You'd need a book to fully answer that one. But speaking just for myself I'd decided sometime in 2010 to abandon my cynicism. Then their book came out. I rushed to buy it, believe it or not. I was not impressed.
You have posted elsewhere Lyall ... "Fresh eyes will one day approach this case in a way or ways we all can't see."
It seems that you have overlooked the fact that "fresh eyes" have indeed studied Madeleine McCann's case in depth and reached conclusions which enabled them to determine that there was enough available evidence to merit reopening it.
Fresh eyes within Scotland Yard revealed evidence which had not been properly analysed and which led them to determine they were looking at a case of stranger abduction.
Independently of the SY review the Policia Judicairia based in Oporto, reached the conclusion that Madeleine was the victim of stranger abduction.
The "fresh eyes" of internet detectives don't quite come into the same class as these two official bodies ... never have and never will.
I think both the PJ team of investigators and the SY team have fulfilled your criteria ~ they have reviewed the evidence ~ and as a result, both are searching for the person\s responsible for abducting Madeleine McCann.