Summers & Swan - A new book - Looking For Madeleine

[faithlilly]

Kate's book has sold approximately 170 copies across three formats on Amazon alone in the month of September, according to Novelrank (a website you seem to set great store by).  The fact that it has sold any copies at all in hardback is amazing, seeing as the paperback is cheaper, the fact that 170 copies were sold from one source alone in the month of September - a book that was first published years ago is pretty impressive, deride it as you no doubt will.  I'm sure Smiffy would be very happy if his book was still selling in such numbers 

Shame this thread isn't about Kate's book then but Summers and wife's.

[Mr Gray]

I'm not the one who was parading the book as a great success.

Now pray tell, which group of people were ?

Tough question that .

it is a tough question AS I have not heard anyone parading the book as  a great success...you are dreaming again...I

[Brietta]

I'm not the one who was parading the book as a great success.

Now pray tell, which group of people were ?

Tough question that .

I bought and read the book ... I found it well written and informative and I recommend it to you.

I'm not the one chewing  the carpet about it however and the fact there are those who have embarked on a metaphysical book burning enterprise suggest that for some obscure reason ... a book written by unbiased authors using credible sources has reached a conclusion not to their liking ... has them seriously worried.

I wonder about that.

[faithlilly]

When you include sources that support a particular conclusion and leave out those that don't what you get is grievously skewed book that is unworthy of its undeniably talented authors.

[Mr Gray]

When you include sources that support a particular conclusion and leave out those that don't what you get is grievously skewed book that is unworthy of its undeniably talented authors.

you obviously don't understand the evidence

[stephen25000]

I bought and read the book ... I found it well written and informative and I recommend it to you.

I'm not the one chewing  the carpet about it however and the fact there are those who have embarked on a metaphysical book burning enterprise suggest that for some obscure reason ... a book written by unbiased authors using credible sources has reached a conclusion not to their liking ... has them seriously worried.

I wonder about that.

I'm not the one chewing the carpet.

It's you and your mates doing that.

Just try admitting the truth, the book is a waste of paper.

[a.baker]

I consider myself fairly neutral with regards to the case and I purchased the book when it was published. I love reading but am struggling with it. I'm finding it a chore to read as it feels like I've read it all before? From newspapers,Kate's book etc. I really do wish I hadn't wasted my money.

[stephen25000]

I bought and read the book ... I found it well written and informative and I recommend it to you.

I'm not the one chewing  the carpet about it however and the fact there are those who have embarked on a metaphysical book burning enterprise suggest that for some obscure reason ... a book written by unbiased authors using credible sources has reached a conclusion not to their liking ... has them seriously worried.

I wonder about that.

The book was written after consultation with the mccanns.

Enough said.

[Brietta]

The book was written after consultation with the mccanns.

Enough said.

Oh dearie me Steph ... it all depends what one means by 'consultation', the authors describe their meeting with the Drs and the police ... it's all in the book where you can read it first hand if you bother to purchase a copy.

Can't quite remember what it was Dr Amaral did when they contacted him ... must be a footnote somewhere ... I'll look again sometime but I see he's mentioned on 30+ pages, so maybe I'll wait until you've got your copy and we can have an informative discussion.

[Alfred R Jones]

Shame this thread isn't about Kate's book then but Summers and wife's.

I mentioned Kate's book in response to this statement from a "sceptic"



seems ....like a couple more on the mcc casualty list .....it just shows people are sick to the back teeth of the mccs....


to illustrate that obviously not everyone is sick to the back teeth of the Mccs...

[faithlilly]

Seems the authors where pointed by SY to the translated PJ files on the internet. You know those translations that the supporters insist are 'dodgy' !

[stephen25000]

Oh dearie me Steph ... it all depends what one means by 'consultation', the authors describe their meeting with the Drs and the police ... it's all in the book where you can read it first hand if you bother to purchase a copy.

Can't quite remember what it was Dr Amaral did when they contacted him ... must be a footnote somewhere ... I'll look again sometime but I see he's mentioned on 30+ pages, so maybe I'll wait until you've got your copy and we can have an informative discussion.

'S & S'  clearly discussed the book with the mccanns.

Any book worth it's salt would be independent.

The book is a joke.

The sales are a joke.

Anyone who backs the book is a joke.

There is no discussion to have brietta.

[Mr Gray]

'S & S'  clearly discussed the book with the mccanns.

Any book worth it's salt would be independent.

The book is a joke.

The sales are a joke.

Anyone who backs the book is a joke.

There is no discussion to have brietta.

All in your very biased opinion of course

[Wonderfulspam]

All in your very biased opinion of course

....say's Mr Switzerland.

[Brietta]

'S & S'  clearly discussed the book with the mccanns.

Any book worth it's salt would be independent.

The book is a joke.

The sales are a joke.

Anyone who backs the book is a joke.

There is no discussion to have brietta.

LOOKING For MADELEINE sure enough seems to have upset your applecart ... then of course that is not your opinion since you have not bothered to read it ... it is the opinion of others who probably haven't read it either.

Who is the 'Great Book Reader in Chief' who tells everyone else what to think, I wonder ??   

So many upset applecarts ... sigh.