group didn't want to return to Portugal and I doubt if it had anything to do with anyone's 'attitude'.

[Alfred R Jones]

Why do you spend your time arguing their corner then? They don't need your help, I'm sure. Your use of the 'Doctor' title seems to have an underlying motive of some kind, so I just thought I'd remind you it doesn't convey anything. The days of respecting people because of their profession are long gone. All the vicars exposed by the NotW, all the lying politicians and misbehaving doctors saw to that.

I can guess why the group didn't want to return to Portugal and I doubt if it had anything to do with anyone's 'attitude'.

In the interests of even handedness I trust you will rebuke the next person who refers to Amaral as Dr Amaral...?

[Mr Gray]

Why do you spend your time arguing their corner then? They don't need your help, I'm sure. Your use of the 'Doctor' title seems to have an underlying motive of some kind, so I just thought I'd remind you it doesn't convey anything. The days of respecting people because of their profession are long gone. All the vicars exposed by the NotW, all the lying politicians and misbehaving doctors saw to that.

I can guess why the group didn't want to return to Portugal and I doubt if it had anything to do with anyone's 'attitude'.

I spend my time arguing the corner of justice because you keep attacking them....you can guess why they didn't return to Portugal and that's all it is..a guess....and wrong..

I wonder if you are so anti doctor when you have a seriously ill member of the family and the doctor saves their life

[Angelo222]

no it doesn't...it's one of the basic rules of justice...the right to silence... We've gone over the refusal before..if you look at the behaviour of the PJ in lying to the mccanns...not being able to understand the evidence ..conduct in the cipriano case....no one in their right minds would have returned

A right to silence is nought to do with attempting to pervert the course of justice.  Only someone with something to hide would have refused to cooperate.

[Mr Gray]

A right to silence is nought to do with attempting to pervert the course of justice.  Only someone with something to hide would have refused to cooperate.

what rubbish....Colin Stagg refused to co operate and he was proved innocent

[Angelo222]

what rubbish....Colin Stagg refused to co operate and he was proved innocent

Did his daughter disappear too?

[Alfred R Jones]

Did his daughter disappear too?

Facetious crap.

[stephen25000]

what rubbish....Colin Stagg refused to co operate and he was proved innocent

Did Harold Shipman cooperate with the names of all his victims ?

[Mr Gray]

Did his daughter disappear too?

you are acting particularly stupid...silence is no confirmation of guilt and only a fool would think that

[G-Unit]

I spend my time arguing the corner of justice because you keep attacking them....you can guess why they didn't return to Portugal and that's all it is..a guess....and wrong..

I wonder if you are so anti doctor when you have a seriously ill member of the family and the doctor saves their life

Doubting someone's word is not 'attacking' it's doubting. You are funny, denying the correctness of my guesses even when you've no idea what they are. Doctors made my seriously ill family member worse a few years ago actually. They make mistakes and commit crimes and tell lies and take drugs and beat their wives and cheat on their husbands just like everyone else.  Their job doesn't make any difference to other aspects of their lives.

[stephen25000]

Doubting someone's word is not 'attacking' it's doubting. You are funny, denying the correctness of my guesses even when you've no idea what they are. Doctors made my seriously ill family member worse a few years ago actually. They make mistakes and commit crimes and tell lies and take drugs and beat their wives and cheat on their husbands just like everyone else.  Their job doesn't make any difference to other aspects of their lives.

Indeed.

The mccanns supporters want to make the 'drs' paragons of virtue, and magnify them as 'victims'.

It won't wash.

Madeleine was and remains the victim, not them.

[Mr Gray]

Doubting someone's word is not 'attacking' it's doubting. You are funny, denying the correctness of my guesses even when you've no idea what they are. Doctors made my seriously ill family member worse a few years ago actually. They make mistakes and commit crimes and tell lies and take drugs and beat their wives and cheat on their husbands just like everyone else.  Their job doesn't make any difference to other aspects of their lives.

I deliberately made that statement to elicit a response from you that I expected...you have a personal grudge against doctors . I doubt the doctors made your family member worse...just you getting everything back to front again

[Mr Gray]

Indeed.

The mccanns supporters want to make the 'drs' paragons of virtue, and magnify them as 'victims'.

It won't wash.

Madeleine was and remains the victim, not them.

if maddie is a victim then her family are victims