I wasn't aware I wasn't giving you straight answers. They seem pretty straight to me.
Anyhoo ! Tanner's evidence ( about the position of the chat ) is corroborated by Jez, that gives it credibility and as I have said before Rebelo certainly had reservations about Gerry's recollection as is shown by his request for a reconstitution.
Did you give a straight answer to this - "And if you believe the police would find JT's evidence credible perhaps you can explain why super-sleuth Amaral dismissed her as a not credible witness?"
No.
I rest my case.
Your theory that Gerry had to relocate himself on the off chance some random person on a balcony saw him, despite the fact that he knew there were two people who would give statements that he was standing in a (slightly) different position is a non-starter. Try and come up with another, more plausible reason. Here's one - all three are remembering the event ever so slightly differently from each other as they are 3 independent people who experienced the event from slightly different perspectives - or is that just completely impossible?