Hmmm...it seems to me you are a sceptic not only regarding the McCanns but also Operation Grange's abilities to forensically examine a timeline and to tell the truth to the general public. I believe the Met has access to a computer system called HOLMES which helps them to identify windows of opportunity in the timeline, but then again maybe that's simply police propaganda and is no more than some guy throwing darts at a wall covered in scraps of paper.
Finally, of course the Met have not stated Madeleine was definitely abducted,in the same way that have not stated that Ben Needham was definitely abducted, but it is clear that it is the theory that holds the most weight as far as their investigations go - perhaps you can explain to us why you know better than them?
Experts (that's
real experts!) are (in my opinion) notoriously reluctant to commit themselves (to any darned thing).
The prosecution in the Ian Huntley trial introduced an expert witness to demolish Huntley's own account of how Holly and Jessica met their deaths. According to Huntley (who pleaded guilty to manslaughter) all three landed up together in his bathroom. One girl developed a nosebleed and he went for some toilet tissue to stem the flow of blood; the other girl slipped, fell into a bath he had run to wash his dog and drowned, while Huntley held his hand over the mouth of the first girl to stop her screaming (and she suffocated).
The expert witness did a good job of demolishing the account.
But at the end of his testimony, asked if he thought Huntley's account
impossible, he replied,
no.
Huntley was convicted on a majority verdict.
Did one juror accord benefit of doubt?