Wandering Off Topic

[Vertigo Swirl]

Abduction is a theory suggested and promoted by Madeleine's parents. It may have happened, but there's no definitive evidence that it did. One of the reasons people have doubts, imo, is the refusal by her parents to consider any other possibility.

What a ludicrous suggestion IMO.

[faithlilly]

https://omny.fm/shows/maddie/theyve-taken-her

[Mr Gray]

https://omny.fm/shows/maddie/theyve-taken-her

Ive alraedy commneted on it...Wolters has said his strong evidence is neither the phone pings or  a witness statement....so sceptics can stop imagining it is

[Robittybob1]

Ive alraedy commneted on it...Wolters has said his strong evidence is neither the phone pings or  a witness statement....so sceptics can stop imagining it is

I'm looking forward to the day you say something new!   

[Mr Gray]

I'm looking forward to the day you say something new!

That is new Rob...don't you realise that.....and quite significant

I've said the strong evidence is not the phone or witness statements...some posters have said I was wrong...now Wolters has confirmed I am right

It's the rest of the forum that is stuck in the past...the Smith sighting....48 questions and Amarals theory

[kizzy]

That is new Rob...don't you realise that.....and quite significant

I've said the strong evidence is not the phone or witness statements...some posters have said I was wrong...now Wolters has confirmed I am right

It's the rest of the forum that is stuck in the past...the Smith sighting....48 questions and Amarals theory

At least GA spoke from the police files.

What HCW has is just words words words....nothing else.

[Anthro]

At least GA spoke from the police files.

What HCW has is just words words words....nothing else.

HCW is speaking from the BKA files.

[jassi]

HCW is speaking from the BKA files.

How would we know? They haven't been released to the public, any more than the OG ones have.

[Mr Gray]

At least GA spoke from the police files.

What HCW has is just words words words....nothing else.

GA spoke from files that didnt understand the evidence...you dont seem to understand that. HCW is speaking for the german police....who I would think do understand the evidence. They convicted CB for rape where the PJ failed

[Anthro]

How would we know? They haven't been released to the public, any more than the OG ones have.

Mr Wolters is the prosecutor, therefore he would not necessarily know all the evidence and detail the BKA has, in my opinion. It would be interesting if there’s an interview with the lead investigator of the BKA.

[faithlilly]

GA spoke from files that didnt understand the evidence...you dont seem to understand that. HCW is speaking for the german police....who I would think do understand the evidence. They convicted CB for rape where the PJ failed

A professional prosecutor, rather than a glory hunter, wouldn’t be talking to Portuguese television programmes and obscure podcasts about the case. He is an embarrassment to the German judicial system.

[Mr Gray]

A professional prosecutor, rather than a glory hunter, wouldn’t be talking to Portuguese television programmes and obscure podcasts about the case. He is an embarrassment to the German judicial system.

The fact that you are impressed by Amaral shows your opinion on police isn't worth a lot...imo

Perhaps if he covered up a beating by his men to extract s confession from CB you would be more impressed

[Brietta]

Mr Wolters is the prosecutor, therefore he would not necessarily know all the evidence and detail the BKA has, in my opinion. It would be interesting if there’s an interview with the lead investigator of the BKA.

I agree, Anthro.

In my opinion the Germans appear to be very hierarchical and Wolters is their spokesperson so it just won't happen; as my personal preference is for investigators to play their cards very close to their chest I'm at ease with it.

[Brietta]

A professional prosecutor, rather than a glory hunter, wouldn’t be talking to Portuguese television programmes and obscure podcasts about the case. He is an embarrassment to the German judicial system.

Any opinion ~ embarrassing or otherwise ~ on civilians dropping false information with as much publicity as possible into an active police investigation?

[faithlilly]

The fact that you are impressed by Amaral shows your opinion on police isn't worth a lot...imo

Perhaps if he covered up a beating by his men to extract s confession from CB you would be more impressed

I’m not at all impressed by Amaral. I think he made some rudimentary mistakes in the case...such as making the parents suspects at the beginning when he could see that there was holes in their story, letting the group collaborate on their statements and letting Gerry sit behind Kate when she gave her first statement.