I think you'd need to ask the Met; they seemed to take those e fits seriously. Surely a properly trained professional police force wouldn't use e fits if they weren't properly produced?
Those efits were the only other things the Met had from the witnesses in the Smith family besides their statements. To ask the witnesses to reproduce their memories more than a couple of years later would have resulted in unreliable efits.
After almost ruling out Tannerman, the only other unidentified person walking in Luz & carrying a child at the crucial time around the discovery of Madeleine's disappearance was Smithman. Had I been a detective on the case, finding out who he was would have been my number one priority. However the PJ seemed to have lost interest as soon as the Smiths all said they wouldn't recognise him again. Would that have been because he had been ruled out as the arguido they were investigating at the time?
It was all so clever. For as long as Smithman remained unidentified, the similarly-dressed Tannerman, if he was ever positively identified, would always have a get-out-of-jail-free card. No-one could ever prove that Smithman didn't exist - only that he did through identification. The Smith family broke no laws because they didn't produce efits for either police force - it was the Met's decision to use them.
All my own opinion