Toddler died hours after slipping on marble floor in her family's apartment

[stephen25000]

loads of documentary evidence.....
Amaral blames the parents on a hunch..same as cipriano
no real evidence against the parents...mccanns and cipriano

pj put pressure on parents to confess


all documented

Not a sausage, in reality to support abduction.

[Mr Gray]

Not a sausage, in reality to support abduction.

never mentioned suasages or abduction

[stephen25000]

never mentioned suasages or abduction

You have mentioned abduction on many, many occasions.

As to sausages, you do realize it was referring to the lack of evidence to support it, i.e. abduction ?  £4%4%

[Brietta]

Is this merely your opinion or do you know it as a fact with some documentary evidence of same you would care to share with us?

It is an opinion formed by comparison of the known facts of the Cipriano case and the McCann case.  The most important known facts of which are that two little girls have ~ vanished without trace ~ from locations in close proximity to each other.

It is an opinion which appears to be shared by the family of Joana Cipriano, one of the missing children ...

Quote:
The family of a girl who vanished just seven miles from the Portuguese resort where Madeleine McCann disappeared are convinced the cases are connected.

On the day of Madeleine's fifth birthday, Joana Cipriano's relatives have urged detectives to investigate links between the two disappearances - saying there are too many disturbing similarities for the evidence to be ignored.
http://news.sky.com/story/603144/disturbing-similarities-with-madeleine

[Alice Purjorick]

loads of documentary evidence.....
Amaral blames the parents on a hunch..same as cipriano
no real evidence against the parents...mccanns and cipriano

pj put pressure on parents to confess


all documented

You state "loads" then quote little.
Coincidental events maybe but no evidence there was a "determination to replicate....".

[stephen25000]

It is an opinion formed by comparison of the known facts of the Cipriano case and the McCann case.  The most important known facts of which are that two little girls have ~ vanished without trace ~ from locations in close proximity to each other.

It is an opinion which appears to be shared by the family of Joana Cipriano, one of the missing children ...

Quote:
The family of a girl who vanished just seven miles from the Portuguese resort where Madeleine McCann disappeared are convinced the cases are connected.

On the day of Madeleine's fifth birthday, Joana Cipriano's relatives have urged detectives to investigate links between the two disappearances - saying there are too many disturbing similarities for the evidence to be ignored.
http://news.sky.com/story/603144/disturbing-similarities-with-madeleine

You are speculating.

and that is all that it is.

+ desperation  to find a link.

[Alice Purjorick]

It is an opinion formed by comparison of the known facts of the Cipriano case and the McCann case.  The most important known facts of which are that two little girls have ~ vanished without trace ~ from locations in close proximity to each other.

It is an opinion which appears to be shared by the family of Joana Cipriano, one of the missing children ...

Quote:
The family of a girl who vanished just seven miles from the Portuguese resort where Madeleine McCann disappeared are convinced the cases are connected.

On the day of Madeleine's fifth birthday, Joana Cipriano's relatives have urged detectives to investigate links between the two disappearances - saying there are too many disturbing similarities for the evidence to be ignored.
http://news.sky.com/story/603144/disturbing-similarities-with-madeleine

You are avoiding the question I asked.

[Eleanor]

You are speculating.

and that is all that it is.

+ desperation  to find a link.

No desperation.  There is already a link by proximity.

[stephen25000]

No desperation.  There is already a link by proximity.

That proves nothing Eleanor.

I can't believe you said that.

[Mr Gray]

You state "loads" then quote little.
Coincidental events maybe but no evidence there was a "determination to replicate....".

I've quoted bigger


loads of documentary evidence.....
Amaral blames the parents on a hunch..same as cipriano
no real evidence against the parents...mccanns and cipriano

pj put pressure on parents to confess


all documented

[Brietta]

You state "loads" then quote little.
Coincidental events maybe but no evidence there was a "determination to replicate....".

Your post might have assumed some validity were you capable of arguing exactly what did not replicate the circumstances which ~ in my opinion ~ led to the assumption that a formula which had resulted in conviction and therefore kudos??? for the investigators, was worth trying again in similar circumstances.

The parallels even included the opportunity to make a bob or two from best sellers written by cops on both cases.  I rather suspect you have no argument (what's new?) for the simple reason none exists ... the hypothesis being very reasonable.

[Brietta]

You are avoiding the question I asked.

I have avoided ~ nothing ~ if my answer doesn't suit you, fair enough.  If you wish to pursue an infantile bicker, you have picked the wrong poster, best to find someone else who may indulge and entertain you.

[stephen25000]

Your post might have assumed some validity were you capable of arguing exactly what did not replicate the circumstances which ~ in my opinion ~ led to the assumption that a formula which had resulted in conviction and therefore kudos??? for the investigators.

The parallels even included the opportunity to make a bob or two from best sellers written by cops on both cases.  I rather suspect you have no argument (what's new?) for the simple reason none exists ... the hypothesis being very reasonable.

Pure desperation.

[Brietta]

Pure desperation.

Nota Bene ... I have amended my post to Alice as follows ...
"Your post might have assumed some validity were you capable of arguing exactly what did not replicate the circumstances which ~ in my opinion ~ led to the assumption that a formula which had resulted in conviction and therefore kudos??? for the investigators, was worth trying again in similar circumstances."

I'm finding both of your postings tiresome and I do so wish you would both up your games from the favoured non sequiturs you espouse.
Please do try to make it a bit more interesting and less negative when you post or you won't be worth reading.

[stephen25000]

Nota Bene ... I have amended my post to Alice as follows ...
"Your post might have assumed some validity were you capable of arguing exactly what did not replicate the circumstances which ~ in my opinion ~ led to the assumption that a formula which had resulted in conviction and therefore kudos??? for the investigators, was worth trying again in similar circumstances."

I'm finding both of your postings tiresome and I do so wish you would both up your games from the favoured non sequiturs you espouse.
Please do try to make it a bit more interesting and less negative when you post or you won't be worth reading.

You find my posts tiresome,  so how do you suppose I view yours.

Rhetorical question, of corse.

Yours are no more than a boring tiertribe  of abduction, abduction and abduction.

Regardless of the fact there is b....r all evidence to support it.