Wandering Off Topic

[Mr Gray]

Come back when you have incontravertible evidence that the statements are inaccurate.

another junk post...you you think its ok to beleive they are accurate ......can you supply incontrevertible evidence they are...until you can its stupid to expect me to supply such

you claim they are accurate...I claim that they may well be not...  do you see the difference

[Eleanor]

Come back when you have incontravertible evidence that the statements are inaccurate.

In the meantime are you to decide who can post whatever?

[Vertigo Swirl]

There is not plenty of evidence that the statements were poorly translated imo. On the other hand the evidence of inconsistencies is clearly documented.

there are inconsistencies in all the statements whether those of the Tapas group, the OC staff, Murat, Yvonne Martin, whoever.  Why have you decided only the tapas group statements are suspicious?

[Eleanor]

there are inconsistencies in all the statements whether those of the Tapas group, the OC staff, Murat, Yvonne Martin, whoever.  Why have you decided only the tapas group statements are suspicious?

Good question.  The answer should be interesting.

[Wonderfulspam]

there are inconsistencies in all the statements whether those of the Tapas group, the OC staff, Murat, Yvonne Martin, whoever.  Why have you decided only the tapas group statements are suspicious?

Could be something to do with one of their children going missing in questionable circumstances.
Unless the curtains really did just blow open, but the 3 investigative forces are having a hell of a job proving they did.

[G-Unit]

another junk post...you you think its ok to beleive they are accurate ......can you supply incontrevertible evidence they are...until you can its stupid to expect me to supply such

you claim they are accurate...I claim that they may well be not...  do you see the difference

I don't claim the statements are accurate, I claim there's no evidence that the translations were faulty.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Good question.  The answer should be interesting.

you think I will get an answer?  You’re optimistic!

[Eleanor]

you think I will get an answer?  You’re optimistic!

Silence is sometimes golden.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I don't claim the statements are accurate, I claim there's no evidence that the translations were faulty.

apart from the fact that the McCanns had to spend a considerable amount of money getting them properly translated.  I suppose you don’t class that as evidence though.

[Mr Gray]

I don't claim the statements are accurate, I claim there's no evidence that the translations were faulty.

So you accept the inconsistencies may be due to te stqatements not being accurate. There certainly is evidence that thye are not accurate...KM said said they were...she should know. ..  like it or not that is evidence.Colin Sutton also raised questions about their accuracy

[Wonderfulspam]

So you accept the inconsistencies may be due to te stqatements not being accurate. There certainly is evidence that thye are not accurate...KM said said they were...she should know. ..  like it or not that is evidence.Colin Sutton also raised questions about their accuracy

Well, if Kate said there were then there must have been.
There's simply no earthly reason to ever doubt her about anything really.

[Rossb]

Well, if Kate said there were then there must have been.
There's simply no earthly reason to ever doubt her about anything really.

Well if amaral said so....

[faithlilly]

apart from the fact that the McCanns had to spend a considerable amount of money getting them properly translated.  I suppose you don’t class that as evidence though.

It’s always interested me that while sceptics translated virtually all of those ‘erroneous’ translations believers were unable to muster even one Portuguese translator to show where those errors lay. After all everyone would have been using the same source material, even the parents.

[faithlilly]

So you accept the inconsistencies may be due to te stqatements not being accurate. There certainly is evidence that thye are not accurate...KM said said they were...she should know. ..  like it or not that is evidence.Colin Sutton also raised questions about their accuracy

Ms Healey signed them as accurate.

[Wonderfulspam]

Well if amaral said so....

That doesn't make sense, I don't believe Amarals theory, I have my own thankyou.
I'd never even heard of the guy before I realised 'the abduction' didn't happen, & Wolters won't be proving it ever did anytime in the foreseeable future.