The confession was accepted by the court even though Correia's lawyer Marcos Correia objected to it which was his right. The judges undoubtedly heard the tape recording prior to it being played to the court and decided on balance that it was given freely and without coercion. Those are the facts, we are stuck with them, no amount of maybes and if only's can change that situation.
Bottom line is both Leonor and John Cipriano confessed at different stages of the proceedings to this dreadful crime for which they were ultimately found guilty on the evidence. If they were innocent as some claim they had every opportunity to give evidence to the court but they refused. They have nobody to blame but themselves.
Torture and the the
threat of torture are inextricably linked.
The fact that
photographs of tools
allegedly used to dismember Joana's body were produced as 'evidence', in its own right, says much about the quality of justice that convicted the pair.
If, indeed, Joana's body had been mutilated in the home, the home would have been, literally, teeming with her DNA. We know Portugal has a perfectly competent forensic laboratory.
Why was no effort made to ascertain Joana's blood, and DNA, if that's what happened?