[...moderated ...]
Grime called Eddie back to the first car, then back to the second car. Then the third car Eddie sniffed all round without direction.
As Eddie approached the fourth car (scenic) his behavior CLEARLY changed. He without a shadow of doubt entered the scent cone as evidenced by his sudden HEAD IN THE AIR DEMEANOR. As a result, in his eagerness to find the source did not pay attention to the Scenic at all. It is NOT a case of Grime showing prejudice. Grime did his job perfectly by first realizing his dog had entered the scent cone and second bringing Eddie back to perform the necessary checks that he did not previously perform.
It is the dog handler's role when performing a vehicle search to direct the dog to the door seals and tailgate seal. FACT!
Had Grime allowed Eddie to pass the Renault without performing those checks then he would have been CLEARLY negligent in his approach.
When a dog enters the scent cone it's demeanor changes. The next step from there is to find the concentrated source. With Grime's expert direction he was able to locate that source and ultimately was proved TOTALLY CORRECT.
As for the relevance of your uniform argument.....so what. The dog is trained with a cue for when it's time to perform it's role. That can be a number of things such as a certain collar or vest but in Eddie's case it was clearly the click of the fingers combined with a specific verbal cue. AT THAT POINT THE DOG KNOWS IT'S TIME TO WORK. It's nothing to do with the dog seeing a uniform. Each dog is trained with different cues.
My own dog will empty his bowels to a specific command. I let him off leash for a variety of reasons but once I give that command he knows without a shadow of doubt what is required of him. IMO Grime trained his dog well and his dog knew exactly what was required by that command.
The bottom line is when searching vehicles it is the handlers role to direct his dog to the relevant areas. The only reason Grime struggled with the Scenic is not because the dog was disinterested but because the dog was distracted by hitting the scent cone. At that point the handler knows that the source is somewhere close by. Eddie found the source.
I dispute your claim that I am posting from a position of total ignorance. I have done what research is possible and am not ignorant of the events in PDL or of Cadaver dog handling as you rudely claim.
In what way was Eddie proved to be "totally correct"? The only place he alerted was to the driver door adjacent to where the key was on which blood was found. There is no evidence at all that Eddie pointed to anything other than that drop of blood on the key fob.
I have watched videos of the car search, the clothes search and the apartment and other building searches. I have also read the Cadaver Dog Handbook and am therefore aware of the principles of scent cones. And though I am not in any way an expert on the subject I am entitled to an opinion just as you are. I am not convinced that there was not handler direction of the dogs (almost certainly unintentional) in relation to the car which was visibly that belonging to the McCanns and the cuddle toy which the handler knew was in the cupboard.
Until the expert Mr Grime appears on the forum to answer questions then our non-expert opinions will have to differ.