Summers & Swan - A new book - Looking For Madeleine

[carlymichelle]

I have heard that Summers and Swan got some of their 'information' from 'stop the myths'.

Now isn't that a case of  breaking into an asylum ?

that is hilarious   LOL  :D

[Alice Purjorick]

Merciful heavens, my dear - do you really think our resident wordsmith is prepared to have any sort of serious discussion (informed or otherwise) with the likes of us McCann apologists? Chance would be a fine thing madam!

Well judged sir!
I have ologies in sensible discussion, snide remarks , spiteful comments, sarcasm and being offensive in spades.
Take yer pick .
Oh yes I forgot you do don't you, but somehow never seem to include number one on the list.

[Brietta]

Have you forgotten a previous post to me ? %£&)**# &%&£(+ %£&)**# &%&£(+

If you refer to a particular series of four videos ... I stated exactly at which proven lie I stopped watching on each ... and commented on that - nothing else.

[John]

I particularly like the way the authors tend to quote Grime, in that section, rather than stating what Grime says as if authoritative fact.

They are quite right that Grime was freelance in PdL.

We can't judge whether Grime's claim to be in post at South Yorkshire Police when he wrote his profile is true or not, because his profile is not dated.

I don't know why you continue to promote this inaccuracy ferryman but the truth is both you and the authors are wrong.  Martin Grime attended Praia da Luz as a serving police officer having been instructed to do so by South Yorkshire Police.

No doubt this misrepresentation will be of interest to him.

[Wonderfulspam]

I don't know why you continue to promote this inaccuracy ferryman but the truth is both you and the authors are wrong.  Martin Grime attended Praia da Luz as a serving police officer having been instructed to do so by South Yorkshire Police.

 

I do.

[Eleanor]

I don't know why you continue to promote this inaccuracy ferryman but the truth is both you and the authors are wrong.  Martin Grime attended Praia da Luz as a serving police officer having been instructed to do so by South Yorkshire Police.

No doubt this misrepresentation will be of interest to him.

There is a very fine line on this point, John.  Do you know who actually received The Fee?

[ferryman]

I don't know why you continue to promote this inaccuracy ferryman but the truth is both you and the authors are wrong.  Martin Grime attended Praia da Luz as a serving police officer having been instructed to do so by South Yorkshire Police.

No doubt this misrepresentation will be of interest to him.

One fact is beyond dispute (actually, two)

In the official files, Martin Grime gives as his base, his home address in Oxford (naturally, I shan't produce the link, because to give Grime's home address on a public board would be wrong!)

Harrison gives the business address of the (now defunct) National Policing Improvement Agency.

Why is that?

[Miss Taken Identity]

of course stealing some one elses intellectual property is just what can be expected of the caliber of TM SUPPORTER posters.

Not good at drawing eh Sadie? "why use words when you can use pictures and colour in as well"  said the teacher to primary 6.

[faithlilly]

Thanks for saying what we were all thinking! 

Dearie me  !

[Mr Gray]

I dion't think it is of any consequence how the book is selling...it will have no effect on the investigation but it has promoted the innocence of the mccanns and the more the vigilante facebookers perform then the more publicity the book will get.

As a for your opinion of the authors I think you are totally misguided. You have shown poor analytical skills in as much that you have misunderstood all the evidence...Summers and Swann are spot on with their analysis

[faithlilly]

Don't worry...Summmers and Swan really are those ace investigators you always thought...It's you that has got everything wrong

Then perhaps you can furnish us with the new evidence they have uncovered in their book Davel ? You know, the facts that are not already in the public domain.

[Mr Gray]

Then perhaps you can furnish us with the new evidence they have uncovered in their book Davel ? You know, the facts that are not already in the public domain.

You obviously don't understand...there are no new facts...the old ones put the mccanns in the clear...read the book and they explain the evidence of the dogs...the dna ..everything...as agreed by the archiving report

[Alfred R Jones]

Shall we let the members read the book and make up their own mind as to what Summers has been Alfred ?

Can you stop pushing your agenda long enough to let that happen ?

You are the one publicly accusing the authors.  Your agenda is very clear for all to see.  How about just for once putting your money where your mouth is and backing up your accusation with proof?

[faithlilly]

You obviously don't understand...there are no new facts...the old ones put the mccanns in the clear...read the book and they explain the evidence of the dogs...the dna ..everything...as agreed by the archiving report

But the authors boast of extensive research. Are you suggesting they have merely arranged the already accessible facts into an easily read format ? My Davel that is a revelation. It seems you are accusing them of misrepresentation.

[Alfred R Jones]

But the authors boast of extensive research. Are you suggesting they have merely arranged the already accessible facts into an easily read format ? My Davel that is a revelation. It seems you are accusing them of misrepresentation.

Would you say that you have done extensive research on the McCann case?