Are you saying Eddies alerts should be ignored where Keelas do not confirm them as blood (as the flawed argument goes anyway) ? If so, why? Ie what evidence is there specifically that pours doubt on the possibilty or disproves that he alerted to remnant body scent? Just so we can get our facts straight in general.
ie parents bedroom alert for example for one, where Eddie alerted and Keela did not
Dont also forget there is no forensic test available for remnant death or other scent so Eddies alerts if they were to this, could never have been "proven" in a lab
My last question would be why people are happy to consider that Keela is a more reliable dog than Eddie
Is it just because she sniffs out "physical evidence that can be collected" ? Hardly a measure,.... my main point being one cant just be told that Eddies alerts mean nothing unless substantiated with solid reasons why ...whilst that void remains and it always will, all cards are on the table.....still
Let me try this again.
Keela alerts to blood and supposedly to human blood only, to be specific. Assuming this is accurate, then Keela's alert indicates the presence of human blood, in the living room. Clearly, that blood is dead. So if Keela is infallible, we have dead human blood in apartment 5A.
Eddie alerts to a range of dead sources. One of the sources he alerts to is dead blood, whether human in origin or not. So where both dogs alerted, we have dead blood of human origin. We do not yet have sufficient to even indicate a dead human body, merely dead human blood.
I could go through the rest of the evidence step by step but this is not a 'dogs' thread it is a 'propaganda' thread.
To say that the dogs indicated a dead body of human origin, in 5A or in 27 Rua Das Flores or in the Scenic is not accurate. They might or might not have. To state that they did, as a fact, is propaganda.
We have, at this point in time, no evidence that Madeleine is dead. So discussing time for cadaver odour to develop from a human corpse is meaningless.
If someone bled in 5A, whether such person was Madeleine, before Madeleine, or after Madeleine, no matter how long it takes for 'cadaver odour' to develop, there was ample time, from days to months, before the dogs were deployed.