Toddler died hours after slipping on marble floor in her family's apartment

[Mr Gray]

Means nothing, Pathologist Dr da Silva Roubaco, carrying out a post-mortem examination in Portugal, said he found a 5cm bruise on the back of her scalp and some bleeding in the brain and ruled she died from a severe head injury brought on by the slip.

Maybe I should have added pathologist to my earlier list?

she fell forward...I have studied pathology as part of my degree

[carlymichelle]

Means nothing, Pathologist Dr da Silva Roubaco, carrying out a post-mortem examination in Portugal, said he found a 5cm bruise on the back of her scalp and some bleeding in the brain and ruled she died from a severe head injury brought on by the slip.

Maybe I should have added pathologist to my earlier list?

davel seems to  think  toddlers   dont die   from accidents/ head injuries  doesnt he??

[Mr Gray]

davel seems to  think  toddlers   dont die  doesnt he??

I don't think you are able to understand anything I say

[Mr Gray]

davel seems to  think  toddlers   dont die   from accidents/ head injuries  doesnt he??

I made this post this morning so it is a few hours ago and it looks like you have forgotten...


I've never said children don't die from banging their heads....I've said that they don't die immediately and I am 100% right ....so once more you have got the facts wrong. In this case the pathologists are not even sure a head injury was the cause of death...you need to read and understand the article before making any claims

[Angelo222]

Carly how could the same thing have happened to Madeleine?    The McCann's left 5a at 8 o'clock,  Kate checked at 10 o'clock,   if Madeleine had had a fall and banged her head it would have had to have been during those two hours,   so,  if Madeleine died HOURS later as did the child in this article,   then Madeleine would have been alive when Kate checked on her wouldn't she?

A person sustaining cranial trauma can expire at any stage thereafter.

[carlymichelle]

A person sustaining cranial trauma can expire at any stage thereafter.

exactly as i said earlier  remember natasha richardson? liam neesons wife she was fine and then   wasnt

[G-Unit]

Carly how could the same thing have happened to Madeleine?    The McCann's left 5a at 8 o'clock,  Kate checked at 10 o'clock,   if Madeleine had had a fall and banged her head it would have had to have been during those two hours,   so,  if Madeleine died HOURS later as did the child in this article,   then Madeleine would have been alive when Kate checked on her wouldn't she?

The McCanns left at 8.30pm I believe. Why would a fall have to take place within a certain timescale? A fall could have taken place at any time if it produced no symptoms, like the fall in the article. She could have had an apparently minor bump at any time during that day, actually.

[slartibartfast]

I made this post this morning so it is a few hours ago and it looks like you have forgotten...


I've never said children don't die from banging their heads....I've said that they don't die immediately and I am 100% right ....so once more you have got the facts wrong. In this case the pathologists are not even sure a head injury was the cause of death...you need to read and understand the article before making any claims

Death by poisoning and strangulation are much more likely than by head injury.

[Angelo222]

she fell forward...I have studied pathology as part of my degree

Her parents didn't know which part of her head hit the floor.

[Mr Gray]

Means nothing, Pathologist Dr da Silva Roubaco, carrying out a post-mortem examination in Portugal, said he found a 5cm bruise on the back of her scalp and some bleeding in the brain and ruled she died from a severe head injury brought on by the slip.

Maybe I should have added pathologist to my earlier list since you deem to know more than the pathologist who examined the child after her death?

The second pathologist totally disagreed...and as the child fell forwards and struck the front of her head the first pathologist sounds like an idiot

[Angelo222]

davel seems to  think  toddlers   dont die   from accidents/ head injuries  doesnt he??

Yes, he's quite the expert on all things these days 

[jassi]

What's the world coming to when you can't get two doctors to agree, eh ?

[Mr Gray]

A person sustaining cranial trauma can expire at any stage thereafter.

you need to differentiate between a head injury caused by a domestic fall and a car acccident

[Mr Gray]

exactly as i said earlier  remember natasha richardson? liam neesons wife she was fine and then   wasnt

read up on it...she developed symptoms an hour later but died some time after the onset of symptoms

[carlymichelle]

you need to differentiate between a head injury caused by a domestic fall and a car acccident

any head injury can kill someone  by any accident