Yes, the dog alerts are indeed a worrying hurdle for some. Had they simply been alerts here, there and everywhere their value could be overlooked but that is not what occurred. The alerts only related to the McCanns, their hire car and their clothing and the apartment where Madeleine was last seen. Is that a coincidence too far?
I don't think it has anything to do with co-incidence, but has everything to do with the amount of time the dogs were allowed to search.
With regard to the cars:
After 30 seconds (which was the max. time spent on any of the other cars) no alerts had been made and the dog moved on. Equally after 30 seconds at the Renault - no alerts had been made and the dog moved on.
IMO That would qualify as an unbiased test. i.e. After a maximum time of 30 seconds spent on every car - there were no alerts.
However, unlike with the other cars, the dog was repeatedly called back to the Renault - and finally alerted after approx 2 minutes.
IMO that would not qualify as an unbiased test.
If Eddie had been called back to the other cars for the same amount of time i.e. 2 mins. then he may have also alerted at one or more of those vehicles.
We shall never know, but the idea that the 9 other cars had never had a spot of blood or any other material to which Eddie would alert in them - at any time since they left the factory - seems extremely unlikely to me.
The same applies to the other apartments.