Author Topic: Was it all Amaral's fault?  (Read 45397 times)

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #195 on: September 14, 2016, 12:38:16 PM »
Inconclusive, as I recall.

Which means, sod-all

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #196 on: September 14, 2016, 01:01:17 PM »
Are you referring to an open window, some open shutters and open curtains? [4th May 2007, Kate & Gerry McCann, 10th May, Gerry McCann]

Or to an open window, some open shutters and some closed billowing curtains? [Kate McCann's later story]

A changing story doesn't inspire confidence in the witness.

Next please.
Yes, I am referring to the evidence of ALL the key witnesses at the OC that night which you seem happy to dismiss as no evidence at all to support the abduction theory.  Humans vs dogs - the latter you consider evidence, the former you don't.  Any reason why that should be?

Would you happily dismiss the accounts of Ben Needham's family of the day he went missing as non-evidence of abduction?   

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #197 on: September 14, 2016, 01:03:48 PM »
It seems that if a human gives evidence which (on minor detail) reveals a discrepancy then G-unit is happy to dismiss it as evidence of nothing.  If, on the other hand a dog barks, and we have no way of knowing one way or the other if it is mistaken or not, then that's evidence of something!
« Last Edit: September 14, 2016, 02:22:41 PM by ShiningInLuz »

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #198 on: September 14, 2016, 01:57:19 PM »
Yes, I am referring to the evidence of ALL the key witnesses at the OC that night which you seem happy to dismiss as no evidence at all to support the abduction theory.  Humans vs dogs - the latter you consider evidence, the former you don't.  Any reason why that should be?

Would you happily dismiss the accounts of Ben Needham's family of the day he went missing as non-evidence of abduction?   

In your first post you referred to 'Kate's alert' I asked if you meant the open/closed curtains and you have said yes. You haven't responded to my point that changing stories don't inspire confidence in a witness's story.

If you want me to comment on evidence which you claim supports the abduction theory you need to document it, with cites. I will then respond to each point. I can't respond if I don't know what it is.

I know little about the Needham case, but as far as I know the only thing the two cases have in common is a missing child.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #199 on: September 14, 2016, 02:19:34 PM »
In your first post you referred to 'Kate's alert' I asked if you meant the open/closed curtains and you have said yes. You haven't responded to my point that changing stories don't inspire confidence in a witness's story.

If you want me to comment on evidence which you claim supports the abduction theory you need to document it, with cites. I will then respond to each point. I can't respond if I don't know what it is.

I know little about the Needham case, but as far as I know the only thing the two cases have in common is a missing child.
Deflection, disingenuous deflection.  I should have known I wouldn't get a straight answer from you.  I am not going to sit here going through each piece of evidence asking you to comment on each point (as if we haven't covered these a million times before anyway).  That is NOT what this is about.  It is about the nature of what evidence is and who / what supplies it, and the fact that you are happy to accept the woofs of dogs (which cannot be verified and tells us nothing one way or the other) as evidence of something that is not abduction, but not evidence from humans (in this case not just Kate but everyone who was at the OC that night), that is evidence of something ie: abduction.  You claim there is NO evidence for abduction.  What you actually mean is you don't accept the evidence for abduction, for reasons best known to yourself.

If you being totally consistent you would have to draw the conclusion that in the Ben Needham case there is no evidence of abduction.  Try telling that to his family.  Try telling that to the cops who have spent years trying to find him.   

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #200 on: September 14, 2016, 02:37:34 PM »
Deflection, disingenuous deflection.  I should have known I wouldn't get a straight answer from you.  I am not going to sit here going through each piece of evidence asking you to comment on each point (as if we haven't covered these a million times before anyway).  That is NOT what this is about.  It is about the nature of what evidence is and who / what supplies it, and the fact that you are happy to accept the woofs of dogs (which cannot be verified and tells us nothing one way or the other) as evidence of something that is not abduction, but not evidence from humans (in this case not just Kate but everyone who was at the OC that night), that is evidence of something ie: abduction.  You claim there is NO evidence for abduction.  What you actually mean is you don't accept the evidence for abduction, for reasons best known to yourself.

If you being totally consistent you would have to draw the conclusion that in the Ben Needham case there is no evidence of abduction.  Try telling that to his family.  Try telling that to the cops who have spent years trying to find him.

Of course, the dogs don't have a vested interest in it one way or the other.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #201 on: September 14, 2016, 02:44:16 PM »
Of course, the dogs don't have a vested interest in it one way or the other.
So it's only evidence if it comes from someone or something with no vested interested is that what you're saying?   

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #202 on: September 14, 2016, 02:45:25 PM »
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #203 on: September 14, 2016, 02:46:40 PM »
So it's only evidence if it comes from someone or something with no vested interested is that what you're saying?   

Well someone already suggested we be wary of relying on information from arguidos.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #204 on: September 14, 2016, 02:50:55 PM »
Well someone already suggested we be wary of relying on information from arguidos.
Very good.  Do you even understand what evidence means, I wonder?  Do you agree with G-Unit that there is NO evidence to support abduction, only evidence to support other theories?  I await your answer with interest.

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #205 on: September 14, 2016, 03:12:29 PM »
Perhaps someone could explain why, when there is NO evidence of abduction, SY announced it was treating the case as one of stranger abduction?  Is that what the police do?  Just decide what direction an investigation should go in based on....NOTHING?  Is there like a random investigation generator machine at the Met,  like a big spinning wheel with theories on it that they spin, and wherever the pointer stops that's the direction the investigation takes? 

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #206 on: September 14, 2016, 03:26:05 PM »
Perhaps someone could explain why, when there is NO evidence of abduction, SY announced it was treating the case as one of stranger abduction?  Is that what the police do?  Just decide what direction an investigation should go in based on....NOTHING?  Is there like a random investigation generator machine at the Met,  like a big spinning wheel with theories on it that they spin, and wherever the pointer stops that's the direction the investigation takes?

Pray tell, what is the evidence of abduction.

Offline xtina

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #207 on: September 14, 2016, 03:51:06 PM »
Perhaps someone could explain why, when there is NO evidence of abduction, SY announced it was treating the case as one of stranger abduction?  Is that what the police do?  Just decide what direction an investigation should go in based on....NOTHING?  Is there like a random investigation generator machine at the Met,  like a big spinning wheel with theories on it that they spin, and wherever the pointer stops that's the direction the investigation takes?
well that is what the abduction seems to be ...spin
« Last Edit: September 14, 2016, 04:11:35 PM by ShiningInLuz »
Always listen to both sides of the story before you judge.

The first storyteller you will always find has modified the story, for there benefit BE WISE.

Offline G-Unit

Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #208 on: September 14, 2016, 03:52:05 PM »
Deflection, disingenuous deflection.  I should have known I wouldn't get a straight answer from you.  I am not going to sit here going through each piece of evidence asking you to comment on each point (as if we haven't covered these a million times before anyway).  That is NOT what this is about.  It is about the nature of what evidence is and who / what supplies it, and the fact that you are happy to accept the woofs of dogs (which cannot be verified and tells us nothing one way or the other) as evidence of something that is not abduction, but not evidence from humans (in this case not just Kate but everyone who was at the OC that night), that is evidence of something ie: abduction.  You claim there is NO evidence for abduction.  What you actually mean is you don't accept the evidence for abduction, for reasons best known to yourself.

If you being totally consistent you would have to draw the conclusion that in the Ben Needham case there is no evidence of abduction.  Try telling that to his family.  Try telling that to the cops who have spent years trying to find him.

You said;

Quote from: Alfie on Today at 11:08:26 AM
How about Kate's alert for starters?  Then let's go on to the statements they gave about events that evening.
Does none of it count as evidence of an abduction in your view?

and;

Quote from: Alfie on Today at 01:01:17 PM
Yes, I am referring to the evidence of ALL the key witnesses at the OC that night which you seem happy to dismiss as no evidence at all to support the abduction theory.

So am I supposed to trawl through the statements of ''they'' and the ''key witnesses'' you refer to looking for evidence to support the abduction theory? I think not. Firstly I have no idea who you mean and secondly I have read most of the statements in the files and have found nothing at all to support the abduction theory.

I think there's a thread on this, which failed to find any either. If you're convinced it's there, it's up to you to bring it to the discussion.

Please remember I was commenting on what I see as circumstantial evidence [including the dog Eddie's alerts] which, in my opinion, the PJ correctly considered. By that time in the investigation they had worked hard on whatever evidence you refer to, and had got nowhere. The Legal Summary left all possibilities open, so if there is definite evidence of an abduction perhaps you should tell someone?

Despite all of this, it was not possible to obtain any piece of evidence that would allow for a medium man[/b], under the light of the criteria of logics, of normality and of the general rules of experience, to formulate any lucid, sensate, serious and honest conclusion about the circumstances under which the child was removed from the apartment (whether dead or alive, whether killed in a neglectful homicide or an intended homicide, whether the victim of a targeted abduction or an opportunistic abduction), nor even to produce a consistent prognosis about her destiny and inclusively - the most dramatic - to establish whether she is still alive or if she is dead, as seems more likely.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LEGAL_SUMMARY.htm


Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Was it all Amaral's fault?
« Reply #209 on: September 14, 2016, 03:55:27 PM »
Either Operation Grange (including Portuguese and UK law-enforcement agencies) are "in on it", or they (unpardonably) failed to consult with Xtina, Stephen25000 (and countless others) before drawing up the remit ....