I don't think it's me who is making assumptions. Do you know what the McCanns expected to be told? Do you know if their expectations would have been met by other police forces? Unless you have those facts you can't know if their criticism of the PJ was justified or not.
Was the Amaral investigation carried out to textbook standards? I did indeed assume there must have been Portuguese child protection units who had the expertise to conduct a competent inquiry into a missing child case.
I set out to find the responsible agencies in the belief that the Amaral team had been handed Madeleine's case by default and who might therefore not had have had a textbook for reference. Did even one person on that team have experience of working in child protection or human trafficking?
In my opinion there was plenty of experience in Portugal circa 2007 to fill the gap. For example ...
Unidade de polícia dedicada à proteção da criança em portugal 2007
www.otsh.mai.gov.pt/Noticias/Documents/Trafico%20DesHumano.pdffile:///C:/Users/User/Downloads/Trafico%20DesHumano%20(1).pdf
So why did the bosses hand Madeleine's case to a team of drug busters and thief takers? Was that fair either to them or to Madeleine?
Just for background information which I thought illuminating regarding children's rights being abused and Portuguese Supreme Court of Justice rulings is the following:
Quote
In 2007, the Council of Europe condemned Portugal for violating children's rights after the Supreme Court of Justice found some corporal punishment inflicted on young people with disabilities in a home in Setubal to be "lawful" and "acceptable".
The European Committee of Social Rights of the Council of Europe concluded that Portugal violated Article 17 of the European Social Charter, which enshrines the right of children to social, legal, and economic protection.
http://noticias.sapo.tl/portugues/lusa/artigo/22392202.htmlIn my opinion, Madeleine went missing in a country where some of those in charge of affairs didn't give thought to the type of investigative skills that a missing child case might demand and a country with a Supreme Court yet to join the rest of us in this century.
That this might have led to friction and mutual misunderstanding is, in my opinion, self evident from subsequent comment from those involved