Author Topic: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!  (Read 15262 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline faithlilly

I don't recall Alpha Investigations Group being involved in defrauding anyone.  Different story for Oakley International though who manged to pull the wool over the eyes of quite a few including perhaps Henri Exton, who may not have been paid for more than £100,000 for work he was owed for Madeleine's case.
http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/141881/Madeleine-McCann-detective-charged-with-1m-con

Did Mr Exon try to retrieve that sum from Madeleine's Fund in the full knowledge there would be no way of getting it from his employer particularly with the FBI being first in the queue.
Interesting though nonetheless and a sure vehicle for discontent I would have thought.

Which leads me back to your post ... you have omitted the cite for your claim regarding Henri Exton ... would you mind terribly if I asked you to post it up.

Oakley may have defrauded the fund. Exton was defrauded too. Further why do you think Exton ( sic) would have tried to retrieve money from the fund? Do you have any evidence on which to base your question?

Let's be clear, Exton defrauded non one and to suggest that his very critical report on the McCanns and their friends was shaped by being defrauded is not only ridiculous but I'm sure boardering on libel.

As to Exton, he is MI5’s former undercover operations chief. He was also awarded the Queen's Police Medal and is an OBE. So if we're playing your policeman is more successful than mine I think Exton knocks Edgar into a cocked hat.
« Last Edit: August 28, 2017, 10:51:23 PM by Faithlilly »
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Brietta

Oakley may have defrauded the fund. Exton was defrauded too. Further why do you think Exton ( sic) would have tried to retrieve money from the fund? Do you have any evidence on which to base your question?

Let's be clear, Exton defrauded non one and to suggest that his very critical report on the McCanns and their friends was shaped by being defrauded is not only ridiculous but I'm sure boardering on libel.

As to Exton, he is MI5’s former undercover operations chief. He was also awarded the Queen's Police Medal and is an OBE. So if we're playing your policeman is more successful than mine I think Exton knocks Edgar into a cocked hat.

The Sunday Times libelled the McCanns and were forced to pay substantial damages and issue an apology as a result.

Can you produce evidence in support of your allegation: Henri Exton's "very critical report on the McCanns and their friends"?

One of the libels admitted by the Sunday Times rather refutes there is any substance whatsoever in your claim which makes it not bordering on libel but is an actual libel if you cannot do so.

I await your cite with interest ... in the interim, here is mine.

Quote
As the newspaper now accepts, there is no question of the McCanns having
sought to suppress any evidence; indeed all of the material collated by the
private investigators had been provided to the relevant Portuguese and
Leicestershire police four years earlier. The private investigators' report
(including the e-fits) was also provided to the Metropolitan Police in 2011 shortly
after it commenced its review into Madeleine's disappearance.

http://www.carter-ruck.com/images/uploads/documents/McCann-Press_Release-03102014.PDF


By the way ... I stopped playing playground games along the lines of: "playing your policeman is more successful than mine" when I became an adult.  I recommend the experience to you.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline faithlilly

The Sunday Times libelled the McCanns and were forced to pay substantial damages and issue an apology as a result.

Can you produce evidence in support of your allegation: Henri Exton's "very critical report on the McCanns and their friends"?

One of the libels admitted by the Sunday Times rather refutes there is any substance whatsoever in your claim which makes it not bordering on libel but is an actual libel if you cannot do so.

I await your cite with interest ... in the interim, here is mine.

Quote
As the newspaper now accepts, there is no question of the McCanns having
sought to suppress any evidence; indeed all of the material collated by the
private investigators had been provided to the relevant Portuguese and
Leicestershire police four years earlier. The private investigators' report
(including the e-fits) was also provided to the Metropolitan Police in 2011 shortly
after it commenced its review into Madeleine's disappearance.

http://www.carter-ruck.com/images/uploads/documents/McCann-Press_Release-03102014.PDF


By the way ... I stopped playing playground games along the lines of: "playing your policeman is more successful than mine" when I became an adult.  I recommend the experience to you.

Not really sure why you have provided a cite. There is no argument that the Times paid damages to the McCanns for an article which later turned out to be partially untrue. Nowhere, however, within the text of the apology printed in the paper does it say that the reporter's description of the report was false. Below is the apology.

"In articles dated October 23 ("Madeleine clues hidden for 5 years" and "Investigators had E-Fits five years ago", News) we referred to efits which were included in a report prepared by private investigators for the McCanns and the Fund in 2008. We accept that the articles may have been understood to suggest that the McCanns had withheld information from the authorities. This was not the case. We now understand and accept that the efits had been provided to the Portuguese and Leicestershire police by October 2009. We also understand that a copy of the final report including the efits was passed to the Metropolitan police in August 2011, shortly after it commenced its review. We apologise for the distress caused."

As you will see the aology makes no mention of retracting the claim by a 'source close to the fund' that the report by Exton was ' “hypercritical of the people involved” and “would have been completely distracting” if it became public'. It also makes no mention of retracting the claim that Tanner's earlier sighting was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence or that there was questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

I know it has been the supporter's habit to cherry pick the apology issued by the Times but the apology, as the above shows, was issued with regard to the allegations of hidden evidence and not the nature of Exton's report.
« Last Edit: August 29, 2017, 11:06:56 AM by Faithlilly »
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline G-Unit

Not really sure why you have provided a cite. There is no argument that the Times paid damages to the McCanns for an article which later turned out to be partially untrue. Nowhere, however, within the text of the apology printed in the paper does it say that the reporters description of the report was false. Below is the apology.

"In articles dated October 23 ("Madeleine clues hidden for 5 years" and "Investigators had E-Fits five years ago", News) we referred to efits which were included in a report prepared by private investigators for the McCanns and the Fund in 2008. We accept that the articles may have been understood to suggest that the McCanns had withheld information from the authorities. This was not the case. We now understand and accept that the efits had been provided to the Portuguese and Leicestershire police by October 2009. We also understand that a copy of the final report including the efits was passed to the Metropolitan police in August 2011, shortly after it commenced its review. We apologise for the distress caused."

As you will see the aology makes no mention of retracting the claim by a source close to the fund that the report by Exton was ' “hypercritical of the people involved” and “would have been completely distracting” if it became public'. It also makes no mention of retracting the claim that Tanner's earlier sighting was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence or that there was questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

I know it has been the supporters habit to cherry pick the apology issued by the Times but the apology, as the above shows, was issued with regard to the allegations of hidden evidence and not the nature of Exton's report.

Exton confirmed last week that the fund had silenced his investigators for years after they handed over their controversial findings. He said: “A letter came from their lawyers binding us to the confidentiality of the report.”

He claimed the legal threat had prevented him from handing over the report to Scotland Yard’s fresh investigation, until detectives had obtained written permission from the fund.
https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t8322-wow-a-must-read-madeleine-clues-hidden-for-five-years-sunday-times-full-article-now-on-page-1

It seems the e-fits were handed over to the PJ and LP in 2009, but there's no mention of the report being handed over until 2011. Was it handed over by Exton rather than by the McCanns? I can't think why SY would ask him for it if they already had it.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline faithlilly

Exton confirmed last week that the fund had silenced his investigators for years after they handed over their controversial findings. He said: “A letter came from their lawyers binding us to the confidentiality of the report.”

He claimed the legal threat had prevented him from handing over the report to Scotland Yard’s fresh investigation, until detectives had obtained written permission from the fund.
https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t8322-wow-a-must-read-madeleine-clues-hidden-for-five-years-sunday-times-full-article-now-on-page-1

It seems the e-fits were handed over to the PJ and LP in 2009, but there's no mention of the report being handed over until 2011. Was it handed over by Exton rather than by the McCanns? I can't think why SY would ask him for it if they already had it.

So it would appear the report lay gathering dust for 3 years and even then it was not given over willingly.

I wonder how that played with OG ?
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Benice

Not really sure why you have provided a cite. There is no argument that the Times paid damages to the McCanns for an article which later turned out to be partially untrue. Nowhere, however, within the text of the apology printed in the paper does it say that the reporter's description of the report was false. Below is the apology.

"In articles dated October 23 ("Madeleine clues hidden for 5 years" and "Investigators had E-Fits five years ago", News) we referred to efits which were included in a report prepared by private investigators for the McCanns and the Fund in 2008. We accept that the articles may have been understood to suggest that the McCanns had withheld information from the authorities. This was not the case. We now understand and accept that the efits had been provided to the Portuguese and Leicestershire police by October 2009. We also understand that a copy of the final report including the efits was passed to the Metropolitan police in August 2011, shortly after it commenced its review. We apologise for the distress caused."

As you will see the aology makes no mention of retracting the claim by a 'source close to the fund' that the report by Exton was ' “hypercritical of the people involved” and “would have been completely distracting” if it became public'. It also makes no mention of retracting the claim that Tanner's earlier sighting was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence or that there was questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

I know it has been the supporter's habit to cherry pick the apology issued by the Times but the apology, as the above shows, was issued with regard to the allegations of hidden evidence and not the nature of Exton's report.

Firstly, I am always very sceptical about anything claimed by 'a source' close to anyone or anything.

However, you seem to be assuming that it is the McCanns and their friends who were 'hypercriticised'.  You could be right, but unless we know for definite who ''the people involved'' are - it could refer to a number of people  - from the PJ to the UK police and all the other 'agencies'  in between who got involved.   IIRC there was criticism (with hindsight)  that the input of so many people turned out  to be less than helpful to the case in some people's opinion.

On the subject of cherry picking:  this was the same Times article where is was also announced that Martin Smith had changed his mind and no longer believed it was Gerry that he saw.    IIRC sceptics were not so keen to accept that the Times had got that right as they were to believe that the report had been withheld by the McCanns for 'sinister' reasons.   
AIMHO

The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline G-Unit

So it would appear the report lay gathering dust for 3 years and even then it was not given over willingly.

I wonder how that played with OG ?

Why did OG then sit on the information themselves until the Crimewatch programme in October 2013? The review stage ended before that;

the review became a full investigation in July 2012.
http://news.met.police.uk/news/update-on-the-investigation-into-the-disappearance-of-madeleine-mccann-135459
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline jassi

Perhaps " Top Cop " Redwood didn't appreciate the significance for a year or two.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline faithlilly

Firstly, I am always very sceptical about anything claimed by 'a source' close to anyone or anything.

However, you seem to be assuming that it is the McCanns and their friends who were 'hypercriticised'.  You could be right, but unless we know for definite who ''the people involved'' are - it could refer to a number of people  - from the PJ to the UK police and all the other 'agencies'  in between who got involved.   IIRC there was criticism (with hindsight)  that the input of so many people turned out  to be less than helpful to the case in some people's opinion.

On the subject of cherry picking:  this was the same Times article where is was also announced that Martin Smith had changed his mind and no longer believed it was Gerry that he saw.    IIRC sceptics were not so keen to accept that the Times had got that right as they were to believe that the report had been withheld by the McCanns for 'sinister' reasons.   
AIMHO

And the 'anomalies' ?
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline G-Unit

Firstly, I am always very sceptical about anything claimed by 'a source' close to anyone or anything.

However, you seem to be assuming that it is the McCanns and their friends who were 'hypercriticised'.  You could be right, but unless we know for definite who ''the people involved'' are - it could refer to a number of people  - from the PJ to the UK police and all the other 'agencies'  in between who got involved.   IIRC there was criticism (with hindsight)  that the input of so many people turned out  to be less than helpful to the case in some people's opinion.

On the subject of cherry picking:  this was the same Times article where is was also announced that Martin Smith had changed his mind and no longer believed it was Gerry that he saw.    IIRC sceptics were not so keen to accept that the Times had got that right as they were to believe that the report had been withheld by the McCanns for 'sinister' reasons.   
AIMHO

This is how the Times described the report, which they claim to have read;

Their report, seen by The Sunday Times, focused on a sighting by an Irish family of a man carrying a child at about 10pm on May 3, 2007, when Madeleine went missing.

An earlier sighting by one of the McCanns’ friends was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence. The report also raised questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

As well as questioning parts of the McCanns’ evidence, it contained sensitive information about Madeleine’s sleeping patterns and raised the highly sensitive possibility that she could have died in an accident after leaving the apartment herself from one of two unsecured doors.
https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t8322-wow-a-must-read-madeleine-clues-hidden-for-five-years-sunday-times-full-article-now-on-page-1

They have no direct quote from Martin Smith.


Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Brietta

Not really sure why you have provided a cite. There is no argument that the Times paid damages to the McCanns for an article which later turned out to be partially untrue. Nowhere, however, within the text of the apology printed in the paper does it say that the reporter's description of the report was false. Below is the apology.

"In articles dated October 23 ("Madeleine clues hidden for 5 years" and "Investigators had E-Fits five years ago", News) we referred to efits which were included in a report prepared by private investigators for the McCanns and the Fund in 2008. We accept that the articles may have been understood to suggest that the McCanns had withheld information from the authorities. This was not the case. We now understand and accept that the efits had been provided to the Portuguese and Leicestershire police by October 2009. We also understand that a copy of the final report including the efits was passed to the Metropolitan police in August 2011, shortly after it commenced its review. We apologise for the distress caused."

As you will see the aology makes no mention of retracting the claim by a 'source close to the fund' that the report by Exton was ' “hypercritical of the people involved” and “would have been completely distracting” if it became public'. It also makes no mention of retracting the claim that Tanner's earlier sighting was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence or that there was questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

I know it has been the supporter's habit to cherry pick the apology issued by the Times but the apology, as the above shows, was issued with regard to the allegations of hidden evidence and not the nature of Exton's report.

It is quite simple ... as a direct result of the newspaper article to which you refer ... and the shameful conduct of the newspaper in refusal to interact with the McCanns ... they were forced to seek the redress of the law.

The Sunday Times admitted libel.

Quote
The Sunday Times' allegations were completely false. As the newspaper
now accepts, there is no question of the McCanns having sought to
suppress any evidence
; indeed all of the material collated by the private
investigators had been provided
to the relevant Portuguese and
Leicestershire police four years earlier. The private investigators' report
(including the e-fits) was also provided to the Metropolitan Police in 2011
shortly after the Met commenced its review into Madeleine's
disappearance.  Carter Ruck Solicitors
https://www.carter-ruck.com/images/uploads/documents/McCann-Press_Release-03102014.PDF

Therefore you are asserting that the information in the article which was proved to be wrong and therefore libel ... which the libel court agreed was libel ... which the offender agreed was libel ... is still fine to be bandied about as fact.

One simply cannot challenge that sort of mentality.

"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline faithlilly

It is quite simple ... as a direct result of the newspaper article to which you refer ... and the shameful conduct of the newspaper in refusal to interact with the McCanns ... they were forced to seek the redress of the law.

The Sunday Times admitted libel.

Quote
The Sunday Times' allegations were completely false. As the newspaper
now accepts, there is no question of the McCanns having sought to
suppress any evidence
; indeed all of the material collated by the private
investigators had been provided
to the relevant Portuguese and
Leicestershire police four years earlier. The private investigators' report
(including the e-fits) was also provided to the Metropolitan Police in 2011
shortly after the Met commenced its review into Madeleine's
disappearance.  Carter Ruck Solicitors
https://www.carter-ruck.com/images/uploads/documents/McCann-Press_Release-03102014.PDF

Therefore you are asserting that the information in the article which was proved to be wrong and therefore libel ... which the libel court agreed was libel ... which the offender agreed was libel ... is still fine to be bandied about as fact.

One simply cannot challenge that sort of mentality.

I have already posted the apology issued by the Times, detailing what the apology was for. At no time did they apologise for anything they claimed was contained in Exton's report.

Of course if you are claiming otherwise I am sure you will be able to supply a cite.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Benice

And the 'anomalies' ?

I would expect there to be anomalies even if only 2 people were involved  - let alone 9.     Memories are notoriously fallible and different people have vastly different perceptions of time, distance etc. and also different levels of the power of recall.      It would have been highly suspicious if there had been no anomalies or inconsistencies as that would strongly suggest collusion IMO.

There are some major anomalies in many of the statements made by witnesses outside of the group - especially with regard to times.   No-one has claimed that this is proof that some of them must be lying.

IMO
The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline Benice

This is how the Times described the report, which they claim to have read;

Their report, seen by The Sunday Times, focused on a sighting by an Irish family of a man carrying a child at about 10pm on May 3, 2007, when Madeleine went missing.

An earlier sighting by one of the McCanns’ friends was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence. The report also raised questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

As well as questioning parts of the McCanns’ evidence, it contained sensitive information about Madeleine’s sleeping patterns and raised the highly sensitive possibility that she could have died in an accident after leaving the apartment herself from one of two unsecured doors.
https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t8322-wow-a-must-read-madeleine-clues-hidden-for-five-years-sunday-times-full-article-now-on-page-1

They have no direct quote from Martin Smith.

They also received no complaint or demand for a retraction from Martin Smith - otherwise we would have seen it in the form of an apology etc. 

Martin Smith was quick to threaten legal action against newspapers who misrepresented him.   This 'claim'' made by the Times could not have been more momentous if it tried as it was a complete turnaround from his previous stance.

I do not believe for a second that Martin Smith would have allowed such a massive lie to be printed about him - if it was indeed a complete fabrication.  The fact that no apology or retraction was ever forthcoming says it all AFAIAC.

IMHO


The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline slartibartfast

It is quite simple ... as a direct result of the newspaper article to which you refer ... and the shameful conduct of the newspaper in refusal to interact with the McCanns ... they were forced to seek the redress of the law.

The Sunday Times admitted libel.

Quote
The Sunday Times' allegations were completely false. As the newspaper
now accepts, there is no question of the McCanns having sought to
suppress any evidence
; indeed all of the material collated by the private
investigators had been provided
to the relevant Portuguese and
Leicestershire police four years earlier. The private investigators' report
(including the e-fits) was also provided to the Metropolitan Police in 2011
shortly after the Met commenced its review into Madeleine's
disappearance.  Carter Ruck Solicitors
https://www.carter-ruck.com/images/uploads/documents/McCann-Press_Release-03102014.PDF

Therefore you are asserting that the information in the article which was proved to be wrong and therefore libel ... which the libel court agreed was libel ... which the offender agreed was libel ... is still fine to be bandied about as fact.

One simply cannot challenge that sort of mentality.

I would expect the paper to publish the least apology possible the the lawyers couldn't dispute and the libel lawyers to publish what they would have liked the paper to say.
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.