Summers & Swan - A new book - Looking For Madeleine

[xtina]

Perhaps you should place less reliance on reviews from bloggers and buy the book which would enable you to make up your own mind.

Why change the habit of a lifetime though ... people being told what to think by bloggers has been the hallmark of Madeleine's case since 2007.

I know my own mind .....thank you very much................unlike yourself who sees no further than the abduction...because the mccs said there was ........k mcc knew straight away ...yet how long was it before the police were called ....

[Eleanor]

What is your opinion  of Amaral's book  ?

Forget that, I already know the answer. 

and let's not forget the Mills and Boon book, not helped with by JK. %£&)**# &%&£(+ %£&)**# &%&£(+

Come on, Stephen, I asked first.

As for my opinion of Amaral's book, I don't have one because I haven't read it

[xtina]

Have you read it?

If not ... what qualifies you to declare it one sided?

because its about a so called abduction ..................the only thing you are allowed to read in this country.....you are told what you have to think ...thankfully ...some wont be dictated to.

[stephen25000]

Come on, Stephen, I asked first.

As for my opinion of Amaral's book, I don't have one because I haven't read it

Well that makes two of us.

I have only read bits from any of the books, basically because NO ONE should profit from the disappearance of a child.

Unless of course the proceeds from any book were completely donated to charity.

[faithlilly]

Excellent to see that the book is selling rather badly.

[Eleanor]

Well that makes two of us.

I have only read bits from any of the books, basically because NO ONE should profit from the disappearance of a child.

Unless of course the proceeds from any book were completely donated to charity.

So neither of us has read any of the books, but arrived at totally opposite conclusions.  I wonder how we did that.

[Brietta]

I'm afraid  brietta , you're not important enough for me to answer the question.

Deja vu, eh ?

That is possibly a witty comment Stephen, pity it is lost on me ... I do not have the faintest idea what you are wittering on about.
Nothing new there then.

[Brietta]

because its about a so called abduction ..................the only thing you are allowed to read in this country.....you are told what you have to think ...thankfully ...some wont be dictated to.

The arrogance of people who pass judgement on a book they have not read is breath taking.

[Alice Purjorick]

The arrogance of people who pass judgement on a book they have not read is breath taking.

Well my dear have you read it?
If so how about giving us your considered opinion of it?

[Brietta]

Well my dear have you read it?
If so how about giving us your considered opinion of it?

I have read it.

Why don't you do likewise then you may be capable of having an informed discussion ... but probably not with me, my dear, because your posting style really does offend.

[Alice Purjorick]

I have read it.

Why don't you do likewise then you may be capable of having an informed discussion ... but probably not with me, my dear, because your posting style really does offend.

I finished last week sometime if you would like to test me on it go ahead luv
I am glad it offends it is meant to  . I would hate to think I am losing my grip.

[Alfred R Jones]

I have read it.

Why don't you do likewise then you may be capable of having an informed discussion ... but probably not with me, my dear, because your posting style really does offend.

Merciful heavens, my dear - do you really think our resident wordsmith is prepared to have any sort of serious discussion (informed or otherwise) with the likes of us McCann apologists? Chance would be a fine thing madam!

[stephen25000]

The arrogance of people who pass judgement on a book they have not read is breath taking.

Have you forgotten a previous post to me ? %£&)**# &%&£(+ %£&)**# &%&£(+

[xtina]

The arrogance of people who pass judgement on a book they have not read is breath taking.

yes the the same as yours on people you don't know lovey.......who have an opinion diferent to yours

well there seems to be a lot who have read the book...and as arrogant as they will be to you have give the book a big thumbs down......

[stephen25000]

I have heard that Summers and Swan got some of their 'information' from 'stop the myths'.

Now isn't that a case of  breaking into an asylum ?