Gonçalo Amaral: This is a contradiction that goes beyond contradiction! (the denotation and connotation of the word).
According to a certain family testimony, there was an 80% probability the man they saw was him – and this is a already a figure which has a British variable on top (a figure that has been doctored).
At first, the family was quite sure that the man who was carrying the child in his arms was this person but, once they were questioned over there – in a rather informal manner it seems then, they lost that certainty and gave the sighting an 80% probability that it was the father - and a 60% it could have been Madeleine.
What I would like to add is; we have repeatedly spoken here about (the hour of the sighting of Martins Smith being at) 22:00, but we do not know (for sure) if it was at 22:00 hours. A reconstruction would have to deal with that. There are only three moments that we know with some certainty, happen at a precise time.
One is when the child leaves the crèche or, for that matter, a family member (mother) collects her at 17:30 hrs.
The other is the Irish family payment (of their bill) at the Dolphin restaurant. They made that payment with a debit card at 21:27 hours but – you have to bear in mind that after they left the restaurant they went to a bar (…)
And the third, was a phone call made to the GNR (National Republican Guard) at 22:47 hours. Everything else is just chitchat – exactly because the precise times are not known.
For example, in the case of Jeremy (Wilkins) it is not known how long his conversation (with Gerry McCann) lasted. It is not known how long that Irish family stayed in that bar after leaving the restaurant. They say they left around 22:00, but it is not known if it was at 22:05, 22:10, 22:15 or 22:20 PM.
A while ago we spoke of Pamela Fenn – an elderly lady who lived in the apartment above (the McCanns’) – and who has since passed away. Now, this lady only hears the commotion in the apartment below at 22:30 hours. (In other words), she places the moment of the all scene – in which the mother purportedly finds her child missing, not at 22 hours (as the mother does) but at 22:30 hours! This person (Pamela Fenn) is no longer with us but her testimony is .
https://zizipresscuts.wordpress.com/page/6/