Summers & Swan - A new book - Looking For Madeleine

[Alice Purjorick]

Meanwhile back to the plot.

The authors own notes on sources (see book)

They met once with the McCanns
They had one conversation with DCI Redwood who stated he would tell them nothing that was not in the MSM
No interviews took place between the authors and serving police officers in either country,
Principal sources were:
The PJ files.
Kate’s book
Amaral’s book
Collins’ book “Vanished”
BBC News
Sky News
Panorama
Crimewatch
MSM: Telegraph, Guardian, Sunday Times, Sun , Mirror & Express, Correio de Manha,Diario de Noticia,Journal de Noticias,Horas,Publico,Sol, Tal & Qual, Algarve Resident & Portugal News.

Those who were interviewed included:
Jim Gamble
Brian Kennedy (double glazing magnate)
Carlos Anjos
Tony Bennett
Pat Brown
Bren Ryan
Ex Metodo3 chief Elisenda Vilena
Marcia Koenig & Andy Rebman (dog experts)
Various experts on Toxicology and use of chloroform.

Those who refused interviews included
Mark Harrison
Martin Grime
Chief Inspector Olegario de Sousa
John Lowe of FSS
Melissa Little (forensic artist with FSS)
Angela Morado pro-consul for the Algarve 
Goncalo Aamaral
Representatives of Mark Warner
Representatives of FCO

[pathfinder73]

I have no idea .... neither have you

.... and I wouldn't presume to "hang a man" on assumptions.

Your correct. You can't prove it on that alone.

[Alice Purjorick]

Hang on, the visit to the loo?

That could take 2 minutes or it could take 8 or 10.

Again, we dont know, do we?

The issue in the context that it was raised by Amanda is that the longer the elapsed time the more bizarre.

[Mr Gray]

These are serious authors and respected journalists. They have come out strongly in support of the McCanns and have come down strongly on the McCanns doubters including  Amaral, Brown, Bennett, Stevo...and others, and also on the supposed evidence against the McCanns including the dogs and DNA. Which ever way the doubters on here try to spin it...this is a very significant book.

[faithlilly]

These are serious authors and respected journalists. They have come out strongly in support of the McCanns and have come down strongly on the McCanns doubters including  Amaral, Brown, Bennett, Stevo...and others, and also on the supposed evidence against the McCanns including the dogs and DNA. Which ever way the doubters on here try to spin it...this is a very significant book.

Only to supporters.

To everyone else it's a day late and a dollar short.

[Mr Gray]

Only to supporters.

To everyone else it's a day late and a dollar short.

It is significant in as much that it is a powerful message to the general public that the McCanns are innocent

[stephen25000]

It is significant in as much that it is a powerful message to the general public that the McCanns are innocent

Now any member of the public with a bit of savvy and some research will see there's nae evidence of abduction.

and other possibilities exist. &%+((£

[a.baker]

Just wanted to point out,in the tapas groups own timeline that they submitted to the PJ,it states that Gerry only 'urinated' when he used the bathroom.

[Mr Gray]

Now any member of the public with a bit of savvy and some research will see there's nae evidence of abduction.

and other possibilities exist. &%+((£

I'm amember of the public...more than a bit savvy...and I can see that there is evidence of abduction and it is far and away the most probable thing that happened to maddie

[pegasus]

I'm amember of the public...more than a bit savvy...and I can see that there is evidence of abduction and it is far and away the most probaber thing that happened to maddie

In your theory, why did the child not wake up?

[xtina]

It is significant in as much that it is a powerful message to the general public that the McCanns are innocent

No its not a powerfull  message at all

Its one book.....only wrote from the files ....the book proves nothing...



McCanns are innocent

There are a few more books saying the mccs are not innocent you will find

its just another case of ...what you believe

[Mr Gray]

In your theory, why did the child not wake up?

In my experience it is sometimes almost impossible to wake a child of this age who is in a deep sleep

[Mr Gray]

No its not a powerfull  message at all

Its one book.....only wrote from the files ....the book proves nothing...



McCanns are innocent

There are a few more books saying the mccs are not innocent you will find



its just another case of ...what you believe

not in the UK

[Alfred R Jones]

Only to supporters.

To everyone else it's a day late and a dollar short.

Where is your evidence that it is only supporters who view this book as a serious piece of investigative journalism?  Has it been poorly reviewed in the press?  Have any normal people (ie: not the bunch of rabid loonies who have left 1 star reviews on Amazon) claimed it is a seriously flawed book? 

[Mr Gray]

How has Summers suddenly become a one star author when most of his other books were rated manly 5 star...it's because the barmy army are on the march