Author Topic: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?  (Read 173994 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.


Offline Robittybob1

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #631 on: December 15, 2016, 05:16:31 AM »
So you think that Gerry was right?  Despite Jane being adamant in the Cutting Edge video and Jez being sure that the were near the pathway corner on the western side of the road.

Two people against one.   Jez and Jane v Gerry
 
I orefer that Gerry got it wrong, or that they might have started on the eastern side in the roadway itself, then moved back to the western side to get ouit of the way, as a vehicle came up towards them
I intend to see if we can resolve this issue.  I'll go through Jane's statements and see if there is room for a compromise.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #632 on: December 15, 2016, 05:56:21 AM »
Jane 04 May
Quote
She remembers that at about 21.10 Gerald left the restaurant (3) to go to the apartment to check on the children. Five minutes later, the witness left, to go to her apartment to see whether her daughters were OK. At this moment she saw Gerry talking to an Englishman called Jez whom they had got to know during the holidays. They played tennis with him.

She passed by them knowing that Gerry had already been in the apartment (1) to check his children.

Meanwhile a man appeared ( * ) carrying a child (**), with a hurried walk, it being this detail together with the fact that the child dressed in pyjamas, without being wrapped up in a blanket, that caught her attention. She only managed to see him from the side, with the child in his arms. She noticed the individual's presence exactly when she had just passed by Gerry and Jez who were talking, having seen this person step off the pavement that borders on the apartment block where they were staying and rapidly cross the road.

Summary of 2nd statement.
Quote
They ordered dinner and waited for the starters when, about 21h10, GM left the restaurant having gone to the apartment to see his children. Five or ten minutes later the deponent left, having gone to her apartment to check that all was well with her girls. At that time she observed GM talking to an English citizen called Jez that they had met on these holidays. He played tennis with them. She doesn't know if they saw her giving the assurance that, on her part, she did not start a conversation with either of them.

 
She passed them knowing that GM had already been in the apartment to see the children.


She doesn't recall the position/orientation of either Jez or GM while they spoke to each other on the street, only having the perception that one was on the pavement and the other was in the road next to the other. Jez had a baby carriage, the deponent knowing that he had a small child.

Janes rogatory statement:
Quote
4078    “From what I know from reading statements, Gerry was still absent?”
Reply    “He wasn’t there at that point, no, no.  So, erm, then I walked, so I just walked out the, erm, the Ocean Club bit and walked, sort of walked up the road.  And then Gerry was there, he was talking to Jez WILKINS in the road, well they were sort of, as I went by.  So I think I thought then ‘Oh that’s why Jez’, not Jez, ‘That’s why Gerry has been, you know, that’s why he’s longer than we thought’”
Quote
4078    “I know you are uncertain because you think Gerry’s recollection is different, but as far as you can remember”.
Reply    “Well I think one of them was in the road and I think, I thought it was Jez in the road because he had the pram.  And I don’t know which, I can’t remember which way he was facing.  No, I mean, I think I remember in my statement I did say, but I can’t remember now which way he was facing.  And I thought Gerry was almost like on the edge of the pavement or just, just in the road sort of, but definitely sort of by that, sort of more by this alleyway.  I don’t think they were by the apartment gate, I thought they were sort of a bit further down, down the road than that”.
Quote
4078    “And when you have gone past Gerry and Jez whereabouts have they been in relation to you?”
Reply    “If I’m walking this way, they were sort of”.
 
4078    “So they were to your right?”
Reply    “Yeah”.

They were to her right.  So that can be anywhere to the right.
One of them on the footpath and one on the road.  Sounds more like Gerry's memory of one on the road (Gerry) and Jez on the footpath.  If that was on the west side of the road (near side) that would make Gerry facing Jane, and Jez with his back to Jane.   If that was on the East side of the road (farside) that would make Jez facing Jane, and Gerry with his back to Jane.  (I hope I have designated the East and West correctly.)

Quote
4078    “What about other people, what other noises?”
Reply    “No, I mean, there was no, apart from Gerry, well apart from Gerry and Jez there was nobody else around. 

Quote
4078    “Okay.  So when did you first notice Gerry standing there?”
Reply    “I would have probably noticed him as soon as I came, I mean, I don’t, this is not, I don’t think that distance is probably as far as that, you come out and he was, they were sort of, so almost, I’d probably say almost straight away.  Again, I don’t know, but I, I know people are saying I’ve not been on the road, but they were there and I wouldn’t know they were there if I hadn’t walked past, you know, you’ve got to see my frustration in this, and I know Gerry didn’t see me and Jez didn’t see me, but”.
 
4078    “You were there?”
Reply    “They were there and I was there”.
 
4078    “And you say you almost went to acknowledge them but they were so engrossed in conversation?”
Reply    “They were, yeah.  I mean, I don’t know whether you’ve met Gerry, but other people have met Gerry, and when Gerry is talking, it’s bit like I said earlier, that he is very focussed, he is a very focussed person.  And it doesn’t surprise me he didn’t see me, because if he’s talking he’s very focussed on what he’s doing at that stage.  I mean, obviously I don’t  know, I don’t know Jez, I hadn’t actually, I hadn’t had any contact with Jez through the week, I didn’t, you know, he wasn’t somebody we chatted to, so, you know, in terms of him recognising me or knowing me, he didn’t know me, so”.


Jane knew they were there and so were Gerry and Jez,  She was there and they were there.  Whereas Jez tries to make out Jane was not there.  Wrong again.

Quote

4078    “Tell me from there what happened?”
Reply    “So I just carried on walking the opposite way into and then walked through the car park and into our apartment through the back, through the roadside, the roadside door.  And, like I say, I just went in, it was all, they were both, I actually went into the room and checked and they were both quiet.  And then, as I say, I just walked straight back to the restaurant.  I didn’t see anything.  I didn’t see them there when I walked back, they weren’t, there was nobody that I spotted and Gerry and Jez had gone by that stage as well, I think they’d gone back into, well Gerry had obviously gone back into the restaurant and I don’t know where Jez had gone, but I didn’t see them again after, after that point”.

Jane didn't see Jez on her return trip which tends to suggest he took the lane back to Block G4. Jane's check didn't take long and she would have seen him on the return trip if he had gone up to the intersection and through the carpark. Gerry was back at the Tapas so Jez and Jerry's talk did not last long so suggestion by Jez and Bridget that the chat continued for 15 minutes was wrong as well.

Quote
4078    “And then we’ve covered who left the table during the meal and why, we’ve covered the fact that Gerry went, how long he was absent for.  What did Gerald say when he came back”?
 Reply    “Erm well I wasn’t actually there when he came back”.
4078    “No you weren’t that’s right”.
 Reply    “Cos he got back before, so he was back there when I got back”.
 4078    “So when you got back then, after having seen him and Jez, was Gerald behaving or acting differently”?
 Reply    “No not that I noticed no”.

The most important bit here is that Jane arrived back after Gerry.  So when Jez makes out that Jane returned before Gerry, Jez was wrong about that as well.

Jez is wrong on 3 of the points, so the decision goes Gerry's way over all with the conversation more likely on the Eastern side with Gerry's back toward Jane.  No matter where the conversation only one would have shared the footpath with Jane and it probably was Gerry closest to Jane for Jane felt like speaking to Gerry not Jez.
« Last Edit: December 15, 2016, 06:31:07 AM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline G-Unit

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #633 on: December 15, 2016, 07:12:18 AM »
Jane 04 May
Summary of 2nd statement.
Janes rogatory statement:
They were to her right.  So that can be anywhere to the right.
One of them on the footpath and one on the road.  Sounds more like Gerry's memory of one on the road (Gerry) and Jez on the footpath.  If that was on the west side of the road (near side) that would make Gerry facing Jane, and Jez with his back to Jane.   If that was on the East side of the road (farside) that would make Jez facing Jane, and Gerry with his back to Jane.  (I hope I have designated the East and West correctly.)


Jane knew they were there and so were Gerry and Jez,  She was there and they were there.  Whereas Jez tries to make out Jane was not there.  Wrong again.

Jane didn't see Jez on her return trip which tends to suggest he took the lane back to Block G4. Jane's check didn't take long and she would have seen him on the return trip if he had gone up to the intersection and through the carpark. Gerry was back at the Tapas so Jez and Jerry's talk did not last long so suggestion by Jez and Bridget that the chat continued for 15 minutes was wrong as well.

The most important bit here is that Jane arrived back after Gerry.  So when Jez makes out that Jane returned before Gerry, Jez was wrong about that as well.

Jez is wrong on 3 of the points, so the decision goes Gerry's way over all with the conversation more likely on the Eastern side with Gerry's back toward Jane.  No matter where the conversation only one would have shared the footpath with Jane and it probably was Gerry closest to Jane for Jane felt like speaking to Gerry not Jez.


I don't think Jez said there was a 15 minute chat or that he commented on Jane's return to the restaurant. Can you provide cites?

Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Robittybob1

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #634 on: December 15, 2016, 07:21:41 AM »
I don't think Jez said there was a 15 minute chat or that he commented on Jane's return to the restaurant. Can you provide cites?
They have been posted earlier in this thread by me that is why I'm quoting them from memory.  If the thread wasn't so long now I'd look for them.  They were from non-file sources, e.g articles and interviews with Jez and Bridget post May 2007.

Bridget said the conversation lasted up to 15 minutes, and I think it was Jez who suggested Jane passed them on the way back to the restaurant which implies she would arrive back before Gerry.
Now you might not like me quoting Bridget but Jez and Bridget made two joint statements hence they speak for each other.
« Last Edit: December 15, 2016, 07:28:35 AM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline G-Unit

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #635 on: December 15, 2016, 07:50:10 AM »
They have been posted earlier in this thread by me that is why I'm quoting them from memory.  If the thread wasn't so long now I'd look for them.  They were from non-file sources, e.g articles and interviews with Jez and Bridget post May 2007.

Bridget said the conversation lasted up to 15 minutes, and I think it was Jez who suggested Jane passed them on the way back to the restaurant which implies she would arrive back before Gerry.
Now you might not like me quoting Bridget but Jez and Bridget made two joint statements hence they speak for each other.

Bridget wasn't there so her opinion counts for nothing. As Jez only saw Jane earlier when he was setting out I can't accept he said he did see her later. No cites no facts, sorry.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Lace

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #636 on: December 15, 2016, 08:15:12 AM »
If Jane was meant to make out she saw a man with a child to give Gerry an alibi as to not being Tanner Man,  wouldn't it have been much easier for Gerry to just have said 'he saw Jane out of the corner of his eye, but didn't acknowledge her as he was deep in conversation with Jez at the time'?   It would have been a lot simpler than saying he didn't see her and then argue with her about where he would have been standing.

In my opinion the very fact that Gerry is saying he didn't see Jane,  cements the fact that Jane did go past Gerry and Jez when they were talking flip flops an all.

Offline Lace

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #637 on: December 15, 2016, 08:18:07 AM »
So what you are really saying is that although two witnesses, one whose credibility may have been very important in the retrieval of his daughter, assured Gerry that he was standing in a completely different position than he remembered he was conceited enough to totally disregard their opinions simply because he couldn't bear to be wrong?

That Gerry's opinion did undermine Tanner's credibility is undeniable as Rebelo's request for a reconstitution proves.

it is quite believable that Gerry did go to cross the road to meet Jez,  and that is view was looking at the other side of the road.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #638 on: December 15, 2016, 08:24:19 AM »
Bridget wasn't there so her opinion counts for nothing. As Jez only saw Jane earlier when he was setting out I can't accept he said he did see her later. No cites no facts, sorry.
I swear I have already posted the cites.
They made joint statements so they must talk to each other.  She is relating something presumably said to her by Jez.  OK I don't agree they should have been allowed to have joint statements in the first place, but what has happened can't be changed.
He didn't say he saw her later but suggested Jane must have seen them talking on her way back to the table. (Did I say something different before? No.)
Quote
.... it was Jez who suggested Jane passed them on the way back to the restaurant which implies she would arrive back before Gerry.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline G-Unit

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #639 on: December 15, 2016, 08:28:23 AM »
I swear I have already posted the cites.
They made joint statements so they must talk to each other.  She is relating something presumably said to her by Jez.  OK I don't agree they should have been allowed to have joint statements in the first place, but what has happened can't be changed.
He didn't say he saw her later but suggested Jane must have seen them talking on her way back to the table. (Did I say something different before? No.)

/You seem to be making things up.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Robittybob1

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #640 on: December 15, 2016, 08:33:13 AM »
this is the most preposterous piece of reasoning I've read on this board.  How does Gerry insisting he was standing on the other side of the street prevent his daughter from being found?!
I can't see what difference it made but it gave Amaral and Co. another excuse to disbelieve Jane and keep the blame on Gerry. 

/You seem to be making things up.

Definitely not intentionally.  I'm only human and sometimes I make a mistake but in this case definitely not.  Now the only thing that could trip me up would be if one of the mods has removed the posts with the links to the articles.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #641 on: December 15, 2016, 09:03:54 AM »
I think the clues are in this text of this article:

I've kept a copy but didn't save the location.
Quote
With thanks to Winnower

Man who could clear McCanns

Maddie: The Secret Witness

TV boss holds vital clue to mystery


News of the World
By Dominic Herbert & Ross Hall
16 September 2007

THIS is the secret witness whose bombshell testimony could clear the McCanns.

Pictured here for the first time, Jeremy Wilkins' evidence blows holes in the police theory that Gerry and Kate killed four-year-old Madeleine.

Wilkins — seen outside his north west London home — was the man heart surgeon Gerry McCann, 38, spoke with for up to 15 minutes outside the holiday apartments — moments after checking on his children for the last time.

What the TV producer witnessed makes the statement he gave to police a key piece of evidence in the event of a trial.

A friend of Wilkins told the News of the World: "He is entirely convinced of Kate and Gerry's innocence. He believes they are a decent family caught up in an unimaginable nightmare."

We can reveal Wilkins constantly INSISTED to Portuguese detectives that Gerry was totally calm and unflustered as they chatted—far removed from the behaviour that might be expected of a man covering up the death of his daughter.

But another part of Wilkins' evidence ironically helped shift the police focus AWAY from their original kidnap theory.

For the 36-year-old holidaymaker turned the investigation on its head when he revealed a VITAL FLAW in the statement given by key witness, Jane Tanner (right), who claims she saw a man carrying a child away from the apartment complex.

Based on what he has said, Portuguese sources confirmed that police have doubts about Miss Tanner's evidence.

One said: "Her account has raised more questions than answers. She is high on the list of people we need to speak to again."

Wilkins was refusing to expand on what he has told police. His girlfriend Bridget O'Donnell —who was in Praia da Luz with the producer and their eight-month-old son—said: "We have decided it's not appropriate to talk about what happened."

Wilkins' pal added: "He came back from the holiday totally shell-shocked. He was part of a British crowd which included the McCanns who became friends as they holidayed in Portugal.

"He played tennis with Gerry the day before Madeleine disappeared. He has barely said a word about the whole case. He feels as a potential witness that would be inappropriate."

Wilkins—whose production company Zig Zag has made a string of controversial TV programmes—is likely to be re-interviewed as Portuguese detectives desperately try to build a case against the McCanns.

Some of the seven diners who were at the tapas restaurant with the couple on May 3 have already travelled back to Portugal once before to go over events leading to Madeleine's disappearance.

Next time they may be quizzed in the UK by British police assisting their EU counterparts on the inquiry.

Wilkins' crucial encounter with Gerry took place at 9.10pm on the main street outside the apartments next to the McCanns'—and at the entrance to a narrow alleyway that runs past the back of them.

The two were both tennis fans and had played each other during the course of the holiday.

On the night Maddie disappeared Wilkins was taking his eight-month-old son for a walk.

When he bumped into Gerry the two men chatted for up to 15 minutes before the surgeon returned to the tapas bar.

It was during this period of time that Tanner, 37, another member of the McCanns' party, said she WALKED PAST the two men on her way back to her apartment to check on her youngsters.


She told police that she saw a dark-haired man, aged about 35, carrying a child who could have been Maddie's wrapped in a blanket at 9.15pm—when Gerry and Wilkins would still have been chatting.

But Wilkins, viewed by police as a completely independent witness, told cops he could not recall anyone walking past him. And in all the time he was there he saw NO MAN carrying a child.

The TV executive is convinced he would have seen Jane Tanner pass by.

He said: "It was a very narrow path and I think it would have been almost impossible for anyone to walk by without me noticing."

And he also believes he would have seen the mystery man and child who would also have been just yards away.

Cops asked mum-of-two Tanner—on the holiday with with her partner Dr Russell O'Brien, 36—whether it was possible that the man and child she saw was Wilkins with his son.

Check

But a source told us: "She was adamant that it was not Jeremy Wilkins and his child. She is certain she saw someone else and stands by her account."

Gerry and Tanner returned to the restaurant separately shortly afterwards and it was at 10pm that Kate McCann went to check on the children and found Madeleine gone.

Wilkins' importance in the inquiry has only been highlighted because police are troubled by possible inconsistencies in the McCann friends' statements, including discrepancies in the times various people recall arriving at the restaurant.

The Portuguese police believe the McCanns may have been involved in Madeleine's disappearance and think one may be covering up for the other.

Officers are probing an unlikely "three-hour window of opportunity" between 6pm and 9pm when they suspect Madeleine was killed in the apartment and her body hidden somewhere nearby. Forensic evidence gathered so far including DNA or body fluid samples is thought to be inconclusive.

Portuguese police say they could name more official suspects in the coming weeks.

[/quote]
Find this sections: 
When he bumped into Gerry the two men chatted for up to 15 minutes before the surgeon returned to the tapas bar.

It was during this period of time that Tanner, 37, another member of the McCanns' party, said she WALKED PAST the two men on her way back to her apartment to check on her youngsters.


There is another part where it is suggested Jane see them on the way back to the table. 
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Robittybob1

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #642 on: December 15, 2016, 09:11:10 AM »
I may have read this line incorrectly "It was during this period of time that Tanner, 37, another member of the McCanns' party, said she WALKED PAST the two men on her way back to her apartment to check on her youngsters." but I'm sure there are those who propose Jane returned to the table first.

I may have read it as "It was during this period of time that Tanner, 37, another member of the McCanns' party, said she WALKED PAST the two men on her way back FROM her apartment to check on her youngsters.


I have searched for this article on the forum and even though I had posted it previously it has not come up on a search of the site, so it may have been deleted in error.
« Last Edit: December 15, 2016, 09:19:29 AM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline jassi

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #643 on: December 15, 2016, 09:29:41 AM »
Why did ROB leave at 9.30, so soon after JT would  have returned?  Were they checking every 15 minutes?
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Robittybob1

Re: How could Jez and Gerry not see Jane?
« Reply #644 on: December 15, 2016, 09:31:08 AM »
It is not until I had read Russell O'Brien's statements today that things go in Bridget's favour.   His timing and order of events is so at odds with the others that questions need to be asked.
Go back to the source and you will see what I mean.  I'm still a bit confused as to why I say it was Bridget who also suggests Jane arrives back first.

Why did ROB leave at 9.30, so soon after JT would  have returned?  Were they checking every 15 minutes?
Good question but they can say what they like.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.