Wandering Off Topic

[Miss Taken Identity]

Rubbish... When do you think it stopped.. The year previously Kate contributed over 80,000 from the sale of her book

It is NOT rubbish at all. They set up a private company to raise money- Simple!   The public became more aware of what was really going on as did the Vatican and other celebrities.

[kizzy]

So definitely for breaking the law, on judicial secrecy being one reason

Unfortunately half my post was missing - as it wasn't edited must have been my mistake.

GA made a mistake - unprofesional or fustration.

But is there any wonder he was frustrated - with all the interference from the UK


TOTL chapter 6
SNIP
On May 14th, Kate Healy is indignant about the attitude of the liaison officer, who asks her where her daughter is. Neither she nor her husband accepts anyone doubting their word. The officer will be sent packing - and his colleague too - a week after his arrival. That attitude is, to say the least, shocking on the part of parents confronted by such a situation, that, what is more, is in a foreign country. Those two police officers, who distinguished themselves through long experience in the management of situations of kidnap and abduction, had been, all the same, entirely at their disposal; they provided daily logistical and legal support, and afforded them all the help they could have needed.

Curiously, the English do not consider it expedient to disclose the incident and the PJ are not informed. Myself, I only learn of it indirectly. Finally, a solution is found quickly: the two men are replaced by a Portuguese man who speaks fluent English.


SNIP
As time went by, we noticed that a certain number of the police officers sent to Portugal were poorly informed about the progress of the investigation. One of them who - like the majority - was coming to Portugal for the first time, was wearing a green and yellow rubber wrist band, bought for £2, which he played with nervously. The inscription read, "Look for Madeleine." Some of his colleagues told him that he would soon get rid of it. As a matter of fact, he took it off as soon as he got properly into the investigation and he had learned about the evidence placing doubt on the theory of abduction.


According to some on here the mcns made a mistake - that Maddie probably paid for with her life. IMO

[Lace]

Isn't it strange how Amaral tries to make out the British were suspicious of the McCann's,  yet it was his explosive anger at the idea that the Police wanted to follow the line of abduction that got him taken off the case.   Which is it?

[The General]

Isn't it strange how Amaral tries to make out the British were suspicious of the McCann's,  yet it was his explosive anger at the idea that the Police wanted to follow the line of abduction that got him taken off the case.   Which is it?

Neither.

[Lace]

Neither.

Please explain.

[kizzy]

Isn't it strange how Amaral tries to make out the British were suspicious of the McCann's,  yet it was his explosive anger at the idea that the Police wanted to follow the line of abduction that got him taken off the case.   Which is it?

Why do you call it explosive anger - have you a site for that or is that just what you think

Using the word explosive L is OTT in my opinion - unless you can prove otherwise that is.

[Lace]

Why do you call it explosive anger - have you a site for that or is that just what you think

Using the word explosive L is OTT in my opinion - unless you can prove otherwise that is.

The explosive outburst led to the first intervention by the Portuguese government, in a very public reprimand by the Justice Minister Alberto Costa.

[Lace]

https://newsoutlines.blogspot.com/2007/10/madeleine-detective-kicked-off-case.html

[The General]

https://newsoutlines.blogspot.com/2007/10/madeleine-detective-kicked-off-case.html

So not sacked at all then.
If Gerald, a cardiac consultant, is moved from Case A to Case B, is he 'sacked' from Case A?
Was Amaral 'sacked' from the case he was on before MM to lead this investigation?

But I get it; the utter desperation to smear, I understand. I'd do the same. I feel you bro.

[G-Unit]

The explosive outburst led to the first intervention by the Portuguese government, in a very public reprimand by the Justice Minister Alberto Costa.

It was Ribeiro who removed him from the case. He was also given to opening his mouth inappropriately.

Portugal's most senior policeman has apologised to his bosses over claims police rushed into making Kate and Gerry McCann suspects in daughter Madeleine's disappearance.

Alipio Ribeiro said he should have been more cautious in discussing the case and told Minister of Justice Alberto Costa he had a "slip of the tongue".
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/top-portugal-cop-alipio-ribeiro-292328

[kizzy]

The explosive outburst led to the first intervention by the Portuguese government, in a very public reprimand by the Justice Minister Alberto Costa.

Are they your words/opinion or someone else's L

If someone else - please show your source of info.

[kizzy]

Who do you think the Powers that be ae kizzy ?

For what reason do you think they took him off the case ?

The part I missed Sadie off my reply.

Political powers IMO
"My removal was a political issue," says Gonçalo Amaral

Gonçalo Amaral, the former Judiciary Police inspector responsible for the case is another of the faces and voices of the documentary. Just like for Moita Flores for Gonçalo Amaral there was also "no evidence that pointed to an abduction. However, there was a need to continue the investigation," he argues when questioned on the two hours documentary, recalling that children's bed sheets looked "as if no one had slept on them".

Hypothesizing that both Maddie and the twin brothers were under Calpol, a medicine that helps them(children) fall asleep, the former inspector reinforces publicly again that they have come to the conclusion that "this would have been an accidental death" and has no doubts that the removal from the case that he was obliged "was a political issue."

With several testimonies including Pinto Monteiro, the then Attorney-General of the Republic, in a statement, the channel underlines that "The Madeleine McCann Mystery" dissects several lines of investigation that have been "known over the past 12 years, but were never conclusive.

[Lace]

So not sacked at all then.
If Gerald, a cardiac consultant, is moved from Case A to Case B, is he 'sacked' from Case A?
Was Amaral 'sacked' from the case he was on before MM to lead this investigation?

But I get it; the utter desperation to smear, I understand. I'd do the same. I feel you bro.

Did I say sacked?  I said taken off the case. [bro]

[Brietta]

Are they your words/opinion or someone else's L

If someone else - please show your source of info.

You appear to have missed ... http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7060.msg572169#msg572169

Snip
  ... Kate and Gerry have constantly said they are very willing to co-operate fully with the Portuguese authorities.

They will continue to do so regardless of who is in charge of the hunt for Madeleine." The bombshell came after Amaral accused British police of shielding the McCanns.

He claimed they were only pursuing leads that could help clear the couple, and were hampering his investigation into the four-year-old's disappearance from her family's holiday apartment in the the Algarve.

The explosive outburst led to the first intervention by the Portuguese government, in a very public reprimand by the Justice Minister Alberto Costa.

Last night a Portuguese police source described Amaral's remarks as "the straw that broke the camel's back".

He had breached Portuguese law and broken his silence over the Madeleine case, claiming:

"The British police have only been working on what the McCann couple want them to and what suits them most." The McCanns have been warned they face jail if they speak about the case – but Amaral appeared unconcerned by the secrecy laws as he sneered at a line of inquiry being followed by Leicestershire Police.

Amaral said a tip-off sent to Prince Charles's website that Madeleine may have been snatched by a former employee at the Ocean Club complex had "no credibility whatsoever".

He told Portuguese newspaper Diario de Noticias: "The Ocean Club is in Praia da Luz, not in London.

"That means that anything in respect to the complex and the employees – current or ex – has been or is being investigated by the Policia Judiciaria.

"It won't be an email, and an anonymous one at that, which will distract our line of investigation." He even claimed the tipoff was created by the McCanns.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7060.msg572169#msg572169

[sadie]

The part I missed Sadie off my reply.

Political powers IMO
"My removal was a political issue," says Gonçalo Amaral

Gonçalo Amaral, the former Judiciary Police inspector responsible for the case is another of the faces and voices of the documentary. Just like for Moita Flores for Gonçalo Amaral there was also "no evidence that pointed to an abduction. However, there was a need to continue the investigation," he argues when questioned on the two hours documentary, recalling that children's bed sheets looked "as if no one had slept on them".

Hypothesizing that both Maddie and the twin brothers were under Calpol, a medicine that helps them(children) fall asleep, the former inspector reinforces publicly again that they have come to the conclusion that "this would have been an accidental death" and has no doubts that the removal from the case that he was obliged "was a political issue."

With several testimonies including Pinto Monteiro, the then Attorney-General of the Republic, in a statement, the channel underlines that "The Madeleine McCann Mystery" dissects several lines of investigation that have been "known over the past 12 years, but were never conclusive.

Thanks for your response Kizzy

But you are just quoting Amarals own excuses as to why he was removed.  Can we have something with some real sources and weight attached instead of Amarals, IMO, fantacies attempting to support himself.


Let's face it, Amarals word doesn't carry much value, does it?   After all he is a convicted purjorer.