Author Topic: Have the dog alerts any significance?  (Read 114743 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline G-Unit

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #330 on: January 17, 2017, 11:56:05 AM »
The alerts are intelligence.

We knew from Bob Small that the responses of
specialist dogs were, or ought to be, classed as
intelligence, not evidence [Madeleine]
« Last Edit: January 23, 2017, 07:17:13 PM by John »
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline sadie

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #331 on: January 17, 2017, 12:27:10 PM »
In 5A, with the exception of the alert near the wardrobes, Keela proved that all the other alerts by Eddie were to blood from a living person.

1)    Having seen mistys video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THoDAqUTl48 which shows Eddie mis-alerting in multiple places like the area where he alerted in 5A, no reasonable person could think that the one in 5A was bona fide.  It would not stand up in Court.

2)  Also the problem with Tasmins deceased Grandpa, who lived in that apartment and his cremated remains/ clothes being brought back from hospital raises another big question mark about the validity of this so called alert.   
This may have been sorted by SY, but we have no means of finding out whether they were brought back and whether they were stored in / by that wardrobe /edge of the bed.  But it seems likely that a widow would like her hubbies personal effects ... and his ashes back

And the most likely storage place are
(i)  in that wardrobe at the bottom left hand end (if she just wanted to keep them)

Or, if she wanted comfort from them,
(ii)  by the top of the bed where she could feel he was near her.


No myths there, Slarti




ETA:  Now please excuse me, I must get on
.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #332 on: January 17, 2017, 12:53:09 PM »
In 5A, with the exception of the alert near the wardrobes, Keela proved that all the other alerts by Eddie were to blood from a living person.

1)    Having seen mistys video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THoDAqUTl48 which shows Eddie mis-alerting in multiple places like the area where he alerted in 5A, no reasonable person could think that the one in 5A was bona fide.  It would not stand up in Court.

2)  Also the problem with Tasmins deceased Grandpa, who lived in that apartment and his cremated remains/ clothes being brought back from hospital raises another big question mark about the validity of this so called alert.   
This may have been sorted by SY, but we have no means of finding out whether they were brought back and whether they were stored in / by that wardrobe /edge of the bed.  But it seems likely that a widow would like her hubbies personal effects ... and his ashes back

And the most likely storage place are
(i)  in that wardrobe at the bottom left hand end (if she just wanted to keep them)

Or, if she wanted comfort from them,
(ii)  by the top of the bed where she could feel he was near her.


No myths there, Slarti



ETA:  Now please excuse me, I must get on
.





'In 5A, with the exception of the alert near the wardrobes, Keela proved that all the other alerts by Eddie were to blood from a living person.'

You can of course provide proof for that statement ?

« Last Edit: January 23, 2017, 07:19:24 PM by John »

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #333 on: January 17, 2017, 01:15:57 PM »
If the alerts had any reliability they would be accepted as evidence
They simply have no reliability confirmed by Grime

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #334 on: January 17, 2017, 01:26:06 PM »
If the alerts had any reliability they would be accepted as evidence
They simply have no reliability confirmed by Grime

Albeit reluctantly.

Offline sadie

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #335 on: January 17, 2017, 02:12:18 PM »

'In 5A, with the exception of the alert near the wardrobes, Keela proved that all the other alerts by Eddie were to blood from a living person.'

You can of course provide proof for that statement ?

Oh,wake up at the back purrleaze stephen.

You obviously haven't been reading all Grimes and Harrisons comments/ statements as kindly posted (mainly) by Ferryman

All Eddies alerts MUST be checked by Keela, if not they mean nothing except the likelyhood is old blood from a living person

If Keela checks, but also alerts, then that is proof that they are both smelling the same thing.  Keela only alerts to blood from a living person ... so they are both alerting to the blood from a living person.


In the case of 5A, they either both alerted to dried blood or Keela did not check ... with the exception of in / close to the wardrobe / bedhead in the main bedroom.

Because of Eddies erratic behaviour in mistys video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THoDAqUTl48 ... which shows Eddie mis-alerting in multiple places like the area where he alerted in 5A, (a semi-enclosed place like the wardrobe / bed space in 5A), no reasonable person could think that the one in 5A was bona fide.  It would not stand up in Court.

Also the death of Mr ?Milburn, Tasmins Grandpa, raises another big question mark about the validity of this so called alert.   What happened to his clothes, normally returned to the widow ... and his ashes?   If just kept, even if washed and for a short time, they would leave a strong odour of cadaver.

Where would they have been kept in a small flat?

Just stored, the most likely out of the way place is in the bottom of the furthest wardrobe .... where Eddie alerted

If kept as a sentimental and comfort thing, then the most likely place is as close to Mrs Milburn as she lay in bed as possible .... and that would be on the floor or on the table close to the wall as possible, so that she could reach out and touch them if she felt the need / the wish to do so.


There is just no substance to any cadaver having been in that flat. 
Nothing that could even have been presented to Court because when carefully analysed the whole accusation is empty ... or, in the bedroom case, so dicey that it would be risible in a Court case


Amaral got it wrong.  Seems he didn't understand it. 
The only other conclusion is that he was so keen to nail Kate and Gerry that he pretended, but let's NOT go there ... cos we have no proof, or indicators, do we?


Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #336 on: January 17, 2017, 02:21:21 PM »
In 5A, with the exception of the alert near the wardrobes, Keela proved that all the other alerts by Eddie were to blood from a living person.

1)    Having seen mistys video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THoDAqUTl48 which shows Eddie mis-alerting in multiple places like the area where he alerted in 5A, no reasonable person could think that the one in 5A was bona fide.  It would not stand up in Court.

2)  Also the problem with Tasmins deceased Grandpa, who lived in that apartment and his cremated remains/ clothes being brought back from hospital raises another big question mark about the validity of this so called alert.   
This may have been sorted by SY, but we have no means of finding out whether they were brought back and whether they were stored in / by that wardrobe /edge of the bed.  But it seems likely that a widow would like her hubbies personal effects ... and his ashes back

And the most likely storage place are
(i)  in that wardrobe at the bottom left hand end (if she just wanted to keep them)

Or, if she wanted comfort from them,
(ii)  by the top of the bed where she could feel he was near her.


No myths there, Slarti



ETA:  Now please excuse me, I must get on
.
This quote is stuffed with myths.

From an earlier discussion of the dog alerts -
"From Ruth McCann - current owner of 5a -

'The apartment is owned by Ruth Margaret McCann, who is unrelated to the McCanns according to family spokesperson Clarence Mitchell.
 
The apartment A, number 5, locate at Rua Dr. Agostinho da Silva, Montes da Luz Urbanization, Praia da luz, is registered with the number 3666.
 
In 2001 the house was bought by a kind of society belonging to Daniel John Aldred, his daughter Donna Michelle Aldred (from his first marriage), Michael William McCann and his wife, Ruth Margaret McCann.
 
Michael McCann born in Devonport, Plymouth was a widower when he married Margaret Ruth Pittaway, 53, who was also widowed in 1987.
 
In 2005, Michael and Ruth bought the part of the Aldred couple giving each of them 50% of the apartment.
 
Later in July 2006 Michael McCann died in Liverpool and in November of the same year Ruth McCann inherited his part becoming the only proprietor.'
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id21.html"

mccannfiles stopped working in Oct 2016, so if anyone wants to look at that, use the Wayback Machine, assuming it works for this .com.

Michael McCann died in Liverpool in July 2006.  To attribute death scent to his death, you need to speculate about someone bringing said death scent to Luz.

The apartment was sold in 2001/2002, and Tasmin's grandmother supposedly owned it prior to that.  As Tasmin would have been aged around 6 in 2001/2002, the accuracy of her memory of that time is open to question.  The same thread on this forum has raised the suggestion that Tasmin's grandmother was in apartment 5B.  I have no information about when 5B was sold prior to May 2007, therefore I shall not speculate on how accurate her memory of that might be.
« Last Edit: January 23, 2017, 07:20:41 PM by John »
What's up, old man?

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #337 on: January 17, 2017, 03:10:52 PM »
Oh,wake up at the back purrleaze stephen.

You obviously haven't been reading all Grimes and Harrisons comments/ statements as kindly posted (mainly) by Ferryman

All Eddies alerts MUST be checked by Keela, if not they mean nothing except the likelyhood is old blood from a living person

If Keela checks, but also alerts, then that is proof that they are both smelling the same thing.  Keela only alerts to blood from a living person ... so they are both alerting to the blood from a living person.


In the case of 5A, they either both alerted to dried blood or Keela did not check ... with the exception of in / close to the wardrobe / bedhead in the main bedroom.

Because of Eddies erratic behaviour in mistys video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THoDAqUTl48 ... which shows Eddie mis-alerting in multiple places like the area where he alerted in 5A, (a semi-enclosed place like the wardrobe / bed space in 5A), no reasonable person could think that the one in 5A was bona fide.  It would not stand up in Court.

Also the death of Mr ?Milburn, Tasmins Grandpa, raises another big question mark about the validity of this so called alert.   What happened to his clothes, normally returned to the widow ... and his ashes?   If just kept, even if washed and for a short time, they would leave a strong odour of cadaver.

Where would they have been kept in a small flat?

Just stored, the most likely out of the way place is in the bottom of the furthest wardrobe .... where Eddie alerted

If kept as a sentimental and comfort thing, then the most likely place is as close to Mrs Milburn as she lay in bed as possible .... and that would be on the floor or on the table close to the wall as possible, so that she could reach out and touch them if she felt the need / the wish to do so.


There is just no substance to any cadaver having been in that flat. 
Nothing that could even have been presented to Court because when carefully analysed the whole accusation is empty ... or, in the bedroom case, so dicey that it would be risible in a Court case


Amaral got it wrong.  Seems he didn't understand it. 
The only other conclusion is that he was so keen to nail Kate and Gerry that he pretended, but let's NOT go there ... cos we have no proof, or indicators, do we?


Keela was trained to react to the presence of blood Sadie.

Yes or No ?

...and Keela could not know the difference whether the blood came from a living or non living source ?

Yes or No  ?

By the way Sadie, any blood Keela alerted to, would have been in a state of decomposition. Now isn't that ironic, given your earlier comment.


« Last Edit: January 23, 2017, 07:27:26 PM by John »

Offline sadie

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #338 on: January 17, 2017, 03:34:04 PM »
This quote is stuffed with myths.

From an earlier discussion of the dog alerts -
"From Ruth McCann - current owner of 5a -

'The apartment is owned by Ruth Margaret McCann, who is unrelated to the McCanns according to family spokesperson Clarence Mitchell.
 
The apartment A, number 5, locate at Rua Dr. Agostinho da Silva, Montes da Luz Urbanization, Praia da luz, is registered with the number 3666.
 
In 2001 the house was bought by a kind of society belonging to Daniel John Aldred, his daughter Donna Michelle Aldred (from his first marriage), Michael William McCann and his wife, Ruth Margaret McCann.
 
Michael McCann born in Devonport, Plymouth was a widower when he married Margaret Ruth Pittaway, 53, who was also widowed in 1987.
 
In 2005, Michael and Ruth bought the part of the Aldred couple giving each of them 50% of the apartment.
 
Later in July 2006 Michael McCann died in Liverpool and in November of the same year Ruth McCann inherited his part becoming the only proprietor.'
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id21.html"

mccannfiles stopped working in Oct 2016, so if anyone wants to look at that, use the Wayback Machine, assuming it works for this .com.

Michael McCann died in Liverpool in July 2006.  To attribute death scent to his death, you need to speculate about someone bringing said death scent to Luz.

The apartment was sold in 2001/2002, and Tasmin's grandmother supposedly owned it prior to that.  As Tasmin would have been aged around 6 in 2001/2002, the accuracy of her memory of that time is open to question.  The same thread on this forum has raised the suggestion that Tasmin's grandmother was in apartment 5B.  I have no information about when 5B was sold prior to May 2007, therefore I shall not speculate on how accurate her memory of that might be.

Mistake number 1. 
Yours!
I have not speculated that it was the death of Michael Mccann that Eddie just may have alerted to.  I believe that it is more likely that it was the death of Tasmins grandfather, who as her Mums maiden name was Milburn, is likely to have been a Mr Milburn, who died in Portugal.   Although what this snippet shows us is that there were two men whose ashes might, quite probably, have been brought back to 5A.  Cadaver odour lasts for decades we are told.

Mistake number 2.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atfDV7imHHY
In order to see a number of ordinary people who observed 5A in the days preceding Madeleine vanishing , I suggest that you watch from 1.30. until about 4.30.     Tasmin appears @ about 2.30

Referring to the man peering over the wall at the Mccann apartment she clearly says "my grandparents used to live there"

So straight from the horses mouth we get it that her Grandparents lived at 5A.  I have no idea whether they owned it or whether they long term rented it from the (other) Mccanns


mistake number 3 (IMO)

Tasmin Milburn Silence is a clear thinking, observant and intelligent girl.  Even if her Grandpa died in 2001 and she was only six, my bet is that she would have had pretty clear reciollection of where they lived and of her grandparents.  It was said that at one time that she and her mother rented the apartment next door to 5A, but please dont ask me to prove that.  Most stuff seems to have been wiped off the internet.

Remember, unless you know otherwise, we dont know when her grandparents lived in 5A, if they possibly rented


May I repectfully point out that the quote you give us has no origin address apart from this forum !!   and no posters name !!   Can you give us those details please SIL ?


So to sum up, the so called facts in your post SIL are very woolley, with nobodies name attached, let alone a trustworthy document. 

Do you honestly think that Tasmin would have forgotten where her grandparents lived when she spent so much time with them?   ... and she passed by each day, it seems.

Offline sadie

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #339 on: January 17, 2017, 03:57:36 PM »
Keela was trained to react to the presence of blood Sadie.

Yes or No ?

...and Keela could not know the difference whether the blood cane from a living or non living source ?

Yes or No  ?

Keela was trained to alert only to the blood from a living person.  The odour of the blood from a dead person would NOT smell the same, it would smell of death.  Keela was NOT trained to alert to this, because she was not a Cadaver dog.

The two dogs were used together because they complimented each other.  Eddie unfortunately was double trained and alerted to living blood and the scent of death.  Keela alerted to ONLY the scent of living blood (dessicated).

When Eddie alerted it could have been to Living blood (dessicated) or it could have been to the odour of a dead body.  To sort out whether he was alerting to dead body odour, or the blood from a living person, it was necessary for Keela to sniff the odour too. 
If she alerted as well, then it was living blood.
If she kept quiet at the same odour, then it was either a sign that it could be cadaveresent odour ... or it could be pig ... or it could be a false alarm from an over excited dog .... as in mistys video 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THoDAqUTl48

As you can see, Eddie kept alerting to alcoves/ corners very reminiscent of the area between the wardrobe, the wall and the bed in The Mccann bedroom.

I am afraid that the lovely dog Eddie, whilst very good in most ways, was too erratic and unreliable in others.  The courts upon seeing that video would have laughed themselves silly with scorn. 



Furthermore, I believe that you, stephen, are intelligent enough to understand that.  Time you accepted it TBH.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #340 on: January 17, 2017, 04:20:38 PM »
Keela was trained to alert only to the blood from a living person.  The odour of the blood from a dead person would NOT smell the same, it would smell of death.  Keela was NOT trained to alert to this, because she was not a Cadaver dog.

The two dogs were used together because they complimented each other.  Eddie unfortunately was double trained and alerted to living blood and the scent of death.  Keela alerted to ONLY the scent of living blood (dessicated).

When Eddie alerted it could have been to Living blood (dessicated) or it could have been to the odour of a dead body.  To sort out whether he was alerting to dead body odour, or the blood from a living person, it was necessary for Keela to sniff the odour too. 
If she alerted as well, then it was living blood.
If she kept quiet at the same odour, then it was either a sign that it could be cadaveresent odour ... or it could be pig ... or it could be a false alarm from an over excited dog .... as in mistys video 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THoDAqUTl48

As you can see, Eddie kept alerting to alcoves/ corners very reminiscent of the area between the wardrobe, the wall and the bed in The Mccann bedroom.

I am afraid that the lovely dog Eddie, whilst very good in most ways, was too erratic and unreliable in others.  The courts upon seeing that video would have laughed themselves silly with scorn. 



Furthermore, I believe that you, stephen, are intelligent enough to understand that.  Time you accepted it TBH.

I have read through some of the reports

Now can provide a citation from the source that Keels could only detect blood from a living individual ?

Your opinion does not count in that.

Also,  'blood from living or dead would not smell  the same ?

Please qualify that statement. As it is , it is meaningless.
« Last Edit: January 23, 2017, 07:45:05 PM by John »

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #341 on: January 17, 2017, 05:28:11 PM »
Mistake number 1. 
Yours!
I have not speculated that it was the death of Michael Mccann that Eddie just may have alerted to.  I believe that it is more likely that it was the death of Tasmins grandfather, who as her Mums maiden name was Milburn, is likely to have been a Mr Milburn, who died in Portugal.   Although   Cadaver odour lasts for decades we are told.

Mistake number 2.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atfDV7imHHYwhat this snippet shows us is that there were two men whose ashes might, quite probably, have been brought back to 5A.
In order to see a number of ordinary people who observed 5A in the days preceding Madeleine vanishing , I suggest that you watch from 1.30. until about 4.30.     Tasmin appears @ about 2.30

Referring to the man peering over the wall at the Mccann apartment she clearly says "my grandparents used to live there"

So straight from the horses mouth we get it that her Grandparents lived at 5A.  I have no idea whether they owned it or whether they long term rented it from the (other) Mccanns


mistake number 3 (IMO)

Tasmin Milburn Silence is a clear thinking, observant and intelligent girl.  Even if her Grandpa died in 2001 and she was only six, my bet is that she would have had pretty clear reciollection of where they lived and of her grandparents.  It was said that at one time that she and her mother rented the apartment next door to 5A, but please dont ask me to prove that.  Most stuff seems to have been wiped off the internet.

Remember, unless you know otherwise, we dont know when her grandparents lived in 5A, if they possibly rented


May I repectfully point out that the quote you give us has no origin address apart from this forum !!   and no posters name !!   Can you give us those details please SIL ?


So to sum up, the so called facts in your post SIL are very woolley, with nobodies name attached, let alone a trustworthy document. 

Do you honestly think that Tasmin would have forgotten where her grandparents lived when she spent so much time with them?   ... and she passed by each day, it seems.
"what this snippet shows us is that there were two men whose ashes might, quite probably, have been brought back to 5A."
You are speculating that two men who had died were cremated, and that ashes or other belongings were then transported to Portugal.  If you have no evidence of this, it pure speculation, nothing more.

"Tasmin Milburn Silence is a clear thinking, observant and intelligent girl."
You are speculating that a 6 year old child has an accurate memory when aged 12, and on her personal characteristics.  That is pure speculation, nothing more.

The Cutting Edge documentary has some interesting things in it which are relevant to the case.  It also has several unsupported claims, and some things which are contrary to witness statements.  In the depiction of the Smith sighting, the entire group of 9 are in one blob.  The 3 Smith statements say otherwise.  Edgar says the man was acting unusually, including a swerve.  The 3 statements contradict this.

I wondered where Robbity got his 'proof' that Gerry switched on the light during his check.  It would appear it came from this documentary.

You appear to be asking me to provide a cite from a site that I have clearly explained expired in October 2016.  I have no intention of wasting my time on that.  The post got past the moderation team of the time (2014).

If you have any evidence that someone either died in 5A, or that belongings of deceased people (cremated or otherwise) were brought into 5A, the onus is on you to provide the evidence to support this.  In the absence of such evidence, you are merely speculating.
What's up, old man?

Offline Brietta

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #342 on: January 17, 2017, 06:42:16 PM »
"what this snippet shows us is that there were two men whose ashes might, quite probably, have been brought back to 5A."
You are speculating that two men who had died were cremated, and that ashes or other belongings were then transported to Portugal.  If you have no evidence of this, it pure speculation, nothing more.

"Tasmin Milburn Silence is a clear thinking, observant and intelligent girl."
You are speculating that a 6 year old child has an accurate memory when aged 12, and on her personal characteristics.  That is pure speculation, nothing more.

The Cutting Edge documentary has some interesting things in it which are relevant to the case.  It also has several unsupported claims, and some things which are contrary to witness statements.  In the depiction of the Smith sighting, the entire group of 9 are in one blob.  The 3 Smith statements say otherwise.  Edgar says the man was acting unusually, including a swerve.  The 3 statements contradict this.

I wondered where Robbity got his 'proof' that Gerry switched on the light during his check.  It would appear it came from this documentary.

You appear to be asking me to provide a cite from a site that I have clearly explained expired in October 2016.  I have no intention of wasting my time on that.  The post got past the moderation team of the time (2014).

If you have any evidence that someone either died in 5A, or that belongings of deceased people (cremated or otherwise) were brought into 5A, the onus is on you to provide the evidence to support this.  In the absence of such evidence, you are merely speculating.

No-one had to die in apartment 5A ~ nor was it necessary for their belongings to be returned to 5A for there to be a transference of the scent of a dead person.

It is documented that individuals only have to be in the same room as a deceased person for the transference to affect the clothing being worn.

 http://allnurses.com/general-nursing-discussion/the-smell-of-359205.html
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline G-Unit

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #343 on: January 17, 2017, 07:01:38 PM »
No-one had to die in apartment 5A ~ nor was it necessary for their belongings to be returned to 5A for there to be a transference of the scent of a dead person.

It is documented that individuals only have to be in the same room as a deceased person for the transference to affect the clothing being worn.

 http://allnurses.com/general-nursing-discussion/the-smell-of-359205.html

The patients discussed in the link were dying, not dead.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Have the dog alerts any significance?
« Reply #344 on: January 17, 2017, 07:03:46 PM »
The patients discussed in the link were dying, not dead.
Some had died also.
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.