The only thing I disagree with you there is, " ... but not unsurprisingly sides are drawn up"
I am fairly new to the 'debate' and am continually surprised and even amazed at peoples' invective and inventiveness. I remain surprised that there are black hats and white hats ... why on earth should there be?
1. It's the way we work. We just love belonging to teams and gangs that can bully and sneer at others that don't agree with us. That is not a "royal we" you understand.
2. On the basis that as with everything some swear by some swear at. Instant two teams. It would I am sure be possible to start a fight in some places over stuffed marrow. Well Jonathan Swift thought so about the end an egg is opened so it is hardly a novel concept. I used the terms Black Hat and White Hat in the knowledge that one of Cerberus' heads would not delete the words. Others words may have been more appropriate only to have snapped at by Cerberus.
3. I agree. I incline to the view some folk are either being paid to do it or are doing it for a laugh. One finds it scarcely credible they really mean some of it.