He didn't know the place so he used a simple less used route where he couldn't get lost.
The route may be simple, but it is very definitely not less well used.
Rua 25 de Abril and Rua Direita are collectively known as the M537. This dates to a time when the main road from Burgau (west) to Lagos (east) went straight through the heart of Luz (centre). You can see this on Google maps. This was presumably before the N125 to the north.
I'd wager a bucket load of money that at the time the route was two-way. It makes no sense otherwise.
However, let us stick to the more relevant time. Here (photo) are the traffic signs immediately west and north of Rua 25 de Abril. What does ones beady eyes pick out?
Do you notice that 1) traffic from the west heading for Luz is directed to head down along 25 de Abril?
Do you notice that 2) the sign is not about how to get to the beach? That it says nothing about the praia? That it simply says, if you want Luz, then turn right?
Rua 25 de Abril is NOT a quiet backstreet in Luz. It is a MAJOR part of the Luz 1-way system. It is busy and it was busy in May 2007.
Please let me make it clear. I do NOT think that anyone driving down 25 de Abril at 10pm on that night would have given a single thought about a man with a child in his arms.
But the character of Luz has to be understood to progress this case. Luz was NOT quiet that night. It was NOT (as claimed by Amaral) closed for the evening.
If Smithman went along 25 de Abril, he fluked it.