Author Topic: A Question of Propaganda.  (Read 273506 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #915 on: December 23, 2015, 05:55:27 PM »
Operation Havern was an investigation into child-abuse.

It wasn't an investigation into murder.

Offline mercury

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #916 on: December 24, 2015, 03:25:23 AM »
Given that both dogs alert to dead blood, and Keela supposedly only to human blood, then there is no need to hunt for a body within 5A, merely a source of human blood.

The Scenic key fob proves that.  And the alert by both dogs in the sand bucket test, thereby indicating human origin, and the forensics showing the material to be Gerry's, shows that both dogs react to dead blood from a live human being.

There is no proof of a dead body in the Madeleine McCann case, merely of a disappearance.

Are you saying Eddies alerts should be ignored where Keelas do not confirm them as blood (as the flawed argument goes anyway) ? If so, why? Ie what evidence is there specifically that pours doubt on the possibilty or disproves  that he alerted to remnant body scent? Just so we can get our facts straight in general.

ie parents bedroom alert for example for one, where Eddie alerted and Keela did not

Dont also forget there is no forensic test available for remnant death or other scent so Eddies alerts if they were to this, could never have been "proven" in a lab

My last question would be why people are happy to consider that Keela is a more reliable dog than Eddie

Is  it just because she sniffs out "physical evidence that can be collected" ? Hardly a measure,.... my main point being one cant just be told that Eddies alerts mean nothing unless substantiated with solid reasons why ...whilst that void remains and it always will, all cards are on the table.....still
« Last Edit: December 24, 2015, 04:47:20 AM by mercury »

Offline Mr Gray

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #917 on: December 24, 2015, 09:26:15 AM »
Are you saying Eddies alerts should be ignored where Keelas do not confirm them as blood (as the flawed argument goes anyway) ? If so, why? Ie what evidence is there specifically that pours doubt on the possibilty or disproves  that he alerted to remnant body scent? Just so we can get our facts straight in general.

ie parents bedroom alert for example for one, where Eddie alerted and Keela did not

Dont also forget there is no forensic test available for remnant death or other scent so Eddies alerts if they were to this, could never have been "proven" in a lab

My last question would be why people are happy to consider that Keela is a more reliable dog than Eddie

Is  it just because she sniffs out "physical evidence that can be collected" ? Hardly a measure,.... my main point being one cant just be told that Eddies alerts mean nothing unless substantiated with solid reasons why ...whilst that void remains and it always will, all cards are on the table.....still

not only should be ignored....they have been ignored...for very...very obvious reasons that have been discussed a million times

Offline Mr Gray

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #918 on: December 24, 2015, 09:29:26 AM »
Are you saying Eddies alerts should be ignored where Keelas do not confirm them as blood (as the flawed argument goes anyway) ? If so, why? Ie what evidence is there specifically that pours doubt on the possibilty or disproves  that he alerted to remnant body scent? Just so we can get our facts straight in general.

ie parents bedroom alert for example for one, where Eddie alerted and Keela did not

Dont also forget there is no forensic test available for remnant death or other scent so Eddies alerts if they were to this, could never have been "proven" in a lab

My last question would be why people are happy to consider that Keela is a more reliable dog than Eddie

Is  it just because she sniffs out "physical evidence that can be collected" ? Hardly a measure,.... my main point being one cant just be told that Eddies alerts mean nothing unless substantiated with solid reasons why ...whilst that void remains and it always will, all cards are on the table.....still



just to add...there is no evidence that eddie did not alert to RBC ....but no evidence he did...taht makes the alerts useless as I have pointed out many times

Offline Brietta

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #919 on: December 24, 2015, 09:45:19 AM »
Are you saying Eddies alerts should be ignored where Keelas do not confirm them as blood (as the flawed argument goes anyway) ? If so, why? Ie what evidence is there specifically that pours doubt on the possibilty or disproves  that he alerted to remnant body scent? Just so we can get our facts straight in general.

ie parents bedroom alert for example for one, where Eddie alerted and Keela did not

Dont also forget there is no forensic test available for remnant death or other scent so Eddies alerts if they were to this, could never have been "proven" in a lab

My last question would be why people are happy to consider that Keela is a more reliable dog than Eddie

Is  it just because she sniffs out "physical evidence that can be collected" ? Hardly a measure,.... my main point being one cant just be told that Eddies alerts mean nothing unless substantiated with solid reasons why ...whilst that void remains and it always will, all cards are on the table.....still

There are very good scientific and common sense reasons why residual scent should not be taken as 'proof' that a particular person's remains have lain at the position of an alert.

The dog may very well be capable of identifying exactly to whom the scent belongs ... but it cannot relay that information to the investigators.

A quick check of the internet or the very many dog threads already on the forum will confirm that there are many VOCs which replicate the scent of human remains which will cause the animal's trained response.
Residual scent has many components and science hasn't yet worked out exactly what or which combination it is that enables the dog to detect and alert.

Please try to understand that a stand alone alert won't be accepted even in a Scottish court where such evidence has been allowed without other compelling evidence for the consideration of a court.

Therefore Eddie's 'alerts' mean nothing without corroboration and his unreliability having been demonstrated in the Haute de la Garenne investigation should make him less of a pin up boy for promoting a seriously flawed hypothesis.   
« Last Edit: December 24, 2015, 09:47:26 AM by Brietta »
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline pathfinder73

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #920 on: December 24, 2015, 10:26:35 AM »
There are very good scientific and common sense reasons why residual scent should not be taken as 'proof' that a particular person's remains have lain at the position of an alert.

The dog may very well be capable of identifying exactly to whom the scent belongs ... but it cannot relay that information to the investigators.

A quick check of the internet or the very many dog threads already on the forum will confirm that there are many VOCs which replicate the scent of human remains which will cause the animal's trained response.
Residual scent has many components and science hasn't yet worked out exactly what or which combination it is that enables the dog to detect and alert.

Please try to understand that a stand alone alert won't be accepted even in a Scottish court where such evidence has been allowed without other compelling evidence for the consideration of a court.

Therefore Eddie's 'alerts' mean nothing without corroboration and his unreliability having been demonstrated in the Haute de la Garenne investigation should make him less of a pin up boy for promoting a seriously flawed hypothesis.   

Eddie was trained and his work speaks for itself. He detected cadaver scent in a garage and then the house next door. He amazed the authorities when checking that a kid had died in the house. Eddie alerted to cadaver scent. That's his job. Don't even bring the Jersey fiasco into it as an argument. Child abuse happened there and god knows what else.
« Last Edit: December 24, 2015, 10:28:44 AM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Offline faithlilly

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #921 on: December 24, 2015, 11:14:46 AM »
this was the point I was responding to:

You are right misty there wasn't enough time for cadaver scent to develop and yet SY have stated they feel Madeleine may have been dead when she was taken from the apartment. Rather a large coincidence don't you think that there may have been a body in 5a, that the dogs alerted in no other apartment but 5a yet the body they alerted to was not Madeleine's ?

The discussion was about coincidence.  The coincidence that in the hunt for a missing child a cadaver dog alerted in a room in which she had been but which turned out not to be her at all.  So, coincidences of this type can happen, for whatever reason.

So you think it's conceivable that a cadaver dog alerted in 5a, SY think Madeleine may not have left 5a alive and that is not connected ? Okkkkaaayyyy !!
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #922 on: December 24, 2015, 11:20:06 AM »
So you think it's conceivable that a cadaver dog alerted in 5a, SY think Madeleine may not have left 5a alive and that is not connected ? Okkkkaaayyyy !!

Scotland Yard think Madeleine's abductor might have murdered Madeleine in the apartment (please God they wrong)!

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #923 on: December 24, 2015, 11:23:17 AM »
Scotland Yard think Madeleine's abductor might have murdered Madeleine in the apartment (please God they wrong)!

The abductor yet again.

I will remind you yet again, not one iota of forensic evidence to show one ever existed.

Repeatedly typing it won't make it true.

Offline G-Unit

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #924 on: December 24, 2015, 12:08:38 PM »
So you think it's conceivable that a cadaver dog alerted in 5a, SY think Madeleine may not have left 5a alive and that is not connected ? Okkkkaaayyyy !!

When police use dogs they are checking to see what may have been on the premises, whether it's drugs, explosives, bodies or whatever. If the dogs don't alert it's back to square one. If the dogs do alert the search intensifies. If nothing is found do the police;
a) Sack the dogs.
b) Apologise for suspecting the people whose premises they are searching.
c) Conclude that there probably was something there but it's been moved/disposed of.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Mr Gray

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #925 on: December 24, 2015, 12:35:56 PM »
So you think it's conceivable that a cadaver dog alerted in 5a, SY think Madeleine may not have left 5a alive and that is not connected ? Okkkkaaayyyy !!

dog alerted in 5a...SY think Maddie may still be alive...amaral's lawyer saying maddie may still be alive...
dog alert....absolutely meaningless

Offline Mr Gray

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #926 on: December 24, 2015, 12:38:46 PM »
It isn't just me ferryman.

Now tell me, have they found Madeleine or how she disappeared ?

so  who else ...

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #927 on: December 24, 2015, 12:45:38 PM »
so  who else ...

You really believe I'm the only person who does not believe an abduction took place ?

 8**8:/:

Offline Mr Gray

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #928 on: December 24, 2015, 12:50:54 PM »
When police use dogs they are checking to see what may have been on the premises, whether it's drugs, explosives, bodies or whatever. If the dogs don't alert it's back to square one. If the dogs do alert the search intensifies. If nothing is found do the police;
a) Sack the dogs.
b) Apologise for suspecting the people whose premises they are searching.
c) Conclude that there probably was something there but it's been moved/disposed of.

the fact that you think it's that simple shows you do not understand the alerts

Offline Brietta

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #929 on: December 24, 2015, 12:52:23 PM »
Eddie was trained and his work speaks for itself. He detected cadaver scent in a garage and then the house next door. He amazed the authorities when checking that a kid had died in the house. Eddie alerted to cadaver scent. That's his job. Don't even bring the Jersey fiasco into it as an argument. Child abuse happened there and god knows what else.

As far as "God knows what else" may have occurred at Haute de la Garenne there is no evidence which supports the speculation despite a long and expensive investigation. 

There is evidence however that Eddie's false alerts contributed to the chaos.  Ignoring the fact won't make it go away.

There is a problem the propagandists may find themselves landed in.

Catchy as the "Dog's don't lie" slogan is there is just so much accurate information available about the work these dogs are capable of and the protocols under which they and their handlers operate that it knocks what we have seen on video of what happened in Luz into a cocked hat.

Eddie was a victim recovery dog, trained like all the others on pig and human blood, who in my opinion was well past his usefulness by the time he was deployed in Luz ... unless playing with the evidence and tossing it around was his trained response.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....