Author Topic: A Question of Propaganda.  (Read 273463 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline mercury

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #990 on: December 24, 2015, 08:27:44 PM »
Let me try this again.

Keela alerts to blood and supposedly to human blood only, to be specific.  Assuming this is accurate, then Keela's alert indicates the presence of human blood, in the living room.  Clearly, that blood is dead.  So if Keela is infallible, we have dead human blood in apartment 5A.

Eddie alerts to a range of dead sources.  One of the sources he alerts to is dead blood, whether human in origin or not.  So where both dogs alerted, we have dead blood of human origin.  We do not yet have sufficient to even indicate a dead human body, merely dead human blood. One does not necessarily follow from the other but I will go with that for now

I could go through the rest of the evidence step by step but this is not a 'dogs' thread it is a 'propaganda' thread. Quite, we have done it all a million times before, but there is a reason that alot of people will just not accept the directive to ignore the cadaver dog......well, many reasons least of all a child went missing, a cadaver dog alerted, it alerted nowhere else but somehow we are led to believe its all down to mushrooms and fraudulent dog handlers? and if it isn't then "just forget about it"...thats not how it works...if there was an unbiased and proven credible argument it mght happen but never has been one that has convinced me......the one and only time anyone will have an argument that Eddie was not alerting to remnant cadaver scent is if and when the child is ever found alive

To say that the dogs indicated a dead body of human origin, in 5A or in 27 Rua Das Flores or in the Scenic is not accurate.  They might or might not have. To state that they did, as a fact, is propaganda. As is to state that the cadaver dog alerting means nothing at all/useless/not evidence of anything

We have, at this point in time, no evidence that Madeleine is dead.  So discussing time for cadaver odour to develop from a human corpse is meaningless. Not really, its an exploration of a possibility and not without cause for concern...presumption of innocence notwithstanding...its a spanner in the works..***see article at end

If someone bled in 5A, whether such person was Madeleine, before Madeleine, or after Madeleine, no matter how long it takes for 'cadaver odour' to develop, there was ample time, from days to months, before the dogs were deployed. No proof that blood was the only thing Eddie alerted to...I notice you did not give a reason iyo as to his alert in the parents bedroom where when Keela was brought in was not "confirmed" as blood


Answers in red SIL

*** http://www.policek9.com/Fleck/Cadaver%20Dogs.pdf

Sorry to party poop all, have a good one
« Last Edit: December 24, 2015, 08:57:18 PM by mercury »

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #991 on: December 24, 2015, 08:29:53 PM »
Report says following the suspension of Chief Officer Graham Power.

http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2012/jun/28/jersey-secrecy-culture

Graham Power: 'I was suspended by the very government whose institutions were being investigated. You cannot get much more conflicted than that."

Before moving to Jersey to take charge of the island's police in 2000, Graham Power had served in the senior ranks of four other forces in a career spanning more than 30 years. A recipient of the Queen's Medal for distinguished service, he had been vetted by UK authorities to "top secret" level and was so well regarded that he had also been appointed an assessor for the body that selects chief officers for UK constabularies.

The initial suspension, which related to Power's management and supervision of a child abuse inquiry centred around Haut de la Garenne, a children's home on the island, continues to be a hugely controversial topic in Jersey. It's an episode which Jersey's critics see as a prime example of the way the island's elite treats those who dare to challenge their authority.

Power, as well as child abuse survivors the Guardian has spoken to on the island, claim that after his suspension, some victims lost faith in the investigation. He said: "After my suspension a police officer working in the incident room approached me in the street and told me that incident room staff were busy dealing with calls from victims who were distressed after hearing that I had been suspended and were saying that 'it would all be covered up again'. I have had similar messages from people close to victims and from individual victims who do not wish to be named."

Wiltshire police wrote the report and they were independent.

When I've time I will dig out the exact reference from the report that confirms, from the report of a technician of an Oxford Laboratory, that the piece of coconut Eddie reacted to was just that, a piece of coconut.

The exact reference is in the report I link to above.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #992 on: December 24, 2015, 08:36:02 PM »
Libel again. I suggest you read what the  report actual says rather than your preferences. The criticism is directed at the officers running the investigation not Grime. Please desist.

I have read precisely what the report says.  When I've time, I will dig out the precise reference of where Grime, specifically, is criticised.

In fact, I know I have given the reference to Brietta, and she may have it?

I am a little busy at the moment.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #993 on: December 24, 2015, 09:13:44 PM »
in response to mercury....


the alerts are meaningless because they tell us nothing...that is an undeniable fact..perhaps you can tell us what value the alerts have...what information they give us....you won't be able to

Offline Mr Gray

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #994 on: December 24, 2015, 09:20:09 PM »
.
Mercury posted..


.the one and only time anyone will have an argument that Eddie was not alerting to remnant cadaver scent is if and when the child is ever found alive .


That really is absolute rubbish...it is quite valid to believe that eddie did not alert to cadaver scent when...

1. His handler has not confirmed it...even when asked a direct question
2. There is no proof to support that he did

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #995 on: December 24, 2015, 09:30:48 PM »
Not helpful to the "Dogs Don't Lie" brigade.

I thought it rather like San Diego*. "It has something for everyone".*
"A K-9 cannot properly separate odors if s/he is rushed or hurried through this process".

*If you remember your ALF that is.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #996 on: December 24, 2015, 09:33:19 PM »
in response to mercury....


the alerts are meaningless because they tell us nothing...that is an undeniable fact..perhaps you can tell us what value the alerts have...what information they give us....you won't be able to
Do you work for BBC news? You ask a question then give the answer.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Mr Gray

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #997 on: December 24, 2015, 09:35:48 PM »
Do you work for BBC news? You ask a question then give the answer.

I give my answer and invite others to give theirs...it seems no one  including you can give an answer...all you can do is make sarcastic comments.

As no one has been able to give an answer it is fair to conclude I am right

Offline mercury

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #998 on: December 24, 2015, 10:32:08 PM »
.
Mercury posted..


.the one and only time anyone will have an argument that Eddie was not alerting to remnant cadaver scent is if and when the child is ever found alive .


That really is absolute rubbish...it is quite valid to believe that eddie did not alert to cadaver scent when...

1. His handler has not confirmed it...even when asked a direct question
2. There is no proof to support that he did

That really is absolute rubbish as neither is possible

But, all people are free to believe what they want (a right you seem to deny in a totalitarian way to some)

Merry xmas though
And have FUN



ferryman

  • Guest
Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #999 on: December 24, 2015, 11:18:01 PM »
Quote
3.10.11 We now deal with the introduction of Martin GRIME and his Enhanced
Victim Recovery Dog (EVRD) to Operation Rectangle. Operation
Haven has established through enquiry with the NPIA, that
Martin GRIME was an ACPO accredited dog handler whilst he was a
serving police officer, but forfeited accreditation upon his retirement in
July 2007. We mentioned that Mr GRIME remains on the ACPO
accredited list of experts though his EVRD is no longer accredited by
ACPO. Whilst Martin GRIME’s original contract to Jersey was for five
days, his actual deployment lasted for 130 days.
3.10.12 The forensic review carried out by    X of the NPIA
questioned the presence of Martin GRIME on site for such a long
time. X , was informed that Martin GRIME had been
acting as a Deputy Crime Scene Manager to Forensic Service
Manager X , at the request of DCO HARPER. The forensic
review noted Martin GRIME’s lack of formal training or qualifications
to perform the role of Deputy Forensic Service Manager and that to
utilise him in this role ‘cannot be recognised as good practice’. The
review also noted that ‘there was concern from some persons
interviewed that too much reliance had been placed on the dogs’. It is
accepted that dogs are ‘presumptive screening assets’ only and that
any alerts or indications they give must be forensically corroborated.
In addition, it is a fact that there were no concise terms of reference
for the deployment of Martin GRIME and his EVRD or his subsequent
use as a search advisor, apparently with the support of
DCO HARPER.
3.10.13 CO POWER himself states ‘the search dog seemed to play a
significant role in determining whether a specific location needed to
be examined further. I am not an expert on dogs or what they do’.
3.10.14 Again, there is a distinct lack of documentary evidence to show any
intrusive supervision of the SIO with regard to the continued search.
This Inquiry concludes that the actions of DCO HARPER and
Martin GRIME went unsupervised for some considerable time. To
Page 116 of 383


Supervision Highly Confidential – Personal Information
CO POWER’s credit, there is an e-mail exchange between him and
DCO HARPER dated 10 May 2008 in which CO POWER raises the
question of the continued use of Martin GRIME and his EVRD. He
says ‘Lenny, it has struck me for some time that he [Mr GRIME] is an
expensive resource who has more than his fair shared of down time’.
DCO HARPER replied in the same e-mail string ‘to be fair to him
though, he hasn’t got much down time as he is also the NPIA search
coordinator and is fully employed’. CO POWER replies ‘Thanks.
Better understood now’. CO POWER does not appear to pursue the
matter further.
3.10.15 However, DCO HARPER’s reply was not factually accurate.
Martin GRIME was neither an NPIA search advisor nor fully
employed. In his statement, Martin GRIME states that ‘I am a Subject
Matter Expert registered with the UK National Policing Improvement
Agency and specialist homicide canine search advisor… I advise
Domestic and International Law enforcement agencies on the
operational deployment of police dogs in the role of homicide
investigation. I develop methods of detecting forensically recoverable
evidence by the use of dogs and facilitate training’. His expertise lay
purely in the use of dogs in searching, not as a 'search co-ordinator'.
3.10.16 OFFICER X notes that during conversation with X, CO POWER
accepted that ‘the dog was ‘probably unreliable’ and that the dog
handler, GRIME, had too much influence over the enquiry, again,
Mr POWER didn’t say how he managed or dealt with that issue’. This
Inquiry has been unable to establish whether CO POWER made any
further attempts to supervise the SIO in this key part of the
investigation.
3.10.17 OFFICER X concludes ‘decisions should be made based on
professional policing judgement and evidence. When you look at the
facts, the excavation and searching of Haut De La Garenne… was
not justified’.

(Operation Havern)

Offline mercury

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #1000 on: December 24, 2015, 11:18:30 PM »
in response to mercury....


the alerts are meaningless because they tell us nothing...that is an undeniable fact..perhaps you can tell us what value the alerts have...what information they give us....you won't be able to
Just cos dogs cant speak doesnt mean ther indications are meaningless...they are at the very very least intellgence,get over it and stop makng a fool of yourself day in day out..time for new years resolutions? Stop coming across as a dictator...its quite  unpalatable lol...not even sure why im responding to your rubbsh...probably the last thread of hope of making you see a little or more sense, pontless task,now stop stalking cos youre getting creepy


Merry xmas

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #1001 on: December 24, 2015, 11:29:01 PM »
Answers in red SIL

*** http://www.policek9.com/Fleck/Cadaver%20Dogs.pdf

Sorry to party poop all, have a good one
"No proof that blood was the only thing Eddie alerted to...I notice you did not give a reason iyo as to his alert in the parents bedroom where when Keela was brought in was not "confirmed" as blood."

If you have a source that shows Keela in -
the parent's bedroom
the veranda outside the parents' bedroom
the garden underneath the parents' bedroom
then -
would you kindly provide a link to it as I would be most interested.  At least at the moment, I am not aware of any.

I have seen the longer video in which Martin Grime states that an alert, in this case Eddie, can be because of the way wind blows or perhaps because some source was there, but now is not.

The clothes that were alerted to after the search of 27 Rua da Flores are one option.  Kate's clothes, stored in the wardrobe of apartment 5A.  That happens to be a complex option, as the dogs did not alert to where these clothes were between 5A and 27 Rua das Flores.  In summary, probably no.

So let me think through the simple solution.  There is dead human blood in the living room and the air currents waft this into the parents' bedroom.  Eddie gets it in both places.  Keela gets it only in the living room.  I will let you decide if this is more likely.



 
What's up, old man?

Offline mercury

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #1002 on: December 24, 2015, 11:35:21 PM »
"No proof that blood was the only thing Eddie alerted to...I notice you did not give a reason iyo as to his alert in the parents bedroom where when Keela was brought in was not "confirmed" as blood."

If you have a source that shows Keela in -
the parent's bedroom

the veranda outside the parents' bedroom
the garden underneath the parents' bedroom
then -
would you kindly provide a link to it as I would be most interested.  At least at the moment, I am not aware of any.

I have seen the longer video in which Martin Grime states that an alert, in this case Eddie, can be because of the way wind blows or perhaps because some source was there, but now is not.

The clothes that were alerted to after the search of 27 Rua da Flores are one option.  Kate's clothes, stored in the wardrobe of apartment 5A.  That happens to be a complex option, as the dogs did not alert to where these clothes were between 5A and 27 Rua das Flores.  In summary, probably no.

So let me think through the simple solution.  There is dead human blood in the living room and the air currents waft this into the parents' bedroom.  Eddie gets it in both places.  Keela gets it only in the living room.  I will let you decide if this is more likely.

Keela is shown in the dog search video as searchng the parents bedroom, the rest, no, dont have video footage

PS Mr Grime  said an alert at a certain place by the cadaver dog  doesnt necessarily mean that was the source...just that possibly the elements of the source had gathered in a certain place....
« Last Edit: December 25, 2015, 12:13:42 AM by mercury »

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #1003 on: December 24, 2015, 11:56:05 PM »
I give my answer and invite others to give theirs...it seems no one  including you can give an answer...all you can do is make sarcastic comments.

As no one has been able to give an answer it is fair to conclude I am right

Incorrect. You have failed to take into account that some may feel it pointless to debate with you. Not you understand because they feel you have a towering intellect which is always correct rather that you sound like an old fashioned gramophone record with the needle stuck and tend to be abusive.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline mercury

Re: A Question of Propaganda.
« Reply #1004 on: December 24, 2015, 11:59:01 PM »
Incorrect. You have failed to take into account that some may feel it pointless to debate with you. Not you understand because they feel you have a towering intellect which is always correct rather that you sound like an old fashioned gramophone record with the needle stuck and tend to be abusive.


 *&*%£

Nail on head

Merry xmas alice have a good one x

Nite all

 @)(++(*