Wandering Off Topic

[Brietta]

Don't forget Gerry & Jerry not seeing Tanner

Perhaps  nobody saw anybody else, including Tanner.

They don't count.  Gerry saw Jes.  Jes saw Gerry.  Just in case anyone thinks they weren't there Jane saw them both.  Jane would have been invisible if the Irish teenager who saw all hadn't seen her.  Did anyone see the Sperreys in the street ??? or anyone else who ate in the Tapas that evening.

[Vertigo Swirl]

WOW.  There can only be one conclusion.  EVERYONE was in on it.  A bit like “Murder On the Orient Express”.  I solved it.

[jassi]

They don't count. Gerry saw Jes.  Jes saw Gerry. Just in case anyone thinks they weren't there Jane saw them both.  Jane would have been invisible if the Irish teenager who saw all hadn't seen her.  Did anyone see the Sperreys in the street ??? or anyone else who ate in the Tapas that evening.

I'm sure the Carpenters saw each other as well.

[Brietta]

I'm sure the Carpenters saw each other as well.

Can you reeeeeeeally be sure 👽👽👽👽👽👽👽 it is all very strange after all.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I'm sure the Carpenters saw each other as well.

Great band.

[G-Unit]

They don't count.  Gerry saw Jes.  Jes saw Gerry.  Just in case anyone thinks they weren't there Jane saw them both.  Jane would have been invisible if the Irish teenager who saw all hadn't seen her.  Did anyone see the Sperreys in the street ??? or anyone else who ate in the Tapas that evening.

What Irish teenager?

[Brietta]

What Irish teenager?

The Irish teenager who saw it all but who no-one saw just as no-one saw anyone else on the street that night.

[ShiningInLuz]

The Irish teenager who saw it all but who no-one saw just as no-one saw anyone else on the street that night.

If you are reduced to saying Aoife Smith saw it all when in reality she was dining with her family in the Dolphin, then this forum has been reduced to a shambles.

British tracker dogs that are not trained to track, followed by a mysterious Irish teenager.

Not a good day, was it?  Perhaps your Thanksgiving turkey went down better?

[sadie]

If you are reduced to saying Aoife Smith saw it all when in reality she was dining with her family in the Dolphin, then this forum has been reduced to a shambles.

British tracker dogs that are not trained to track, followed by a mysterious Irish teenager.

Not a good day, was it?  Perhaps your Thanksgiving turkey went down better?

Nah, not Aoife.

I think that Brietta is referring to a teenage girl who was in the alleyway catching a quick fag away from her family.   It was reported in the early days and there are sufficient people here who will know about it, so I am not even trying for a cite.

[Brietta]

If you are reduced to saying Aoife Smith saw it all when in reality she was dining with her family in the Dolphin, then this forum has been reduced to a shambles.

British tracker dogs that are not trained to track, followed by a mysterious Irish teenager.

Not a good day, was it?  Perhaps your Thanksgiving turkey went down better?

Aoife Smith ??? who mentioned Aoife ... as the song goes ... only you  ... although the celebrated duo of Reis and Levy might possibly be able to tell you far more about the Irish teenager than I ever could.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3550.msg134591#msg134591
Interesting thread that one. 

I was enthralled to find you share Holly's 'thing' about witness statements and incrimination.
Snip
If you are correct that they were visiting 605, an excellent place to monitor the Tapas bar up to the rear of 5A, then they have put themselves into the suspect box.  Right place, right time, car to whizz Madeleine away.

Parked cars? Standard.  I suspect this helps to explain the Tannerman sighting. 
_______________________________________________________________________

As I said, interesting and a thread well worth revisiting. Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3550.msg228314#msg228314

[misty]

As I said, interesting and a thread well worth revisiting. Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3550.msg228314#msg228314
_______________________________________________________________________

Looking at that topic, there was an observation by DCI regarding the spelling of Gerry's name in Martin Smith's Jan 2008 statement...all in English & presumably signed by Martin as correct.
Why is Gerry referred to as "Gerard" 4 times?
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P16/16_VOLUME_XVIa_Page_4136.jpg
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3550.msg228331#msg228331

[G-Unit]

The Irish teenager who saw it all but who no-one saw just as no-one saw anyone else on the street that night.

The Irish teenager who may or may not have actually existed, you mean? I was discussing real people.

[Brietta]

The Irish teenager who may or may not have actually existed, you mean? I was discussing real people.

Just because they are not real people does that mean they do not exist particularly if married to a grain of truth; Goncalo Amaral by his account speaks to many of them while respecting their right to privacy by keeping them all anonymous.  Whether they may or may not exist has never been questioned by the sceptics who comment on them.

[G-Unit]

Just because they are not real people does that mean they do not exist particularly if married to a grain of truth; Goncalo Amaral by his account speaks to many of them while respecting their right to privacy by keeping them all anonymous.  Whether they may or may not exist has never been questioned by the sceptics who comment on them.

The Irish teenager was a rumour imo.

[Brietta]

The Irish teenager was a rumour imo.

Oh ... I would never have guessed.  Why do you think the rumour might have been started by Reis who first reported it.