What I am trying to establish is - in that situation, would MW Listening service be legally liable for any loss of or injury to any child whom they had been asked to regularly check upon? Had the McCanns sued MW, what effect would GA's thesis (that Madeleine had been overdosed & had a fatal accident which the McCanns then covered up) have had on any decision regarding the extent of any liability on the part of MW childcare? Would the MW childcare have been considered more or less reasonable & responsible than the routine the Tapas group undertook?
I think you are creating your own academic problems here. Officially the authorities have said they did fail in their duty of care though there was, obviously, no intent to harm.
Now,
Had a listenng service been on offer, and it was carried out and everything seemed fine, as it normally is, why would MW be liable? If a MW nanny had seen a potential worrysome sign and did nothng about it, then maybe. I dont know, Im not a lawyer.
Not even sure why we are all discussing this issue any more....views are settled....no consensus, pointless waste of time,hey ho