Author Topic: Daily Express publishes written apology over headline calling Maddie cop a liar  (Read 4901 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Online Eleanor


Goncal Amaral was publicly accused in the Express's headline of having 'Lied about death cover-up claim'.

That has now been publicly corrected.

He did not lie.

Neither did he tell the truth, since no one knows what that is.

Offline Jean-Pierre


Goncal Amaral was publicly accused in the Express's headline of having 'Lied about death cover-up claim'.

That has now been publicly corrected.

He did not lie.

I suggest you read it more closely.  The court did not make any determination as to whether he lied or not.  And therefore the express were wrong to write the headline saying that he had.  It was rightly corrected. 

However as they did not in their judgement consider whether he lied or not, you cannot actually state that he did not lie.  The question remains open (it's a bit uncomfortable when the boots on the othr foot, isn't it!)

Offline Alice Purjorick

I suggest you read it more closely.  The court did not make any determination as to whether he lied or not.  And therefore the express were wrong to write the headline saying that he had.  It was rightly corrected. 

However as they did not in their judgement consider whether he lied or not, you cannot actually state that he did not lie.  The question remains open (it's a bit uncomfortable when the boots on the othr foot, isn't it!)

Didn't the judge at one stage state the trial was not about truth?
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline xtina

I suggest you read it more closely.  The court did not make any determination as to whether he lied or not.  And therefore the express were wrong to write the headline saying that he had.  It was rightly corrected. 

However as they did not in their judgement consider whether he lied or not, you cannot actually state that he did not lie.  The question remains open (it's a bit uncomfortable when the boots on the othr foot, isn't it!)


(it's a bit uncomfortable when the boots on the othr foot, isn't it!)

err...uncomfortable for whom ........i have a boot on each foot ..........unless you meant yourself .....my feet are fine thank you  8((()*/
Always listen to both sides of the story before you judge.

The first storyteller you will always find has modified the story, for there benefit BE WISE.

Offline Mr Gray


(it's a bit uncomfortable when the boots on the othr foot, isn't it!)

err...uncomfortable for whom ........i have a boot on each foot ..........unless you meant yourself .....my feet are fine thank you  8((()*/

the court...nor the judge ruled that amaral did not lie.....he obviously did

Offline Mr Gray

Didn't the judge at one stage state the trial was not about truth?

The trial is about the law...that was the point the judge was making...the McCanns were entitled to the presumption of innocence whatever the truth. that's why I don't see the court waiting for any developments in the SY case
« Last Edit: December 13, 2015, 05:18:20 PM by davel »

ferryman

  • Guest

Goncal Amaral was publicly accused in the Express's headline of having 'Lied about death cover-up claim'.

That has now been publicly corrected.

He did not lie.

I'm (slowly) getting my head round the way  this trial was conducted.  That the court may have found grounds other than Amaral's lies (his breach of duty to keep his mouth shut about a case he coordinated etc) to find in favour of the McCanns is quite different from the (patently false) assertion that Amaral did not lie.

Amaral lied, and lied, and lied ...

But the court chose other grounds to find in favour of the McCanns .....
« Last Edit: December 13, 2015, 05:39:46 PM by ferryman »

stephen25000

  • Guest
I'm (slowly) getting my head round the way  this trial was conducted.  That the court may have found grounds other than Amaral's lies (his breach of duty to keep his mouth shut about a case he coordinated etc) to find in favour of the McCanns is quite different from the (patently false) assertion that Amaral did not lie.

Amaral lied, and lied, and lied ...

But the court chose other grounds to find in favour of the McCanns .....

Then list the lies with cites, along with the lies of all parties in this case, with cites.
« Last Edit: December 14, 2015, 03:34:19 AM by John »