Eddie and Keela and what the alerts meant if anything.

[Mr Gray]

Would the public be told this.  SY seems to keep lots of information under wraps.

I think thats one of the most ridiculous suggestions Ive seen on this forum...

[Robittybob1]

I think thats one of the most ridiculous suggestions Ive seen on this forum...

And for you to say that is "one of the most ridiculous suggestions Ive seen on this forum" is doubly ridiculous IMO.

[Robittybob1]

is that supposed to be  a serious question

Do you know?

[Mr Gray]

Do you know?

thats the second most ridiculous question

[Robittybob1]

thats the second most ridiculous question

Well I'll ask this:  Do you think it is impossible for cadaver odour to permeate a couple of inches of concrete?

"A cadaver dog can actually detect human remains through concrete, buried underground, or at the bottom of a body of water, using its extremely well-honed noses to search for faint traces of the chemicals emitted by the human body during decomposition. " https://behindthecrime.wordpress.com/about/the-working-dogs/

[ShiningInLuz]

chapter 16 ..TOTL..

More recently, it's Eddie who helps to find a body buried under a flagstone at the former orphanage, Haut-de-la-Garenne, in Jersey, setting for a terrible case of paedophilia and child murder.

but of course amaral claime dhis book was based on the police files....are postsers still not aware of the claims amaral made in his book

You started off saying Grime claimed that Eddie had alerted to a body under concrete.

This has now morphed into Amaral's saying, with no mention of Grime.

Worse, your 'cite' does not even say Eddie alerted over concrete.  It says Eddie assisted in a search.  In reality, it is common knowledge that Eddie was deployed on the Jersey case.

[Mr Gray]

You started off saying Grime claimed that Eddie had alerted to a body under concrete.

This has now morphed into Amaral's saying, with no mention of Grime.

Worse, your 'cite' does not even say Eddie alerted over concrete.  It says Eddie assisted in a search.  In reality, it is common knowledge that Eddie was deployed on the Jersey case.

Cite for I said  grime made the claim... That's the third most ridiculous thing I've heard.. I said amaral makes the claim in his book

[G-Unit]

Sure but in this case there's not a scintilla of evidence against the McCanns.  This doesn't mean they were not involved in MM's disappearance just that there's no evidence they were.

It was up to the first investigation to find evidence about what had occured and whatever their reasons were they failed. As Pedro do Carmo said in 2017, all possbilities were still being considered. They still didn't have enough evidence to identify the crime. That's why I think theorising about 'watchers' and 'abductors' is somewhat premature when there's no evidence that such people existed.

[Mr Gray]

Well I'll ask this:  Do you think it is impossible for cadaver odour to permeate a couple of inches of concrete?

"A cadaver dog can actually detect human remains through concrete, buried underground, or at the bottom of a body of water, using its extremely well-honed noses to search for faint traces of the chemicals emitted by the human body during decomposition. " https://behindthecrime.wordpress.com/about/the-working-dogs/

Morse couldn't detect cadaver odour through a brown paper bag in the lane case

[Eleanor]

No bodies, under concrete or otherwise, were found at Haute de la Garenne.  Everybody knows this and have done for quite some considerable time.
So where did Amaral get this idea from?

[Mr Gray]

You started off saying Grime claimed that Eddie had alerted to a body under concrete.

This has now morphed into Amaral's saying, with no mention of Grime.

Worse, your 'cite' does not even say Eddie alerted over concrete.  It says Eddie assisted in a search.  In reality, it is common knowledge that Eddie was deployed on the Jersey case.

You must  have been reading a different forum... My cite is still there and the cite makes the claim that Eddie alerted to a body under a slab of concrete


..

More recently, it's Eddie who helps to find a body buried under a flagstone at the former orphanage, Haut-de-la-Garenne, in Jersey, setting for a terrible case of paedophilia and child murder.

[Mr Gray]

It was up to the first investigation to find evidence about what had occured and whatever their reasons were they failed. As Pedro do Carmo said in 2017, all possbilities were still being considered. They still didn't have enough evidence to identify the crime. That's why I think theorising about 'watchers' and 'abductors' is somewhat premature when there's no evidence that such people existed.

He said no evidence against the mccanns

[Robittybob1]

Morse couldn't detect cadaver odour through a brown paper bag in the lane case

Maybe brown paper acts as a filter to cadaver odour.  Does it is a question that needs answering.  Now answer the question about the concrete.

[Mr Gray]

Maybe brown paper acts as a filter to cadaver odour.  Does it is a question that needs answering.  Now answer the question about the concrete.

Could you enforce the rules and ask sil to provide the cite requested

[Robittybob1]

Could you enforce the rules and ask sil to provide the cite requested

I think you have answered it well enough.  SIL IMO was wrong thinking you said Grime made that claim.  Leave it at that.