What did Kate McCann really see in the Children's Bedroom

[barrier]

A reconstruction may have enabled a better understanding of movement and interactions that night, rather than proving anything.

Might have eliminated some things quicker though.

[Vertigo Swirl]

A reconstruction may have enabled a better understanding of movement and interactions that night, rather than proving anything.

But whose version of events would they have followed?

[Brietta]

Might have eliminated some things quicker though.

What a great pity it is that the PJ didn't think to arrange one sooner?

[jassi]

But whose version of events would they have followed?

That would depend on who participated. As a last resort, the early statements of the group would have to do.

[jassi]

What a great pity it is that the PJ didn't think to arrange one sooner?

Indeed it is a great pity for all concerned.

[barrier]

Indeed it is a great pity for all concerned.

Probably would have saved a bit of landscaping.

[Snowgirl]

A distinct possibility imo.

So you think Madeleine could have tidied her bed before getting out through the described as heavy door ,down the steps  opening and closing behind her ......thoughtful child ..... the gate ,despite her mother saying she would not have left the apt. .....this contradicting her telling Fiona that they’d left a door open so Madeleine could come to find them if she awoke distressed again ?

[barrier]

So you think Madeleine could have tidied her bed before getting out through the described as heavy door ,down the steps  opening and closing behind her ......thoughtful child ..... the gate ,despite her mother saying she would not have left the apt. .....this contradicting her telling Fiona that they’d left a door open so Madeleine could come to find them if she awoke distressed again ?

Its a possibility is what I wrote,not claimed.

[Robittybob1]

Prince William tied a ladder to Harry’s car, that’s a prank.  Removing a sleeping child from her bed only for her to disappear forever can hardly be defined as a prank, not by any normal definition of the word.

I have not determined the nature of the prank yet both you and Brietta seem to suggest it involved removing a sleeping child.  I have not said anything like that.
"Prince William tied a ladder to Harry’s car, that’s a prank" but if that ladder had killed someone as Harry and Meghan drove away would it still be a prank?

[Vertigo Swirl]

That would depend on who participated. As a last resort, the early statements of the group would have to do.

But I thought they all differed wildly, so which one to go with?

[Vertigo Swirl]

I have not determined the nature of the prank yet both you and Brietta seem to suggest it involved removing a sleeping child.  I have not said anything like that.
"Prince William tied a ladder to Harry’s car, that’s a prank" but if that ladder had killed someone as Harry and Meghan drove away would it still be a prank?

Perhaps you could elucidate on the nature of the so-called prank then.  Give us a for instance.

[Robittybob1]

I think Robbity’s point was a reconstitution would have proved nothing either.

But whatever mistakes were noted would be used against them never the less.

[Robittybob1]

So you think Madeleine could have tidied her bed before getting out through the described as heavy door ,down the steps  opening and closing behind her ......thoughtful child ..... the gate ,despite her mother saying she would not have left the apt. .....this contradicting her telling Fiona that they’d left a door open so Madeleine could come to find them if she awoke distressed again ?

In my theory Madeleine left via the front door which appears easy to open, and no gates to contend with.

[jassi]

But I thought they all differed wildly, so which one to go with?

That's why it would have been better if the group had been there, as they would have been able to correct anomalies in statements, or alternatively concede particular errors.

If statements are so wildly different, is it any surprise that police came to certain conclusions ?

[Robittybob1]

Perhaps you could elucidate on the nature of the so-called prank then.  Give us a for instance.

Put it this way I think it had something to do with the child being carried by Totman.  (And I'm not saying that child was Madeleine, for she left by the front door IMO.)

Someone had to carry the ladder to the reception that was tied to Harry's car.  I don't think William went and fetched it IMO.  There would be helpers.