Author Topic: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?  (Read 61824 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #345 on: January 08, 2016, 01:53:06 PM »
If there had not been such Media interest, and the immediate presence of The British Ambassador then I do believe that at least Kate McCann would have been tortured into some kind of confession.  But Amaral saw his nemesis, and then proceeded to do the only other thing he could, in some vague hope of justifying the treatment of The Ciprianos.
 
Michael Cook was tortured and left in his own excretement, appearing in court with black eyes and broken teeth. And absolutely no one did anything about it.  Not even Britain.  This was not going to be allowed again.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #346 on: January 08, 2016, 02:02:31 PM »
If there had not been such Media interest, and the immediate presence of The British Ambassador then I do believe that at least Kate McCann would have been tortured into some kind of confession.  But Amaral saw his nemesis, and then proceeded to do the only other thing he could, in some vague hope of justifying the treatment of The Ciprianos.
 
Michael Cook was tortured and left in his own excretement, appearing in court with black eyes and broken teeth. And absolutely no one did anything about it.  Not even Britain.  This was not going to be allowed again.

Meanwhile, Rebelo was fiercely criticised (in certain quarters!) for leading a separate (Portuguese) investigation (the name of which escapes me) which led to no arrests and no successful conclusion, let alone convictions.

Which reinforces my impression (of Rebelo) that he conducts his investigations where the evidence leads (or doesn't!), not where his prejudices and personal inclinations takes him.

Rebelo is a real policeman.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #347 on: January 08, 2016, 02:40:23 PM »
Meanwhile, Rebelo was fiercely criticised (in certain quarters!) for leading a separate (Portuguese) investigation (the name of which escapes me) which led to no arrests and no successful conclusion, let alone convictions.

Which reinforces my impression (of Rebelo) that he conducts his investigations where the evidence leads (or doesn't!), not where his prejudices and personal inclinations takes him.

Rebelo is a real policeman.

Rebelo was stymied before he even began.  Which leads me to suspect that absolutely no one in The PJ on the Algarve was being monitored.  They were a law unto themselves.  No one was even remotely interested in what they were up to.
What has transpired since would suggest that steps are being taken.  But short of seriously castigating all of them at the time, then there wasn't much Rebelo could do.  More coward him.  He crept his way around it all.

Offline pegasus

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #348 on: January 08, 2016, 02:55:19 PM »
Rebelo was stymied before he even began.  Which leads me to suspect that absolutely no one in The PJ on the Algarve was being monitored.  They were a law unto themselves.  No one was even remotely interested in what they were up to.
What has transpired since would suggest that steps are being taken.  But short of seriously castigating all of them at the time, then there wasn't much Rebelo could do.  More coward him.  He crept his way around it all.
LP were working with Rebelo's PJ as proven by communications between them in Feb 2008.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #349 on: January 08, 2016, 03:15:41 PM »
LP were working with Rebelo's PJ as proven by communications between them in Feb 2008.

Much good did it do. And who exactly was Rebelo's PJ?  He didn't hang around in UK for long enough even to see David Payne's Rogatory Interview.  So you think that he didn't know that his PJ was prone to torture?

Every one knows that The Algarve PJ resorted to torture.  There have been enough incidents in the past.

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #350 on: January 08, 2016, 03:46:32 PM »
Difficult especially to get rid of a body successfully in a foreign country, in a very short time frame, in the dark and without the aid of transport I'm sure you'd agree.  Well you probably won't but there we are...

I agree it would be especially difficult but not impossible, however the bit that was being discussed at the beginning of this particular conversation was Cipriano.
You know, the old: well there wasn't a body, she had seven bells knocked out of her, there were no "forensics", there was only circumstantial evidence, the guy in charge was the same one who was in charge of the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
I was merely observing that there have been cases, in this country, where a verdict of murder was brought in where no body had been recovered there was no "forensics" and only circumstantial evidence. In fact a large number of criminal convictions rely on the cumulative effect of circumstantial evidence for their success rather than direct evidence.

"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #351 on: January 08, 2016, 03:56:57 PM »
I agree it would be especially difficult but not impossible, however the bit that was being discussed at the beginning of this particular conversation was Cipriano.
You know, the old: well there wasn't a body, she had seven bells knocked out of her, there were no "forensics", there was only circumstantial evidence, the guy in charge was the same one who was in charge of the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
I was merely observing that there have been cases, in this country, where a verdict of murder was brought in where no body had been recovered there was no "forensics" and only circumstantial evidence. In fact a large number of criminal convictions rely on the cumulative effect of circumstantial evidence for their success rather than direct evidence.

There doesn't seem to be any circumstantial evidence in the cipriano case

Offline Eleanor

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #352 on: January 08, 2016, 04:38:17 PM »
There doesn't seem to be any circumstantial evidence in the cipriano case

Oh, do come on.  Leonor was her Mother.  Isn't that enough?

Offline Carana

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #353 on: January 08, 2016, 05:42:48 PM »
I agree it would be especially difficult but not impossible, however the bit that was being discussed at the beginning of this particular conversation was Cipriano.
You know, the old: well there wasn't a body, she had seven bells knocked out of her, there were no "forensics", there was only circumstantial evidence, the guy in charge was the same one who was in charge of the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
I was merely observing that there have been cases, in this country, where a verdict of murder was brought in where no body had been recovered there was no "forensics" and only circumstantial evidence. In fact a large number of criminal convictions rely on the cumulative effect of circumstantial evidence for their success rather than direct evidence.

I'd agree that there may be the odd case in which sufficient evidence exists to convict someone, beyond a reasonable doubt, for murder without a body.

However - and this is my own criteria - I would have thought that whatever evidence did exist would need to be overwhelming in order to demonstrate, beyond a reasonable doubt that:

a) substantial evidence existed that the victim was in fact dead;

b) any such death was due to a third-party;

c) in the event of a) and b) that the death was more than an accident or manslaughter / negligent homicide (whichever definition is used in a particular jurisdiction);

d) investigative procedure had been diligently followed throughout;

e) sufficient evidence existed as to the perpretators in the event of the above;

f) the right to a fair trial had not been compromised.

What, in any of the above, supports how these convictions were arrived at?

Edited to add a further point.
« Last Edit: January 08, 2016, 05:48:22 PM by Carana »

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #354 on: January 08, 2016, 07:37:44 PM »
I'd agree that there may be the odd case in which sufficient evidence exists to convict someone, beyond a reasonable doubt, for murder without a body.

However - and this is my own criteria - I would have thought that whatever evidence did exist would need to be overwhelming in order to demonstrate, beyond a reasonable doubt that:

a) substantial evidence existed that the victim was in fact dead;

b) any such death was due to a third-party;

c) in the event of a) and b) that the death was more than an accident or manslaughter / negligent homicide (whichever definition is used in a particular jurisdiction);

d) investigative procedure had been diligently followed throughout;

e) sufficient evidence existed as to the perpretators in the event of the above;

f) the right to a fair trial had not been compromised.

What, in any of the above, supports how these convictions were arrived at?

Edited to add a further point.

Judge by your own criteria by all means however that way lies anarchy if we all want to do it and impose our own mores and punishments accordingly. I remain content that on balance individual cases will be judged on the basis of what ever law prevails in that particular jurisdiction. It ain't perfect but it's better than a bunch of yahoos who can't tell the difference between a paediatrician and a paedophile calling the shots.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Carana

Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #355 on: January 08, 2016, 08:11:03 PM »
Judge by your own criteria by all means however that way lies anarchy if we all want to do it and impose our own mores and punishments accordingly. I remain content that on balance individual cases will be judged on the basis of what ever law prevails in that particular jurisdiction. It ain't perfect but it's better than a bunch of yahoos who can't tell the difference between a paediatrician and a paedophile calling the shots.

Again, I'd agree in principle, but to take even my first point: there is no evidence that couldn't be successfully questioned by an averagely bright 10-year-old that she actually got home, let alone that she was massacred within it.

The "evidence" that she got home is one witness (not cross-examined) who stated the he/she saw her walking towards home while the witness was having a fag on a balcony somewhere in the vicinity of the church area. It was accepted by the court that, as a rule of common experience, children normally arrive home, and that therefore it was classified as a proven fact that she did as well.

- Could the witness have mistaken her for someone else? (Possibly not in a small village.)
- Could the witness have been lying? (Who knows?)
- While child abduction may be rare, seeing a child walking towards home is not a guarantee that the child actually did arrive back home.

That's for starters.


ETA: to remain on topic, in a police investigation without checks and balances (e.g, CCTV, recorded interviews with start and end times), recorded police brutality... the judicial system seems to have been dysfunctional.

Would the McCanns have been tortured had they been Portuguese? People had been beaten up in 2004 and Madeleine disappeared only 3 years later. So I don't find that implausible. On the other hand, I'm not aware of any cases of beatings in police custody since then. 
« Last Edit: January 08, 2016, 08:22:19 PM by Carana »

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #356 on: January 08, 2016, 09:12:20 PM »
I don't think the McCanns would have been tortured.  The PJ would not have dared tortured two intelligent British subjects because they would have known they'd never have gotten away with it, ignorant Portuguese peasants are much easier game.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #357 on: January 08, 2016, 09:15:05 PM »
I don't think the McCanns would have been tortured.  The PJ would not have dared tortured two intelligent British subjects because they would have known they'd never have gotten away with it, ignorant Portuguese peasants are much easier game.


XENOPHOBIC COMMENT.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #358 on: January 08, 2016, 09:24:30 PM »

XENOPHOBIC COMMENT.
So you don't agree that the Ciprianos are ignorant Portuguese peasants then?  Interesting...

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Would the McCanns have been tortured too had they been Portuguese?
« Reply #359 on: January 08, 2016, 09:25:56 PM »
So you don't agree that the Ciprianos are ignorant Portuguese peasants then?  Interesting...

As you well aware, I was referring to the people as a whole.