Author Topic: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...  (Read 134997 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline mercury

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #615 on: October 24, 2015, 08:55:01 PM »
I think this is where the 5 minute gaps idea originated, but I can't be bothered checking the entire thread.

What is more important is whether they sat there clock-watching (time driven) and said "it's 10.03 so you need to go and check".  Or whether they said "nice main meal, I'd better go and check now" (event driven).

Both checks happen to be easy to predict.

However, seeing the T9 (minus 1) start to tuck into mains gives a fair degree of security that no-one will be checking within 5 minutes.

Avoid the pre-starters, avoid the starters (too short), go for the big gap - the mains.

Perhaps they meant every 5 minutes someone was getting up...but not the same person/couple...still, must have been a crappy get together nightly if people were playing musical chairs all night, must have been a constant case of "as I was saying before you ran off"

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #616 on: October 24, 2015, 09:20:55 PM »
As global principles one would have to say they are mutually exclusive. 8(>((

That would depend on the definition of "global" upon which one relied in the specific context it had been used:

global
ˈɡləʊb(ə)l/
adjective
adjective: global

    1.
    relating to the whole world; worldwide.
    "the downturn in the global economy"
    synonyms:   worldwide, international, world, intercontinental; universal
    "the global economy"
    antonyms:   national, local
    2.
    relating to or encompassing the whole of something, or of a group of things.
    "give students a global picture of what is involved in the task"
    synonyms:   comprehensive, overall, general, all-inclusive, all-encompassing, encyclopedic, universal, exhaustive, blanket; More
    broad, wide-ranging, far-reaching, extensive, sweeping, cross-disciplinary, interdisciplinary, multidisciplinary
    "a global view of the problem"
    antonyms:   partial, restricted
        Computing
        operating or applying through the whole of a file, program, etc.
        "global searches"


You pays yer money you takes yer pick; you can debate this forever if you like but I am not going to. I am happy to use seeming mutually exclusive arguments as long as I do not use them simultaneously in the same exchange. I don't have a game plan to which I must adhere. I log on then counterpunch to the current posts and see what drops out. I am quite content to put up with all the crap too as it's all part of the fun. I mean it ain't serious is it?
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline G-Unit

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #617 on: October 24, 2015, 10:15:30 PM »
If the checking really was every 5 minutes, then someone had to get up in the middle of the main course each night to conduct a timed check.  There is zero evidence that this was the routine.

The evidence is that checks were pre-starters, between starters and mains, and after mains.

Thursday was actually somewhat of an exception due to a sick child, but the swapover in the case still took place after a hurried eating of mains, not in the middle of it.

The problem as i see it is that we don't actually have a start time which is set in stone.

The written timelines have everyone seated by 8.45pm.
Dianne and Fiona said they left for the restaurant at 8.45pm in their first statements.
Stephen Carpenter said they all arrived at approximately 8.30pm.
Jane left for the restaurant at 8.30pm and said in her first statement that 'several' of the others were there before her. (later she changed this and said only the McCanns were there before her)
The waiter said they were booked in at 8.30pm each night and it would have been noticed by the staff if they were late.
Jeremy Wilkins was there on the Wednesday evening and said they were all there by 8.30pm that night.

Therefore I wonder why the typewritten timeline was changed to all there at 9pm. Why didn't the waiter notice? Why didn't Stephen Carpenter notice?

The waiter also said that once all were seated he would put two bottles of red, two bottles of white and a bottle of water on the table. He would then take the orders. The mains would be served 20-25 minutes after the orders were taken, meanwhile they would eat the starters.

So the time at which the mains were served depends totally on the time the orders were taken. If 8,50pm, say, then the mains were served at 9.15pm at the latest. If 9pm then they were served at 9.25pm at the latest. Either way it suggests that Russell must have left to check his daughter before 9.25pm at the latest.

Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #618 on: October 24, 2015, 10:24:18 PM »
That would depend on the definition of "global" upon which one relied in the specific context it had been used:

global
ˈɡləʊb(ə)l/
adjective
adjective: global

    1.
    relating to the whole world; worldwide.
    "the downturn in the global economy"
    synonyms:   worldwide, international, world, intercontinental; universal
    "the global economy"
    antonyms:   national, local
    2.
    relating to or encompassing the whole of something, or of a group of things.
    "give students a global picture of what is involved in the task"
    synonyms:   comprehensive, overall, general, all-inclusive, all-encompassing, encyclopedic, universal, exhaustive, blanket; More
    broad, wide-ranging, far-reaching, extensive, sweeping, cross-disciplinary, interdisciplinary, multidisciplinary
    "a global view of the problem"
    antonyms:   partial, restricted
        Computing
        operating or applying through the whole of a file, program, etc.
        "global searches"


You pays yer money you takes yer pick; you can debate this forever if you like but I am not going to. I am happy to use seeming mutually exclusive arguments as long as I do not use them simultaneously in the same exchange. I don't have a game plan to which I must adhere. I log on then counterpunch to the current posts and see what drops out. I am quite content to put up with all the crap too as it's all part of the fun. I mean it ain't serious is it?
As long as you realise that no one can ever take anything you say very seriously then fair enough, but arguing with me just for the sake of it is a bit tiresome IMO.

Offline mercury

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #619 on: October 24, 2015, 10:40:09 PM »
As long as you realise that no one can ever take anything you say very seriously then fair enough, but arguing with me just for the sake of it is a bit tiresome IMO.

It's not encumbent on anyone to realise anything at all especially when borne from a false premise

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #620 on: October 24, 2015, 11:50:47 PM »
As long as you realise that no one can ever take anything you say very seriously then fair enough, but arguing with me just for the sake of it is a bit tiresome IMO.

Everyone is here arguing for the sake of it so in your opinion it is all tiresome?
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #621 on: October 24, 2015, 11:55:21 PM »
Everyone is here arguing for the sake of it so in your opinion it is all tiresome?
if you have a valid point to make then debate with others can be constructive and interesting, both to take part in and observe.  However, when you challenge someone just for the sake of winding them up then that can be quite tiresome. 

Offline mercury

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #622 on: October 24, 2015, 11:59:25 PM »
if you have a valid point to make then debate with others can be constructive and interesting, both to take part in and observe.  However, when you challenge someone just for the sake of winding them up then that can be quite tiresome.

People in glass houses etc!

And if anyone is getting bored, you could also go back to the older thread -  evidence for abduction....just to cut doubled up rubbish, IE sort wheat from chaffe and keep the wheat if theres any



http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4142.0
« Last Edit: October 25, 2015, 12:13:07 AM by mercury »

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #623 on: October 25, 2015, 12:35:33 PM »
The problem as i see it is that we don't actually have a start time which is set in stone.

...
This problem may well exist in a time driven abduction scenario.

But in the event driven scenario, it does not.  The abductor simply waits until he observes the mains being dished up, knowing that from that point on he has a lot longer than 5 minutes to execute his plan.

The diners (and waiters) could be easily observed, so the simplest plan is to observe them until the window of opportunity begins, then get on with it.

This has the added advantage of giving the longest head start, since the next check is unlikely within 20-30 minutes.
What's up, old man?

Offline Miss Taken Identity

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #624 on: October 25, 2015, 01:32:13 PM »
This problem may well exist in a time driven abduction scenario.

But in the event driven scenario, it does not.  The abductor simply waits until he observes the mains being dished up, knowing that from that point on he has a lot longer than 5 minutes to execute his plan.

The diners (and waiters) could be easily observed, so the simplest plan is to observe them until the window of opportunity begins, then get on with it.

This has the added advantage of giving the longest head start, since the next check is unlikely within 20-30 minutes.

Of course this is IF when Maddie was abducted. There is no independent witnesses of Maddie being alive and well since that afternoon. Only DP who paid that visit, he can't recall what for...so hmmm.
'Never underestimate the power of stupid people'... George Carlin

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #625 on: October 25, 2015, 01:55:31 PM »
Of course this is IF when Maddie was abducted. There is no independent witnesses of Maddie being alive and well since that afternoon. Only DP who paid that visit, he can't recall what for...so hmmm.
I do not subscribe to any single theory, but the thread is about the possibility of abduction, not the alternatives.

With each alternative, I try to get my head round what supports it and what goes against it.

In an abduction scenario, David Payne IS an independent witness that Madeleine was alive in the evening of 3rd May after getting back to 5A.  (He is NOT in some other scenarios, but the thread is not about such other scenarios).

So, how to optimise the possibility of abduction?  Make it planned, remove the need for the patio door to be left open, and take into account normal human behaviour.

Normal human behaviour is that no one, whilst in the act of eating, checks their watch and interrupts eating to do a check according to a timed schedule.  They eat until the food is consumed, then check in a break.

The statements covering this issue all say that is what happened.

Therefore a window of opportunity existed that is significantly longer than 5 minutes.  It is the time it takes to eat a main course.

It is a possibility that cannot be dismissed.  But it does not mean that things happened this way.
What's up, old man?

Offline misty

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #626 on: October 25, 2015, 02:04:02 PM »
I do not subscribe to any single theory, but the thread is about the possibility of abduction, not the alternatives.

With each alternative, I try to get my head round what supports it and what goes against it.

In an abduction scenario, David Payne IS an independent witness that Madeleine was alive in the evening of 3rd May after getting back to 5A.  (He is NOT in some other scenarios, but the thread is not about such other scenarios).

So, how to optimise the possibility of abduction?  Make it planned, remove the need for the patio door to be left open, and take into account normal human behaviour.

Normal human behaviour is that no one, whilst in the act of eating, checks their watch and interrupts eating to do a check according to a timed schedule.  They eat until the food is consumed, then check in a break.

The statements covering this issue all say that is what happened.

Therefore a window of opportunity existed that is significantly longer than 5 minutes.  It is the time it takes to eat a main course.

It is a possibility that cannot be dismissed.  But it does not mean that things happened this way.

Kate was going to check at 9.30 so main course hadn't arrived at that stage?
JT bolted down her  main course to relieve ROB from poorly child duties, so main course after 9.30?
That effectively rules Tannerman out of the equation as the abductor in the main course window of opportunity.

Offline Anna

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #627 on: October 25, 2015, 02:21:03 PM »
Please correct me on any timings that I may have wrong. To serve 9 people would take a bit of time, so serving  probably started somewhere between 9.20pm and 9.30pm?

Notice how nobody sees or hears anything.........Music from the restaurant?

20.30 Mccanns go to dinner ***

          Russ and Jane go to dinner

20.45-50 The Paynes go to dinner

20.50-55 Matt goes to check and passes the paynes
Diane didn’t see him.

21.00 Matt returns to dinner

21.00 gerry does a check and leaves after going to the bathroom. ***(I would select this time space. 21.00-21.15 If they were using the front door or window, they could have seen Gerry leave, if watching from up the road……not knowing that he would stop and talk. It seems nobody even saw JT go up the road, so would they see an abductor?)

21.10 Gerry stops and talks to Jez  ***
They didn’t see JT

21.15 JT goes to check and sees crèche man  ***
Gerry and Jez see neither of them

21.20 -22.00 Moyes are on their balcony overlooking tapas and McCanns garden
They see nothing of anyone.
Warrington Guardian

Couple search for missing Madeleine

Sunday, 6 May 2007
By Staff reporter

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post136742.html#p136742
The People




21.25 Matt and Russ go on a check
Russ stays behind with sick child

21.30 Matt returns

21.30 Gerry does another check ?  ***
So main course was served around here

21.40 JT goes to relieve Russ who is caring for a child.

21.45ish Russ returns to dinner      ***

The Carpenters leave somewhere around this time gap, 9.30-10pm, because they didn’t see Jez and Gerry talking or anyone else…..

At approximately half past eight, Gerry and Kate and their group of approximately ten people were already seated at their table, which was so close to ours that it was possible to converse with them, we spoke of tennis amongst other things, I vaguely remember that Gerry and Kate and other people from the group would leave the table in intervals (inaudible), I think it was to check on the children , but I do not remember with what frequency or how many times the people left the table to check on the children. We did not talk about the system for checking the children or the fact that they had left them alone in the apartment, it was only later upon hearing the news that I realised that they had left the children alone in the apartment and that they were regularly checking to see if they were all right. Between approximately a quarter past nine and half past nine we left the Tapas bar to go home,

………………………………................................................
Everyone was seated APPROX  8..30 possibly wrong by 15-20 minutes or so?
If he left after the group had done several checks possibly 9.30 or later?
Sounds like he is out by 15-30minutes. Which is understandable, when on holiday.



22.00 Kate check and alarm


“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #628 on: December 02, 2015, 11:32:26 PM »
Did anyone watch the documentary "The Murder Detectives"?  many interesting aspects to this series, not least the fact that despite getting their man, there was no forensic evidence at all linking him to the scene of the crime, despite the fact that CCTV clearly showed him opening an internal door with an ungloved hand.

Offline mercury

Re: For those who dismiss the possibility of abduction...
« Reply #629 on: December 02, 2015, 11:46:04 PM »
Did anyone watch the documentary "The Murder Detectives"?  many interesting aspects to this series, not least the fact that despite getting their man, there was no forensic evidence at all linking him to the scene of the crime, despite the fact that CCTV clearly showed him opening an internal door with an ungloved hand.

Must mean madeleine was abducted...