Did Gonçalo Amaral misinterpret the evidence?

[stephen25000]

because thats when amaral says it happened and thats what we are discussing

It has already been stated that Amaral did not get everything right and that 'sceptics' as they are called, do not agree with everything he says.

[Mr Gray]

I suppose he could have been out by a couple of hours.

it would have to be more than a couple of hours...the whole point is taht maddie did not suffer a head injury and die whilst the mccanns were at the tapas......

[Mr Gray]

It has already been stated that Amaral did not get everything right and that 'sceptics' as they are called, do not agree with everything he says.

so again you accept he got this wrong

[stephen25000]

so again you accept he got this wrong

Accidental death could be the result of different scenarios.

We know that already.

[slartibartfast]

it would have to be more than a couple of hours...the whole point is taht maddie did not suffer a head injury and die whilst the mccanns were at the tapas......

As no one known is in full possession of the facts then any suggested solution is just a thesis.

[Mr Gray]

Accidental death could be the result of different scenarios.

We know that already.

amaral said she fell off the sofa...thats what we are discussing....the fact that she didn't reduces the number of scenarios

[stephen25000]

For reference purposes.

https://www.nspcc.org.uk/preventing-abuse/child-protection-system/case-reviews/2015/

[Mr Gray]

As no one known is in full possession of the facts then any suggested solution is just a thesis.

amaral does not talk about a thesis...he says maddie died in the apartment...he states opinion as fact

[Mr Gray]

For reference purposes.

https://www.nspcc.org.uk/preventing-abuse/child-protection-system/case-reviews/2015/

no relevance at all

[slartibartfast]

amaral does not talk about a thesis...he says maddie died in the apartment...he states opinion as fact

Wrong.

[carlymichelle]

I suppose he could have been out by a couple of hours.

i dont understand why   davel thinks children cant die  from hitting their  heads    right  away

[slartibartfast]

i dont understand why   davel thinks children cant die  from hitting their  heads    right  away

That and trapped and suffocated, broken neck etc...

[stephen25000]

no relevance at all

Read through the cases.

[carlymichelle]

That and trapped and suffocated, broken neck etc...

drowning/near drowning etc

[Mr Gray]

Read through the cases.

a 17 yr old girl hanged herself