Documentaries & Articles for Discussion

[mercury]

She got immediate reaction and immediate unquestioned help from the people sitting at the table.  All young. All fit and athletic.  All capable of covering the ground quickly, the women - with the exception of Jane Tanner - to help Kate and to check on their own children who were also alone.

In my opinion had she remained on the balcony screaming her head off that too would have been subject to criticism.

I don't know how I would have behaved in the same situation, but with the benefit of hindsight I consider her behaviour was entirely appropriate.

She had discovered that Madeleine was missing.
She immediately searched the apartment.  Madeleine wasn't there ~ neither was there evidence of a threatening adult in the vicinity.
She immediately raised the alarm and got the search for her daughter started in the shortest possible time.

Absolute tosh, there could have been an immediate removal of her other kids and THAT is the point, there is no evidence there was no nearby threat so stop making thngs up,another risk KM took , =BIG  red flag....you can attempt to spin this forever but you will always just be a dervish for it

[jassi]

How racist.

How pathetic 

[Brietta]

Absolute tosh, there could have been an immediate removal of her other kids and THAT is the point, there is no evidence there was no nearby threat so stop making thngs up,another risk KM took , =BIG  red flag....you can attempt to spin this forever but you will always just be a dervish for it

Once the apartment had been checked it probably took her seconds to alert the people sitting at the table. Common sense dictates that she took the most direct and immediate course of action to raise the alarm.

[stephen25000]

Once the apartment had been checked it probably took her seconds to alert the people sitting at the table. Common sense dictates that she took the most direct and immediate course of action to raise the alarm.

Immediate action.

Go to reception and call the police.

That is called logic.

[mercury]

Once the apartment had been checked it probably took her seconds to alert the people sitting at the table. Common sense dictates that she took the most direct and immediate course of action to raise the alarm.

You are conveniently IGNORING the point of abductors hiding nearby...why is that?

And the MOST immediate and direct action would have been screaming for help!! Whlst protecting her two remaining offspring!!!

Your responses have been poor.

[mercury]

How pathetic 

Alfreds middle name is just that...!!!

[Brietta]

You are conveniently IGNORING the point of abductors hiding nearby...why is that?

And the MOST immediate and direct action would have been screaming for help!! Whlst protecting her two remaining offspring!!!

Your responses have been poor.

Do you really imagine that having kidnapped a child the abductor was hanging around waiting ... for what exactly?


Oh and by the way, do please take note that however goading your rhetoric ... I shall not be responding in kind, if I decide to respond at all.

[Brietta]

Immediate action.

Go to reception and call the police.

That is called logic.

Are you suggesting she should have  -  left the children  -  and popped down to reception. 

I don't know if I would consider that to be at all logical ... however, you are entitled to your opinion.

[mercury]

Do you really imagine that having kidnapped a child the abductor was hanging around waiting ... for what exactly?


oh and by the way, do please take note that however goading your rhetoric ... I shall not be responding in kind, if I decide to respond at all.

Oh I see, the mother will have KNOWN child abductors /molesters/burglars/stop at one..and was positive ghey had long gone...cite???..so felt comfortable leaving them alone...dont be so bleedin daft and apologetic, its actually nauseating

[stephen25000]

Are you suggesting she should have  -  left the children  -  and popped down to reception. 

I don't know if I would consider that to be at all logical ... however, you are entitled to your opinion.

She did leave the other two children. %&5%£

[mercury]

Brietta MistyAlfred and others of a similar "persuasion" need to realise certain facts and snap out of dreamland  into reality


When you find one of your chldren stolen YOU DO NOT LEAVE THE OTHERS!!! In danger


Its not rocket science!! You all dismay me at best, make me want to throw up at worst....pathetic

[Alice Purjorick]

She did leave the other two children. %&5%£

Unless she had one under each arm when she arrived at the tapas at 22:00 or whatever time it was, errrrrm yes!

[Brietta]

Oh I see, the mother will have KNOWN child abductors /molesters/burglars/stop at one....so felt comfortable leaving them alone...dont be so bleedin daft and apologetic, its actually nauseating

Hmmmm ... so abductors can be expected to hang around in the vicinity waiting to be discovered.  I thought the motivator is usually to put as much distance between him/herself and the scene of the crime as possible.

But there you are ...

[Brietta]

Unless she had one under each arm when she arrived at the tapas at 22:00 or whatever time it was, errrrrm yes!

One under each arm ???

When negotiating those lethal steps ???

What if she had dropped one or both on their heads ???  Have you reeeeeally thought things through ... don't think so.

[ferryman]

What a pity that the liaison doesn't say whether he passed the questions on or what the answers were. Please note they didn't ask if sedatives had been used, they asked if there was any evidence that a substance had been used. The answer was probably that there was no evidence, because none was found.

Faith Lilly ignorantly blustered that no witness mentioned concern about (possible!) use of sedatives in the abduction until the rogatory interviews.

I corrected Faith Lilly's ignorance.