Author Topic: Wandering Off Topic  (Read 3200397 times)

0 Members and 126 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1230 on: June 17, 2016, 03:10:38 PM »

Dave, don't you yet realize, it isn't even known what happened to Madeleine  ?

you need to tell amaral that

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1231 on: June 17, 2016, 03:14:45 PM »
if the parents are ruled out then woke and wandered and abduction are the only real options...agreed

I asked you to provide a supporting calculation. That should be easy enough without having to ask me questions.
Let's see yer workings then I'll comment if it's worthwhile. Meanwhile it's up to you to substantiate your assertion.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1232 on: June 17, 2016, 03:44:05 PM »
if the parents are ruled out then woke and wandered and abduction are the only real options...agreed

Nope, you can't have woke & wandered without the McCanns being a pair of liars.


GM;   'she was tucked up in bed, errm... and there's no way she... she could have got out on her own.'
https://youtu.be/6Rw4S5o2KPY

KM;  'The shutter was up & the window was open, I'm not lying about that'
https://youtu.be/WLvnfcl-Zkg?t=1369


Christian Brueckner Fan Club

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1233 on: June 17, 2016, 04:00:34 PM »
Nope, you can't have woke & wandered without the McCanns being a pair of liars.


GM;   'she was tucked up in bed, errm... and there's no way she... she could have got out on her own.'
https://youtu.be/6Rw4S5o2KPY

KM;  'The shutter was up & the window was open, I'm not lying about that'
https://youtu.be/WLvnfcl-Zkg?t=1369

They are contradictory statements at the very least.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1234 on: June 17, 2016, 04:28:06 PM »
I asked you to provide a supporting calculation. That should be easy enough without having to ask me questions.
Let's see yer workings then I'll comment if it's worthwhile. Meanwhile it's up to you to substantiate your assertion.

I would prefer to break it down into chunks.....I'm happy to answer your question....so can we agree on some basics.
if the parents are ruled out then that leaves w@w and abduction...agreed

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1235 on: June 17, 2016, 04:32:25 PM »
I would prefer to break it down into chunks.....I'm happy to answer your question....so can we agree on some basics.
if the parents are ruled out then that leaves w@w and abduction...agreed

If she w@w, then who otw?

(opened the window)
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1236 on: June 17, 2016, 04:34:12 PM »
If she w@w, then who otw?

(opened the window)

I haven't got that far yet

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1237 on: June 17, 2016, 04:47:24 PM »
I would prefer to break it down into chunks.....I'm happy to answer your question....so can we agree on some basics.
if the parents are ruled out then that leaves w@w and abduction...agreed

OK lets break it down into chunks :
Chunk 1: MM disappeared without trace on 3rd May 2007. The police could find no evidence to point to any specific cause.
Chunk:2 Your assertion above: "there seems to be enough to rule out the parents....nothing found in nine years and if the parents are ruled out abduction is odds on".
Chunk 3: Will be your substantiation of that assertion as I requested and as in accordance with forum rules.
Chunk4: Will be comments by members , possibly including me, on your substantiation.
Your move
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1238 on: June 17, 2016, 04:54:10 PM »
OK lets break it down into chunks :
Chunk 1: MM disappeared without trace on 3rd May 2007. The police could find no evidence to point to any specific cause.
Chunk:2 Your assertion above: "there seems to be enough to rule out the parents....nothing found in nine years and if the parents are ruled out abduction is odds on".
Chunk 3: Will be your substantiation of that assertion as I requested and as in accordance with forum rules.
Chunk4: Will be comments by members , possibly including me, on your substantiation.
Your move
there seems to be enough to rule out the parents....nothing found in nine years and if the parents are ruled out abduction is odds on

good that I asked the question...which part of the statement would you like an assertion for...

]there seems to be enough to rule out the parents....nothing found in nine years
   note I have used the word seems.....parents do not seem to be being investigated and Redwood has said they are not suspects...that seems to rule them out.....

and if the parents are ruled out abduction is odds on....or this part






stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1239 on: June 17, 2016, 05:36:35 PM »
there seems to be enough to rule out the parents....nothing found in nine years and if the parents are ruled out abduction is odds on

good that I asked the question...which part of the statement would you like an assertion for...

]there seems to be enough to rule out the parents....nothing found in nine years
   note I have used the word seems.....parents do not seem to be being investigated and Redwood has said they are not suspects...that seems to rule them out.....

and if the parents are ruled out abduction is odds on....or this part

The crime if any, is unknown.

The last known people to see Madeleine, where the mccanns.

On that basis alone, how can you discount them, as their accounts of events VARY.

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1240 on: June 17, 2016, 05:37:37 PM »
there seems to be enough to rule out the parents....nothing found in nine years and if the parents are ruled out abduction is odds on

good that I asked the question...which part of the statement would you like an assertion for...

]there seems to be enough to rule out the parents....nothing found in nine years
   note I have used the word seems.....parents do not seem to be being investigated and Redwood has said they are not suspects...that seems to rule them out.....

and if the parents are ruled out abduction is odds on....or this part

Are you now saying there are two assertions/postulations call it what you will ?

OK so let's make a stipulation that the parents were not involved.
On the basis of the parents not being involved your assertion is that abduction is odds on. The accepted definition of odds on being "more likely than evens".
If the parents were not involved there are two other possibilities: woke and wandered never to be seen again or abducted. So lets see yer calcs for arriving at "more likely than evens" for the abduction possibility. Or if you can't do that the calculations for longer odds on woke and wandered will do ...............
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1241 on: June 17, 2016, 06:46:21 PM »
The crime if any, is unknown.

The last known people to see Madeleine, where the mccanns.

On that basis alone, how can you discount them, as their accounts of events VARY.

Cite for vary

Offline pegasus

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1242 on: June 18, 2016, 02:15:58 AM »
Statement of GNR handler Fernandes talking about the dog Rex's behaviour on 4th May

"after the dogs were given this scent from the towel and near apartment 5A of block 5, the first sniffer dog headed to the door of that apartment."

Dogs can detect the direction of a scent trail.
IMO the PJ officer supervising should have unlocked the wooden door and allowed the dog to continue into the apartment.
« Last Edit: June 18, 2016, 02:19:34 AM by pegasus »

Offline Benice

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1243 on: June 18, 2016, 11:07:12 AM »
You may have noticed that this couple are very determined and sure of themselves. They 'knew' immediately what had happened to their daughter and they told the world about it. They told everyone that the shutters had been forced and their daughter taken. Gerry told his relatives there were paedophile gangs in Portugal and they had taken Madeline.

When it emerged that the shutters were undamaged and that they had left their children home alone in an unlocked apartment they glossed over that and carried on regardless.

They don't 'do' guilt.

Kate presumed the shutters must have been forced open - because as far as they knew they were locked.

Kate was immediately convinced  that an intruder had entered the apartment via the window.  Of course she thought her daughter had been taken.   She would have been abnormal not to have  thought that.

 Their relatives and friends were not there - and put their own interpretations of what 2  traumatised parents were telling them.   Chinese whispers ensued.     To claim that Gerry said Madeleine had definitely been taken by a paedaphile gang - on the strength of a witness who admitted he did not hear the whole conversation - or the exact words spoken but said what he heard was .... 'along the lines of....' is an example of chinese whispers on your part IMO.

When I first heard that Madeleine had disappeared - I immediately thought she had been taken by a paedaphile - and so did everyone else I knew.  That is the most common scenario in these cases.

As for they don't 'do' guilt.  They had said more than once that  they will carry the guilt of what happened with them for the rest of their lives - what more do you want.

I notice you make no allowances at all for the shock and trauma they were suddenly plunged into - and talk as if they were calmly telling people what they wanted them to believe - even though  (if they were guilty)  they would know without doubt that the shutters had not been smashed/jemmied - and the police would find them to be undamaged.     So why on earth would they want to convince the PJ or anyone else  - that they had been telling lies?

As for this couple being 'very determined and sure of themselves'.  Yes - they are sure Madeleine was abducted and they are determined to find out what happened to her and have been doing just that for the last 9 years.

That is not what guilty people would do - or even want to do.  They would want the whole thing to sink into obscurity ASAP.

AIMHO
 
The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline G-Unit

Re: Wandering Off Topic
« Reply #1244 on: June 18, 2016, 01:18:54 PM »
Kate presumed the shutters must have been forced open - because as far as they knew they were locked.

Kate was immediately convinced  that an intruder had entered the apartment via the window.  Of course she thought her daughter had been taken.   She would have been abnormal not to have  thought that.

 Their relatives and friends were not there - and put their own interpretations of what 2  traumatised parents were telling them.   Chinese whispers ensued.     To claim that Gerry said Madeleine had definitely been taken by a paedaphile gang - on the strength of a witness who admitted he did not hear the whole conversation - or the exact words spoken but said what he heard was .... 'along the lines of....' is an example of chinese whispers on your part IMO.

When I first heard that Madeleine had disappeared - I immediately thought she had been taken by a paedaphile - and so did everyone else I knew.  That is the most common scenario in these cases.

As for they don't 'do' guilt.  They had said more than once that  they will carry the guilt of what happened with them for the rest of their lives - what more do you want.

I notice you make no allowances at all for the shock and trauma they were suddenly plunged into - and talk as if they were calmly telling people what they wanted them to believe - even though  (if they were guilty)  they would know without doubt that the shutters had not been smashed/jemmied - and the police would find them to be undamaged.     So why on earth would they want to convince the PJ or anyone else  - that they had been telling lies?

As for this couple being 'very determined and sure of themselves'.  Yes - they are sure Madeleine was abducted and they are determined to find out what happened to her and have been doing just that for the last 9 years.

That is not what guilty people would do - or even want to do.  They would want the whole thing to sink into obscurity ASAP.

AIMHO
 

Why would they assume the shutters were locked?  There is no evidence that the shutter and window were open, still less than an intruder opened them, so your opinion of Kate's opinion relies solely on her and her husband telling the truth.

The nature of Chinese whispers is that they change as they are repeated. The four people who were informed of the broken shutters told the same story. You think Mr MacKenzie misheard? What a strange word to mishear.

I know what they've said, but people don't always mean what they say, you know.

The shock and trauma is speculation, although it would have been present no matter what occurred. Cause unknown. The PJ seem to have been immaterial - it was those back in the UK who needed to be told all about it very early on. All that worry spread around even while their friends were still searching for her. All the phone calls to be made had she been found.

Alex Woolfall said abduction was not discussed with him at the beginning, woke and wandered was, so they seem to have said different things to different people. How better to demonstrate your innocence than to start and maintain a worldwide search for your missing child?

Facts exist, but can be interpreted in different ways.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0