Does Portugal have an Independent Police Complaints Commission, or anything similar?
There is a PJ Disciplinary Unit. I have yet to find confirmation as to whether it actively led its own inquiry into the saga or whether the sanctions were the result of the trial. An article does say that sanctions were applied following an investigation by the Unit.
I haven't found information about all of the officers likely to have been involved, either.
In 2005 Cristóvão got a 120-day "suspension" for "violation of duty" (in PT "suspension" appears to be one of a hierarchy of sanctions, not necessarily a preventive measure pending an inquiry). In 2007, he was apparently "asked to leave" according to the article, which would correspond to what is termed as "compulsory retirement", one level down from the highest sanction which is expulsion.
"A ministra da Justiça negou o recurso de Paulo Pereira Cristóvão, inspetor da Polícia Judiciária até 2007, a quem foi aplicada pena disciplinar por violação de deveres, após envolvimento nas agressões à mãe de Joana, criança desaparecida em 2004, no Algarve, noticia a Lusa."
(...)
O inquérito disciplinar foi-lhe instaurado em 2005 e, dois anos antes de Paulo Pereira Cristóvão ter pedido para abandonar a PJ, o diretor nacional adjunto decidiu aplicar a pena disciplinar agora confirmada pela ministra da Justiça, após a rejeição do recurso."
http://www.tvi24.iol.pt/sociedade/paulo-pereira-cristovao/ministra-nega-recurso-a-pereira-cristovao-de-pena-aplicada-pela-pjThis hit the news because it dragged on for so long...
Amaral also got a sanction, but I'm not entirely sure I understand the legal gibberish - I think it says that on appeal the sanction was reduced to a €500 fine.
However, I'm not sure whether the notice I found concerns the Cipriano or the Madeleine case, nor whether there is more than one as they aren't easy to find. As the appeals go on for so long, the date isn't really a clue.
Polícia Judiciária
Aviso (extrato) n.o 11666/2013
Nos termos e para os efeitos do disposto no n.o 3 do artigo 25 do Regulamento Disciplinar da Polícia Judiciária publicado no Decreto-Lei n.o 196/94 de 21 de julho, na impossibilidade, confirmada, de proceder à notificação pessoal, por ausência, em parte incerta, notifica-se o Coordenador de Investigação Criminal, na situação de aposentado, Licenciado Gonçalo de Sousa Amaral, que por despacho da Ministra da Justiça, de 26 de agosto de 2013, foi concedido provimento parcial do recurso hierárquico por si interposto do ato recorrido consubstanciado no despacho do Diretor Nacional Adjunto, de 30 de junho de 2010, tendo a pena disciplinar de multa no montante de 500,00 € sido mantida e a suspensão na sua execução sido reduzida de dois para o período mínimo de um ano, começando esta a produzir efeitos decorridos 15 dias após a publicação deste aviso no Diário da República.
6 de setembro de 2013. — Pela Diretora da Unidade, João Prata Augusto.
207241913http://legislacaoportuguesa.com/aviso-extrato-n-o-116662013-d-r-n-o-180-parte-c-serie-ii-de-2013-09-18/I was originally intrigued by this in the defamation / damages trial:
Criminal investigation officers,
retired for various reasons of disciplinary penalty application, retain special rights, being holders of an identification card for recognition of their quality and the rights they enjoy [paragraphs 1 and and 2 of article 149 of the Organic Law of the Judicial Police and Ordinance No. 96/2002 of 31 January].
The statute of the retirement [approved by Decree-Law 498/72 of 9 December] establishes, from its original wording in the respective artº 74, paragraph 1, that
the retired, apart from his right to a retirement pension, remains bound to the civil service, keeping the titles and the category of the position he held and the rights and duties that do not depend on being in activity.
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/v01.htmIt's possible, but not certain, that the €500 fine relates to the Cipriano case, but at some point he appears to have been "invited to find a new career" as well. That further sanction may well be related to the McCann case though.
Disciplinary sanctions:
http://www.dgpj.mj.pt/sections/leis-da-justica/pdf-ult/sections/leis-da-justica/pdf-ult/decreto-lei-n-196-94-de/downloadFile/file/DL196.94.pdf?nocache=1192191524.72