Author Topic: Would it have been better if the McCanns had given up on Madeleine years ago?  (Read 20402 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
It seems that despite the constant criticism levelled at the McCanns supposed self-publicity campaign and determination to keep their child's case in the news and focus of attention, no one is quite prepared to state that things would have been a lot better if the McCanns had simply shut up and b....red off the scene years ago.  How curious.... &%+((£

Offline mercury

It seems that despite the constant criticism levelled at the McCanns supposed self-publicity campaign and determination to keep their child's case in the news and focus of attention, no one is quite prepared to state that things would have been a lot better if the McCanns had simply shut up and b....red off the scene years ago.  How curious.... &%+((£
Why would any sane person  respond to your insane post lol thnk  about it troll goading chuck

 8((()*/"

I have you on ignore and don't  respond to insanity in principle but saw that quoted and gosh your post made me comment, soz about that, Carry on trolling though.....and ENJOY

« Last Edit: October 20, 2015, 11:13:51 PM by mercury »

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Which of the following phrases from my earlier post about the McCanns would forum sceptics view as hyperbole?


"nauseating media performances"

"the vast and profligate spending of taxpayers' cash by the government on the review and reinvestigation"

"the "Barbara Cartland-esque" novel that makes you sick to read" (Kate's book)

 "the evil bullying lawsuit against the poor wronged ex-cop"

surely you must agree that your lives would have been hugely enhanced if the McCanns had faded away into obscurity and not taken part in any of these "repugnant activities" over the last 7 years?

Offline ShiningInLuz

The McCann's made it very clear that Smithman was important,  Kate wrote about him in her book too.
She did indeed write about him in her 2011 book.  It's just that the 2008 e-fit is not in the 2011 book and it's not on the Portuguese page of their site.

Note to self.  Although I have stuck up the transcript of Crimewatch 2013 in full on my blog, plus in simple English, and in Portuguese on my blog, I still need to edit and change re e-fits and contact details.
What's up, old man?

Offline mercury

She did indeed write about him in her 2011 book.  It's just that the 2008 e-fit is not in the 2011 book and it's not on the Portuguese page of their site.

Note to self.  Although I have stuck up the transcript of Crimewatch 2013 in full on my blog, plus in simple English, and in Portuguese on my blog, I still need to edit and change re e-fits and contact details.

Smthman efit was nowhere to be seen from when the Mccanns had it to today....apart from a few parts which were soon scrubbed over and never ever publicised

Offline faithlilly

From OP :

'Would it have been better all round if the McCanns had drawn a line under Madeleine's disappearance years ago, not bothered writing a book themselves, not lobbied for a case review, withdrawn completely from the media and quietly applied for a Presumption of Death certificate seven years after her disappearance?'

If their raison d'etre was the successful recovery of their daughter it would have made no difference either way.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
From OP :

'Would it have been better all round if the McCanns had drawn a line under Madeleine's disappearance years ago, not bothered writing a book themselves, not lobbied for a case review, withdrawn completely from the media and quietly applied for a Presumption of Death certificate seven years after her disappearance?'

If their raison d'etre was the successful recovery of their daughter it would have made no difference either way.
???

Offline slartibartfast

Which of the following phrases from my earlier post about the McCanns would forum sceptics view as hyperbole?


"nauseating media performances"

"the vast and profligate spending of taxpayers' cash by the government on the review and reinvestigation"

"the "Barbara Cartland-esque" novel that makes you sick to read" (Kate's book)

 "the evil bullying lawsuit against the poor wronged ex-cop"

surely you must agree that your lives would have been hugely enhanced if the McCanns had faded away into obscurity and not taken part in any of these "repugnant activities" over the last 7 years?

All of it.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline faithlilly

???

You said would it have been better all round if a,b and c. I said it would have made no difference. The McCanns would still be seen by a large percentage of the population as neglectful parents and Madeleine would still be missing.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
All of it.
That's in your opinion, there are others on this forum who have expressed very similar sentiments to the ones I have written - Mercury, Angelo and Stephen are three who spring to mind. 

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
You said would it have been better all round if a,b and c. I said it would have made no difference. The McCanns would still be seen by a large percentage of the population as neglectful parents and Madeleine would still be missing.
What percentage?  Please provide a cite. 

I think actually it would have made a difference.  I think without the fuel that the book, the media campaign, the review, the reinvestigation etc, I think most people who currently regularly post about the case would have lost interest long ago.  Let's face it - "sceptics" who moan about the McCanns' actions day in, day out actually thrive upon them and have derived an enormous amount of entertainment from them over the years.  Where would they be without them?

Offline faithlilly

What percentage?  Please provide a cite. 

I think actually it would have made a difference.  I think without the fuel that the book, the media campaign, the review, the reinvestigation etc, I think most people who currently regularly post about the case would have lost interest long ago.  Let's face it - "sceptics" who moan about the McCanns' actions day in, day out actually thrive upon them and have derived an enormous amount of entertainment from them over the years.  Where would they be without them?

And just think of all the man hours that you could have devoted to your 'business' instead of berating the sceptics for their lack of moral fibre here day in, day out !
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
And just think of all the man hours that you could have devoted to your 'business' instead of berating the sceptics for their lack of moral fibre here day in, day out !
It's true, and the same goes for you. Had the McCanns faded away into obscurity you might have found better things to do with your time than make snide comments about them and their supporters day in day out, correct?  You might even be a master sashimi chef by now!

Offline Eleanor


So many of us got involved because we were shocked and horrified by what was being done to The McCann, never dreaming that it would still be going on eight years later.

stephen25000

  • Guest
The mccanns and no one else are responsible for what they failed to do.

This thread merely reflects what has happened so many times in the last 8 years, namely the mccanns through their limited band of supporters, doing the blame game.

The mccanns are not the victims, Madeleine was, and anyone with a clear view of the case can see that.