Author Topic: Mark Warner Holidays and Ocean Club Resorts had a duty of care towards their guests.  (Read 132343 times)

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline pegasus

Welcome to the forum.
What was the checking interval at MW child listening service at san agostino ?

Martina

  • Guest
" Mark Warner Holidays had a duty of care towards their guests"

and Mark Warner, Ocean Club and PJ weren't doing the best for their guests and Madeleine were they?

That was the question posed on this thread. I think its clear they did have a duty of care and failed

Mark Warner offered the night creche and nanny services. They are not responsible for the McCanns choice to not use any of these.

Offline Freya

Mark Warner offered the night creche and nanny services. They are not responsible for the McCanns choice to not use any of these.
They are responsible for passing on information about burglaries. That was the point I was making

Offline Freya

Welcome to the forum.
What was the checking interval at MW child listening service at san agostino ?

If I'm honest I cant remember as I went in 2004. I wouldn't be sure that it could be every 15 minutes though as the area they have to cover is huge and I don't remember there being that many staff on of an evening. Sorry I cant be of more help on that front...we didn't use the service

Offline pegasus

If I'm honest I cant remember as I went in 2004. I wouldn't be sure that it could be every 15 minutes though as the area they have to cover is huge and I don't remember there being that many staff on of an evening. Sorry I cant be of more help on that front...we didn't use the service
Thanks. I found this on mumsnet about MW san agostino listening service  in 2003
"staff patrol every 15 mins"

Offline Freya

Thanks. I found this on mumsnet about MW san agostino listening service  in 2003
"staff patrol every 15 mins"
I think that might be an approximation don't you? it's a large site...they can't be that precise. What happens if they come across three or four rooms on the trot where kids are crying? could be right, who knows?

Offline Freya

Thanks. I found this on mumsnet about MW san agostino listening service  in 2003
"staff patrol every 15 mins"

Why is that so important to you? what is the point you are trying to make?

Offline jassi

The service that MW offered ( though not at PDL) checked on children twice as often as the Tapas group claimed they did, so could not be said to be  exactly comparable.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Freya

The service that MW offered ( though not at PDL) checked on children twice as often as the Tapas group claimed they did, so could not be said to be  exactly comparable.
I see. Okay I guess if you want to be picky then its not identical. As I said myself, the bungalows in San agostino were much much further away than 5a to the Tapas.

I think it would be natural to compare them though if you have been to a MW resort previously. You would expect there to be identical services at both...i.e. baby listening. I know I certainly did. I was shocked to find out that you had to go along and sign your older children in at PDL where as in San agostino you didn't...the kids just rocked up to the clubs themselves.

I think you have to be in the mind set of someone who expected there to be baby listening and that no abduction had taken place there and it was a sleepy little fishing village.

Hindsight is a marvellous thing. 8((()*/

Offline jassi

As someone who would never contemplate taking a holiday in  such a resort, I couldn't comment on users expectations.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Freya

As someone who would never contemplate taking a holiday in  such a resort, I couldn't comment on users expectations.

Forgive me, that's exactly what I thought you were doing.

Offline jassi

Forgive me, that's exactly what I thought you were doing.

Of course it wasn't. I said that the MW system checked twice as often as the Tapas - never mentioned what they expected on arrival.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline pegasus

the MW system checked twice as often as the Tapas
Precisely. The MW system has checks every 15mins, with radios, and no drinking allowed.
Only one couple of the group had ever themselves used an MW listening system anywhere.
The 3 couple trip in 2006 was definitely not even to a MW resort.
I never would have posted all this if it hadn't been for the attempts by some peeps to shift guilt onto an innocent holiday company.
« Last Edit: June 25, 2014, 12:03:58 AM by pegasus »

Offline VIXTE

Precisely. The MW system has checks every 15mins, with radios, and no drinking allowed.
Only one couple of the group had ever themselves used an MW listening system anywhere.
The 3 couple trip in 2006 was definitely not even to a MW resort.
I never would have posted all this if it hadn't been for the unsavory attempts by some peeps to shift guilt onto an innocent holiday company.

I asked you and you never replied, so asking again: Why is so important that only one couple used MW listening service abroad? And where this concrete conclusion came from so you are claiming it a true fact?

For your information, listening service is not a big deal only reserved only for Mark Warner. It is being used for decades by many many resorts in the world serving British and other customers. It is used everywhere. Mark Warner has stopped using it but the other resorts are still using it all around the world.
Have you ever been to a family hotel/holiday village/resort abroad????

And how do you know for a fact that a listening service is precisely done every 15 minutes?
I can tell you, because I have used it myself that in fact depending on a hotel it is different, somewhere it is 15 minutes, in some places every 20 minutes, in others every half an hour. I repeat, listening service is still being used by many holidaying parents all around the world.
I hope I have been clear!

As if this listening service saga goes on we might arrive to a calpol story which was all made up exactly the same way as this.

Offline pegasus

I asked you and you never replied, so asking again: Why is so important that only one couple used MW listening service abroad?

And where this concrete conclusion came from so you are claiming it a true fact?

For your information, listening service is not a big deal only reserved only for Mark Warner. It is being used for decades by many many resorts in the world serving British and other customers. It is used everywhere. Mark Warner has stopped using it but the other resorts are still using it all around the world.
Have you ever been to a family hotel/holiday village/resort abroad????

And how do you know for a fact that a listening service is precisely done every 15 minutes?
I can tell you, because I have used it myself that in fact depending on a hotel it is different, somewhere it is 15 minutes, in some places every 20 minutes, in others every half an hour. I repeat, listening service is still being used by many holidaying parents all around the world.
I hope I have been clear!
...
The PR and the statements claim that the system implemented in PDL was based specifically on the MW listening service. Nowhere do any of them claim it was based on any other company's listening system do they?.
I'm happy to agree with you that even if only one couple having ever themselves actually used an MW listening system is not anything to argue over at all. I make it very clear - the couples told the truth about whether on each holiday they actually themselves used, or did not use, the listening service, if you read their statements carefully and don't make assumptions. I got 95%+ of the info straight from their actual statements, I am saying they are telling the truth.
« Last Edit: June 25, 2014, 12:52:31 AM by pegasus »