They are the professionals and if they say they have "smoked him" then smoked he is.
I am the amateur and like all of us amateurs ... have a certain liberty to speculate.
I think there may be an element of that in all of us ... just as there are those who will not give up on their preconceived ideas and prejudices, I prefer my preconceived prejudice on Tannerman and Smithman to the SY version.
As do the Mccanns for some reason...they still have Tannerman primely placed on their website alongside the Australian woman (whoby the way was tracked down and eliminated) but Smthman references and efits are hard to find...and on their Portuguese site, nowhere to be found...how curious, do you have an explanation for this? dOnt you find that a sighting on the night at the right sort of time is a stone that should be turned but seemingly they can't be bothered??
oH BTW if you prefer your preconceived prejudices to SY then do you really have any right to applaud them each time they sneeze? on any other matter? Whilst denigrating the PJ, hypocrisy perchance? Or confusion