This is the Sherlock Holmes who didn't ensure a thorough forensic sweep and garbled whatever was found, who didn't understand what Grime / Harrison actually stated, the credit card info, the window evidence, who thought that no self-respecting Portuguese burglar would know how to pick a bog standard lock, who didn't think to check that his officers had taken available CCTV throughout a sleepy tourist resort, who made no concession for potentially inaccurate statements due to misunderstandings, who couldn't tell the difference between a 60-80% certainty based only on how someone walked and held a child at a highly-charged moment due to media coverage and a 100% certainty as to the identity of the person, who insisted that Jane had positively identified Murat....
Poor old Locard. And Occam, and Galileo.
How many times do we have to point out that the investigation was not a one man show with a maverick detective going against the rules? You may prefer to live with your prejudice but the police in Portugal know what they are doing. If it had been a robbery no insurance company would have paid out because there was no sign of a break-in. You say anything to excuse the McCanns.
The apartment was trampled long before the GNR were called.
The PJ understood very well what Mark Harrison and Martin Grime did.
There was no credit card information because none was ever sent to Portugal.
Those kind of locks are virtually impossible to pick and most robbers gain entry through open windows or doors or bashing it. And there are always signs when a lock is picked.
CCTVs are not permitted in public areas and the only existing camera in the area was the type where the film was erased the next day.
Inaccurate statements with discrepencies always raise alarms with any police force. Misunderstandings!!??
60% to 80% was the reason why the PJ wanted the Smiths to come to Portugal for further verification. But after GA was taken off the case, no more leads were followed.
100% guarantee that Jane Tanner saw Robert Murat? LOL