You seriously cannot be so naive.....its ok if you are, life is a large rich tapestry LOL!!
Actually it was Starti who claimed he was given false reports by his subordinates which he couldn't be expected to know were a pack of lies. I was running with that scenario. IMO Amaral knew exactly what was happening to Leonor Cipriano over a period of 2 days. As Lead Investigator and chief co-ordinator then IMO he would be the one who arranged for her to be brought the the police station in the first place.
A Court found that LC had been tortured at his police station by officers of the PJ. LC's 'crime' was that she could not identify the men who tortured her - probably because she had a bag over her head and blood in her eyes.
Amaral falsified documents to cover up the torture. It all went pear-shaped for him when the Governor of the prison refused to lie and say LC had been beaten up in prison. Good for her.
Amaral was found guilty of perjury and his appeal against his conviction was thrown out. Anyone who can even attempt to claim he was some kind of 'innocent victim' in the face of that fact- is seriously in denial IMO.
The fact that LC is still in prison and the police officers who tortured her have not been identified and punished is a disgrace IMO. Although apparently there has never been a single 'miscarriage of justice' case in Portugal as the police have never once made a mistake. And if you believe that you will believe anything.