Author Topic: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?  (Read 345066 times)

0 Members and 6 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1350 on: January 19, 2016, 07:16:55 PM »
It looks like you do not understand what the court means by proven facts
Proven by common experience
Not by evidence

I have no problem with some facts taken as proven: you produce clear evidence, e.g. a birth certificate and unless there's any major reason to doubt the authenticity, that can presumably be taken as fact.

Where I have an issue is the wand of "common experience" passed over so many points that simply weren't a) of a nature to constitute common experience or b) corroborated.


stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1351 on: January 19, 2016, 07:23:50 PM »
And the Unproven "Facts, which are much more damning in favour of a Miscarriage of Justice.

What "unproven" facts ?

Offline Eleanor

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1352 on: January 19, 2016, 07:24:52 PM »
What "unproven" facts ?

Don't be silly.  You know what they are.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1353 on: January 19, 2016, 07:41:31 PM »
Don't be silly.  You know what they are.

Why do you believe the words of a proven liar ?

Namely Cipriano, and of course her brother.

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1354 on: January 19, 2016, 07:42:07 PM »
What "unproven" facts ?

An unproven fact was the alleged motive: that the child was killed because she'd surprised them having sex.


A "proven" fact, based on "common experience", at random, was that:


ab) at a certain point in time, due to a motive that has not been exactly established, both arguidos started, conjointly, to successively hit minor CC on the head, prompting her to hit her head on the wall’s corner, being visible that she bled, from her mouth, her nose and her temple, due to the hits against the wall, which also caused the minor’s fall and her death, thus ceasing the arguidos’ activity;


My issue is that a) the allegation is not of a nature to be considered of "common experience"  and b) there was no forensic evidence to support it.

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1355 on: January 19, 2016, 07:44:23 PM »

That happened in the Jo Yeates case... but I think that we're discussing apples and oranges.

In the UK:
One issue appears to be what can be admitted as evidence for a jury to consider (the fact that Tabak had been viewing extreme pornography just prior to the events was considered to be off limits).

An out-of-date concept appears to be that the media are gagged from mentioning prior convictions - which anyone can google for themselves these days.

The reasoning, I presume, is to make the jury focus on the facts of the trial at hand and to avoid being influenced by potential prejudice.

None of that appears to be relevant to the concept of the "rules of common experience" in PT law, as far as I understand it. That seems to concern what any reasonable person could consider to be established fact. I simpy can't understand how the "facts" deemed to be proven under that premise equate to everyday experience of life.

I can understand one or two, but not the rest.

A body doesn't ooze much blood two hours after death... ok. But no one seems to have considered that, according to the reconstruction, the torso was sawn in half in the middle of the living room.

That would have to be one enormous clean-up job without anyone else noticing...

Does anyone seriously believe that blood would be the only substance to consider if that scenario had happened?

An unidentified and undated speck of blood at the back of a single fridge/freezer drawer is somehow proof of this? Seriously? That none of the occupants / visitors to this small home noticed that the fridge /freezer had been emptied?

The situation is that under US/UK law there are rules about what is admissible evidence and what isn't furthermore it is decided by the courts and specific advocates what is and what isn't admissible by arcane process not by the proles. Also there are rules governing presumptions and inferences. Once those rules are accepted as the norm in the UK/US system why should similar arcane processes be deemed unacceptable in the Romanesque system? Albeit in the Romanesque system what is admissible is principally at the the judges discretion. Most of the world is subject to a Romanesque system of law...... well it is the most common.

"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1356 on: January 19, 2016, 07:48:40 PM »
An unproven fact was the alleged motive: that the child was killed because she'd surprised them having sex.


A "proven" fact, based on "common experience", at random, was that:


ab) at a certain point in time, due to a motive that has not been exactly established, both arguidos started, conjointly, to successively hit minor CC on the head, prompting her to hit her head on the wall’s corner, being visible that she bled, from her mouth, her nose and her temple, due to the hits against the wall, which also caused the minor’s fall and her death, thus ceasing the arguidos’ activity;


My issue is that a) the allegation is not of a nature to be considered of "common experience"  and b) there was no forensic evidence to support it.


Well, rather obviously since Joana is dead and she was the witness as regards the above.....

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1357 on: January 19, 2016, 07:51:54 PM »

Well, rather obviously since Joana is dead and she was the witness as regards the above.....

Sorry, I don't think I follow...

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1358 on: January 19, 2016, 07:53:54 PM »
so how did the motive of incest come to light if it unproven...very strange

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1359 on: January 19, 2016, 08:02:11 PM »
The situation is that under US/UK law there are rules about what is admissible evidence and what isn't furthermore it is decided by the courts and specific advocates what is and what isn't admissible by arcane process not by the proles. Also there are rules governing presumptions and inferences. Once those rules are accepted as the norm in the UK/US system why should similar arcane processes be deemed unacceptable in the Romanesque system? Albeit in the Romanesque system what is admissible is principally at the the judges discretion. Most of the world is subject to a Romanesque system of law...... well it is the most common.

In this case, there were also four jurors.

The procedure appears clear as to who votes: the youngest to the eldest of the jurors, then the judges from the newest to the most senior.

However, I've read two conficting accounts as to what they actually vote on. According to one explanation, they go through all the points and decide whether they can be considered as fact or not; a different account of the procedure concerns coming to a conclusion about "questions".

The two are not the same... and I haven't yet found anything conclusive as to how the process does in fact work.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1360 on: January 19, 2016, 08:04:29 PM »
Why do you believe the words of a proven liar ?

Namely Cipriano, and of course her brother.

I am still trying to figure out what they actually said, rather than what The PJ said they said.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1361 on: January 19, 2016, 08:06:22 PM »

Well, rather obviously since Joana is dead and she was the witness as regards the above.....

What Proof do you have that Joana is dead.

Offline Carana

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1362 on: January 19, 2016, 08:06:58 PM »
so how did the motive of incest come to light if it unproven...very strange

Too many CSI episodes discussed over a water cooler? Who knows?

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1363 on: January 19, 2016, 08:10:42 PM »
Why do you believe the words of a proven liar ?

Namely Cipriano, and of course her brother.

it is very hard to know who is telling the truth...it seems  several PJ officers lied to cover up the torture

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Why is there so much support for Leonor Cipriano from McCann supporters?
« Reply #1364 on: January 19, 2016, 08:13:04 PM »
What Proof do you have that Joana is dead.


The counter argument works equally as well.

Let's start with the fact that the Cipriano siblings blame each other for the death of Joana.