It was convincing to prove she didn't leave by herself but taken away asleep from the bed like Smithman seen with a sleeping child.
The Drs McCann were dining about forty five seconds away from their children. Not a tremendous distance. If, however they had chosen instead to dine with their friends on the balcony of 5A ... a distance of maybe ten seconds away from the children's bedroom ... it would still have been possible for an intruder to enter the property and take Madeleine. The assaults on children while their parents were on the premises confirm the possibility.
If they had chosen to dine on the patio the probability is that they would not have checked on the children until they were getting ready to retire for the night.
Which would have meant the alarm being raised anything up until two hours later than it was, not that it mattered as no-one with influence seemed to have heard of the 'golden hours'.
That would lead to an interesting scenario apropos Mr Smith's powers of recall both a fortnight after the event and on the occasion of the McCann family's return.