Wandering Off Topic

[jassi]

They must have all moved on and got a life, unlike us saddoes.

Oh LOL very true though Vs.

What I don't understand thou [no not Chinese writing]

Is why you feel the need to constantly defend the mccs when it seems they have all the protection they need.

Also getting on with there lives, when it is Maddie who had neither.

Gerry has established a successful career in academia and is certainly getting on with his life.
Not so sure about Kate.

[Vertigo Swirl]

They must have all moved on and got a life, unlike us saddoes.

Oh LOL very true though Vs.

What I don't understand thou [no not Chinese writing]

Is why you feel the need to constantly defend the mccs when it seems they have all the protection they need.

Also getting on with there lives, when it is Maddie who had neither.

Ask yourself why you feel the need to constantly attack the McCanns when it seems they already have more than enough detractors and then maybe you will see the answer.

[Erngath]

Ask yourself why you feel the need to constantly attack the McCanns when it seems they already have more than enough detractors and then maybe you will see the answer.

Possibly not.

[Robittybob1]

Possibly not.

It appears to be impossible to make progress on this case.

[The General]

It appears to be impossible to make progress on this case.

It will be that way until the main protagonists (and pick your protagonist) tell the truth.

[Robittybob1]

It will be that way until the main protagonists (and pick your protagonist) tell the truth.

I'd have to think about what you mean by "the main protagonists"? 

[The General]

I'd have to think about what you mean by "the main protagonists"?

Well at least on person knows the truth. That person is either lying continually, in a vegetative state or dead.
Let's hope it's the former.
But I don't think it's CB.

[Mr Gray]

Well at least on person knows the truth. That person is either lying continually, in a vegetative state or dead.
Let's hope it's the former.
But I don't think it's CB.

Why don't you think it's CB

[The General]

Why don't you think it's CB

A number of reasons, but, despite him being a decent fit profile wise, they would have proved the link by now.
His total lack of attempting to evade justice is either irredeemably idiotic or an audacious act of Machiavellian brinkmanship, the like of which criminal investigation has hitherto not encountered.
The reliance on the jailhouse snitches, then the apparent under-handed tactic of a plant inside the nick, smacks of desperation. Pumping snitches for information gets you only so far, then they start going all Stephen King on yo ass.
Couple that with the searches that clearly drew a blank (or they would have moved by now) and the total lack of movement since June despite a massive publicity campaign, then it's all but over bar the shouting.

....oh and, in my opinion, MM wasn't abducted.

[Mr Gray]

A number of reasons, but, despite him being a decent fit profile wise, they would have proved the link by now.
His total lack of attempting to evade justice is either irredeemably idiotic or an audacious act of Machiavellian brinkmanship, the like of which criminal investigation has hitherto not encountered.
The reliance on the jailhouse snitches, then the apparent under-handed tactic of a plant inside the nick, smacks of desperation. Pumping snitches for information gets you only so far, then they start going all Stephen King on yo ass.
Couple that with the searches that clearly drew a blank (or they would have moved by now) and the total lack of movement since June despite a massive publicity campaign, then it's all but over bar the shouting.

....oh and, in my opinion, MM wasn't abducted.

I think you have it away at the end..I think the main reason sceptics dismiss CB is because they are hooked on abduction.
We need to wait and see what Wolters has...I can't see him saying what he has without evidence to back it up.,..I think he has proof Maddie was abducted...

[The General]

I think you have it away at the end..I think the main reason sceptics dismiss CB is because they are hooked on abduction.
We need to wait and see what Wolters has...I can't see him saying what he has without evidence to back it up.,..I think he has proof Maddie was abducted...

Hey, if he has, great. But he's doing a remarkable job of showing the world he's got very little.
I have a theory that fits HCW's assertions that doesn't involve abduction, and also fits with CB's movements / lack of evasion. He might be a player, he might not.

[Mr Gray]

Hey, if he has, great. But he's doing a remarkable job of showing the world he's got very little.
I have a theory that fits HCW's assertions that doesn't involve abduction, and also fits with CB's movements / lack of evasion. He might be a player, he might not.

I think you perception of HCW is severely influenced by your disbelief in abduction. I think abduction is odds on

[The General]

I think you perception of HCW is severely influenced by your disbelief in abduction. I think abduction is odds on

I believe you are wrong in your assertion.
I've used the data HCW has provided to try to fit it in to all possibilities.
If he would have said he had evidence of an abduction and left it there, I'd be intrigued.
Unfortunately, once he name-dropped CB it slowly transpired that it didn't fit together, as I described above.

[G-Unit]

I think you perception of HCW is severely influenced by your disbelief in abduction. I think abduction is odds on

Abduction is a theory suggested and promoted by Madeleine's parents. It may have happened, but there's no definitive evidence that it did. One of the reasons people have doubts, imo, is the refusal by her parents to consider any other possibility.

[Mr Gray]

Abduction is a theory suggested and promoted by Madeleine's parents. It may have happened, but there's no definitive evidence that it did. One of the reasons people have doubts, imo, is the refusal by her parents to consider any other possibility.

You seem to think that the only reason abduction is being investigated is because of the parents wishes...which is ridiculous imo.
Looking at all the evidence I would say abduction is by far the most likely and it seems both SY and the Germans agree...I think HCW may well have proof of abduction...we will see